11 Best Key Lock Boxes (and Which Ones Jam)

The short version

01
Best key lock box: ABUS KeyGarage 787. A metal wall box with room for up to 20 keys.
4.8/5Check price →
02
Best push-button key safe: Kidde AccessPoint. Buttons instead of dials, fixed to the wall.
4.7/5Check price →
03
Best wall dial box: Fayleeko. A small zinc and steel box at a low price.
4.6/5Check price →
04
Best for fobs and cards: RUDY RUN. A roomy wall box for keys, fobs and cards.
4.7/5Check price →
05
Best car key vault: HitchSafe HS7000. Hides your car key in the trailer hitch.
4.5/5Check price →
06
Best for night use: Master Lock 5424. Dials that light up when you open the cover.
4.6/5Check price →
07
Best budget box: Puroma Key Lock Box. Wall or doorknob, the lowest-cost pick.
4.6/5Check price →
08
Best realtor lock box: Kingsley Guard-a-Key. Hangs on a knob, a gas pipe or a railing.
4.6/5Check price →
09
Best portable lock box: Iron Lock U-Shackle. Wraps around knobs, handles and gates.
4.5/5Check price →
10
Best smart lock box: igloohome Keybox 3. Guest codes from your phone, synced with Airbnb.
3.9/5Check price →
11
Best Bluetooth wall box: Master Lock 5441. Keypad and app, mounted on the wall.
4.1/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 11

Best key lock box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: Up to 20 keys or 14 cards

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
4-digit dials under a sliding cover
Capacity
4.9
Up to 20 keys or 14 cards; 12–16 keys in practice
Security
4.4
Metal body, die-cast zinc cover, screws to a wall
Value
4.6
Low price; owners rate it highly

Here’s the deal: a bigger box from ABUS, a German lock maker since 1924. It’s 4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 inches, holds up to 20 keys or 14 cards, and has a removable hook to keep keys in order. The housing is metal with a die-cast zinc cover, and a sliding cover keeps dirt off the dials. You set your own 4-digit code. It suits homes, rentals and offices that hand out several keys, and owners rate it highly.

The catch: 20 keys is a tight squeeze; Amazon’s answer puts the realistic number nearer 12–16. The sliding cover keeps out dirt, not driving rain, so mount it under an eave or porch roof. One owner says the plastic key hook feels cheap.

Why we like it

✓ Holds up to 20 keys or 14 cards
✓ Metal body, zinc cover
✓ ABUS lock maker

Watch out for

✗ 20 keys is a squeeze
✗ Cover isn’t weather tight
✗ Plastic key hook

Size

4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

Not listed

Holds

Up to 20 keys or 14 cards

Build

Metal, die-cast zinc cover

Skip it if you open it in the dark: see pick 6.

Test it twice before your spare key goes in.

Dial lock boxes can jam. Owners of the most popular boxes here say a few locked shut for good and had to be cut off. Set your code, open and close it several times, and keep a second spare somewhere else. In winter, ice in the dials can freeze them; warm water frees them. And change the code whenever a guest or worker no longer needs it. A lock box keeps casual hands out; it isn’t a safe, so see our best small safes for anything valuable.

Pick 2 of 11

Best push-button key safe

Lock: Push buttons

Holds: Up to 5 keys

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.6
Push buttons, no dials to freeze; the code is fiddly to change
Capacity
4.3
Up to 5 keys
Security
4.6
Fixed to a wall for good; owners rate the durability very highly
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners praise the value

Here’s the deal: a key safe with buttons instead of dials, fixed to a wall for good. It’s 7 inches wide, 2.7 tall and 3.2 deep, with a titanium-gray finish and mounting hardware. You press your code on 10 push buttons, with over 1,000 combinations, and it holds up to 5 keys. Owners rate the durability very highly, and many keep one so family or paramedics can get in to an elderly parent. One owner says it works at 20 below zero in a Minnesota winter.

The catch: setting the code. You change it with small dials inside, and some owners find them stiff or need a video to work it out. Owners are split on ease of use, and the spec says it isn’t water resistant, so a rubber cover helps in rain.

Why we like it

✓ Push buttons, no dials to freeze
✓ Very durable, owners say
✓ Works in deep cold, one owner says

Watch out for

✗ Code is fiddly to change
✗ Ease of use is split
✗ Not water resistant, spec says

Size

7 × 2.7 × 3.2 in

Lock

Push buttons, 1,000+ codes

Inside

Not listed

Holds

Up to 5 keys

Build

Metal, titanium-gray finish

Skip it if you need room for lots of keys: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 11

Best wall dial box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: Up to 5 house keys

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.3
4-digit dials; owners split on how easy it is to open
Capacity
4.3
Up to 5 house keys shorter than 3.35 in
Security
4.4
Zinc alloy and stainless steel, screws to a wall; owners praise the security
Value
4.7
Low price; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: a small wall box in the classic style, at a low price. It’s 4.7 inches tall, 3.54 wide and 1.6 deep, made of zinc alloy and stainless steel, with an ABS shell against rain, dust and sun. You set your own 4-digit code, with 10,000 choices. It holds up to 5 house keys shorter than 3.35 inches, or a car key or access cards, and 4 screws and wall plugs come with it. Owners say it’s easy to install, works well and is good value, and they rate its security.

The catch: write your code down. The listing warns there’s no way to get it back if you forget it. Owners are split on how easy it is to open, some say it’s smaller than they expected, and a few say it broke within a month.

Why we like it

✓ Easy to install, owners say
✓ Zinc alloy and stainless steel
✓ Low price

Watch out for

✗ Hard to open, some say
✗ No way to recover the code
✗ Smaller than expected, some say

Size

4.7 × 3.54 × 1.6 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

Not listed

Holds

Up to 5 keys under 3.35 in

Build

Zinc alloy, stainless steel, 7.68 oz

Skip it if you want buttons instead of dials: see pick 2.

Pick 4 of 11

Best for fobs and cards

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: 5+ keys, fobs, cards

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.3
4-digit dials, easy to set; some owners say it wouldn’t open
Capacity
4.4
At least 5 keys plus fobs, cards or access tags
Security
4.4
Zinc alloy and stainless steel, 4 screws into brick or concrete; owners praise the sturdiness
Value
4.6
Low price; owners rate the quality very highly

Here’s the deal: a roomy wall box from one of the most-rated lock box listings on Amazon. It’s about 5 × 4 × 2 inches and a pound of zinc alloy and stainless steel, and it holds at least 5 house keys plus key fobs, credit cards or access tags. You set a 4-digit code from 10,000 combinations. It comes with 4 screws and 4 wall plugs for brick or concrete. Thousands of owners rate the quality, say it was easy to install with clear instructions, and find the code simple to set and reset.

The catch: reliability is the one topic where complaints beat praise: some owners say the box wouldn’t open at all. Test the code a few times with the door open before you leave a key inside. It screws to a wall, so it won’t hang on a doorknob.

Why we like it

✓ Room for fobs and cards
✓ Easy to install, owners say
✓ Code simple to reset

Watch out for

✗ Some say it wouldn’t open
✗ Wall only, no shackle
✗ Inside size not listed

Size

5 × 4 × 2 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

Not listed

Holds

5+ keys, fobs, cards

Build

Zinc alloy and stainless steel, 1 lb

Skip it if you want to hang it on a doorknob: see pick 9.

Pick 5 of 11

Best car key vault

Lock: 4-digit code

Holds: A key fob + cards

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
4-digit code, fits with no tools; fit depends on your hitch
Capacity
4.3
A key fob, cash and up to 2 cards
Security
4.6
Solid steel, hidden in the trailer hitch
Value
4.3
Upper-priced for a lock box

Here’s the deal: a hidden drawer that slides into your vehicle’s 2-inch trailer hitch. It’s solid steel with a rust-resistant coating, locks with a 4-digit code, and two bolt bars hold it in the receiver; a rubber hitch cover hides it. It installs in seconds with no tools. It holds your keys, cash and up to 2 cards while you swim, hike or hand the car to a Turo guest. Owners call it well built, easy to install and a great way to stash a key. If you also leave a handgun in the vehicle, see our best car gun safes.

The catch: fit. Owners are split; it needs a standard 2-inch receiver, and all Toyota pickups need a longer bolt set sold separately. Some large fobs barely fit, and a keyless-entry fob needs a signal-blocking bag (sold separately) so the car can’t be opened while it’s inside.

Why we like it

✓ Hidden in the trailer hitch
✓ Steel, no tools to fit
✓ Holds a fob, cash and cards

Watch out for

✗ Fit depends on your hitch
✗ Toyota needs extra bolts
✗ Fob needs a signal-blocking bag

Size

Fits 2 in receivers

Lock

4-digit code

Inside

1.25 × 3.56 × 1.75 in (Amazon’s answer)

Holds

A key fob + cards

Build

Steel, rust-resistant, rubber cover

Skip it if you don’t have a trailer hitch: see pick 9.

Pick 6 of 11

Best for night use

Lock: Light-up dials

Holds: Up to 6 keys

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.6
Dials light up at night; jams with heavy use, some say
Capacity
4.4
Up to 6 keys or a fob
Security
4.3
Metal body, removable shackle
Value
4.3
Pricey for a dial box

Here’s the deal: a portable box whose dials light up when you open the cover, so you can read them at night. It’s 7 inches tall, 2.875 wide and 2.06 deep, with a 4.19 × 2.38 × 1 inch space inside for up to 6 keys, a key fob or access cards. A removable shackle fits most round doorknobs, and a weather cover protects the dials. The light runs on a CR2032 coin battery. Owners love the lighting and rate the quality and durability.

The catch: owners who open it a lot report jamming; one who owns ten says two had to be cut off. Master Lock doesn’t say how long the battery lasts, and one owner’s light stopped working within a year.

Why we like it

✓ Dials light up at night
✓ Room for 6 keys or a fob
✓ Doorknob or fixed spot

Watch out for

✗ Jams with heavy use, owners say
✗ Battery life not listed
✗ Light can fail

Size

7 × 2.875 × 2.06 in

Lock

Light-up 4-digit dials

Inside

4.19 × 2.38 × 1 in

Holds

Up to 6 keys or a fob

Build

Metal body, CR2032 light

Skip it if you open it many times a day: see pick 2.

Pick 7 of 11

Best budget box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: 4–5 loose keys

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.1
Hard to open, many owners say
Capacity
4.3
4–5 loose keys; wall or doorknob
Security
4.3
Alloy and steel; owners rate the security
Value
4.7
Lowest price here; owners rate the quality

Here’s the deal: a low-cost box that goes on the wall or on a doorknob. It’s 5.75 inches tall, 3.07 wide and 1.54 deep, in aluminum-zinc alloy and steel, and weighs 9.6 ounces. A removable shackle hangs it on a knob, or 4 screws and wall plugs fix it to a wall. The code comes set to 0-0-0-0, and you set your own in four steps, with 10,000 possible codes. Amazon’s answer says 4–5 loose house keys fit. Owners rate the quality and value for money, and it’s the lowest-cost pick.

The catch: opening it. Owners often find it hard to open; some say it stopped opening with the right code after a few uses, and a few had to have it cut off. Chunky modern car keys won’t fit inside.

Why we like it

✓ Wall or doorknob
✓ 10,000 codes
✓ Lowest-cost pick

Watch out for

✗ Hard to open, many owners say
✗ Some jam for good
✗ Car key fobs won’t fit

Size

5.75 × 3.07 × 1.54 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

Not listed

Holds

4–5 loose keys (Amazon’s answer)

Build

Aluminum-zinc alloy and steel, 9.6 oz

Skip it if you’ll open it every day: see pick 2.

Pick 8 of 11

Best realtor lock box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: 2–4 keys

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.3
Dials; owners split on ease of use; old code needed to change it
Capacity
4.1
2–4 keys, about 10 cu in
Security
4.4
Owners praise the lock quality; hangs or mounts
Value
4.6
Low price; owners praise how well it works

Here’s the deal: a slim hanging box agents use for showings. It’s 5.3 inches tall, 2.6 wide and 1 deep, and weighs 9.44 ounces. The vinyl-covered shackle goes around a doorknob, and owners also hang it on gas meter pipes, hose bibs and railings; it can mount on a wall too. It has a 4-digit code with 10,000 combinations that you can change as often as you like. Amazon’s answer says 2–4 keys fit comfortably, and a plain car key fits. Owners praise how well it works, its durability and the room inside.

The catch: owners are split on ease of use, and some find the dials hard to work. You need the old code to set a new one, and modern smart car fobs are too big.

Why we like it

✓ Hangs on knobs, pipes, railings
✓ Slim, weather-resistant finish
✓ Change the code anytime

Watch out for

✗ Dials can be hard to use
✗ Need the old code to change it
✗ No room for smart fobs

Size

5.3 × 2.6 × 1 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

About 10 cu in

Holds

2–4 keys (Amazon’s answer)

Build

Metal, vinyl shackle, 9.44 oz

Skip it if you want it fixed to the wall: see pick 3.

Pick 9 of 11

Best portable lock box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: A key ring + a fob

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.1
4 dials under a cover; owners mostly complain about the latch
Capacity
4.3
A 5-key ring plus a fob; 3.25 × 3 × 1.4 in inside
Security
4.3
Zinc alloy and aluminum, stainless U-shackle; not burglary rated
Value
4.6
Low price; owners praise the quality and value

Here’s the deal: a doorknob box with a shackle that swings fully open, so it wraps around a door handle, gate rail, fence post or padlock hasp instead of only a round knob. It’s 4.53 × 2.5 × 4.5 inches and 1.2 pounds of zinc alloy and aluminum in a soft shell that won’t mar doors. Inside are hooks on the back wall that keep keys apart and a tray that catches them when the door opens. The listing is honest about the room: 3.25 × 3 × 1.4 inches, enough for a 5-key ring and one car fob. A cover keeps rain off the dials, and screws come in the box if you’d rather mount it flat. Owners praise the quality, how it holds up outdoors and the value.

The catch: the latch is the top complaint: some owners say they couldn’t get it open. Set the code and test it three times with the door open, as the listing says. Owners are split on how well it keeps water out. It’s a key box, not a safe: Iron Lock says so itself.

Why we like it

✓ Shackle fits handles and gates
✓ Hooks and a catch tray inside
✓ Honest inside size

Watch out for

✗ Latch complaints
✗ Split on water resistance
✗ Not burglary rated

Size

4.53 × 2.5 × 4.5 in

Lock

4-digit dials, resettable

Inside

3.25 × 3 × 1.4 in

Holds

5-key ring + 1 fob

Build

Zinc alloy and aluminum, 1.2 lb

Skip it if you need it to open every time: see pick 8.

Pick 10 of 11

Best smart lock box

Lock: Keypad + Bluetooth

Holds: House keys

SafesGeek score
3.9/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.7
App guest codes synced with Airbnb; works without Wi-Fi
Capacity
4.1
House keys; inside size not listed
Security
4.1
Build details not listed
Value
4.1
Pricey; mixed owner ratings

Here’s the deal: a lock box you manage from your phone. It syncs with your Airbnb calendar and makes a unique code for each guest. Amazon’s answer says it doesn’t need Wi-Fi: the app makes time-limited codes from anywhere, and the box checks them offline, so you only need to be near it with Bluetooth to set it up. It runs on 4 AAA batteries, about 6–12 months by Amazon’s answer, warns you when they’re low, and a 9V battery held to the bottom contacts powers it in an emergency.

The catch: it’s a smart lock with electronics and batteries, not a simple dial box, and its ratings trail the mechanical picks. Battery life drops with heavy use, and the listing doesn’t give the inside size.

Why we like it

✓ Airbnb calendar sync
✓ Guest codes with no Wi-Fi
✓ Low-battery warning

Watch out for

✗ Batteries to change
✗ Mixed owner ratings
✗ Inside size not listed

Size

Not listed

Lock

Keypad, Bluetooth, app codes

Inside

Not listed

Holds

House keys

Build

Electronic, 4 AAA, 9V backup

Skip it if you’d rather have no batteries: see pick 1.

Pick 11 of 11

Best Bluetooth wall box

Lock: Keypad + Bluetooth

Holds: House keys

SafesGeek score
4.1/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
Keypad 4–8 digits or Bluetooth; owners split on reliability
Capacity
4.4
A wall box, 8.1 × 5.3 × 2.1 in
Security
4.3
Zinc wall box; owners complain about the locking mechanism
Value
4.0
Priciest pick; owners say it’s poor value

Here’s the deal: a wall-mounted box with a keypad and an app. Amazon’s answer says guests open it with a 4–8 digit code, no phone needed, and you can open it from the app within Bluetooth range. It doesn’t connect to Wi-Fi; you make one-time codes in the app ahead of time and send them to guests. A single CR123A battery lasts about 6–12 months, the keypad and app warn you when it’s low, and backup power gets you in if it dies. Owners say a single battery lasts a long time.

The catch: you can’t open it remotely from somewhere else, only make codes in advance. It needs a battery change once or twice a year with frequent use, and the listing doesn’t give the inside size. Owners are split on reliability and the Bluetooth connection, and more complain about the locking mechanism and the value than praise them.

Why we like it

✓ Keypad, no phone needed
✓ One-time guest codes
✓ Low-battery warnings

Watch out for

✗ No remote opening
✗ Battery to change
✗ Inside size not listed

Size

8.1 × 5.3 × 2.1 in

Lock

Keypad 4–8 digits, Bluetooth

Inside

Not listed

Holds

House keys

Build

Electronic, CR123A battery

Skip it if you’d rather have no batteries: see pick 2.

PickLockHoldsSizeInsideBuild
ABUS KeyGarage 787
Best key lock box
4.8/5
Check price
4-digit dialsUp to 20 keys or 14 cards4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 inNot listedMetal, die-cast zinc cover
Kidde AccessPoint
Best push-button key safe
4.7/5
Check price
Push buttonsUp to 5 keys7 × 2.7 × 3.2 inNot listedMetal, titanium-gray finish
Fayleeko
Best wall dial box
4.6/5
Check price
4-digit dialsUp to 5 house keys4.7 × 3.54 × 1.6 inNot listedZinc alloy, stainless steel, 7.68 oz
RUDY RUN
Best for fobs and cards
4.7/5
Check price
4-digit dials5+ keys, fobs, cards5 × 4 × 2 inNot listedZinc alloy and stainless steel, 1 lb
HitchSafe HS7000
Best car key vault
4.5/5
Check price
4-digit codeA key fob + cardsFits 2 in receivers1.25 × 3.56 × 1.75 in (Amazon’s answer)Steel, rust-resistant, rubber cover
Master Lock 5424
Best for night use
4.6/5
Check price
Light-up dialsUp to 6 keys7 × 2.875 × 2.06 in4.19 × 2.38 × 1 inMetal body, CR2032 light
Puroma Key Lock Box
Best budget box
4.6/5
Check price
4-digit dials4–5 loose keys5.75 × 3.07 × 1.54 inNot listedAluminum-zinc alloy and steel, 9.6 oz
Kingsley Guard-a-Key
Best realtor lock box
4.6/5
Check price
4-digit dials2–4 keys5.3 × 2.6 × 1 inAbout 10 cu inMetal, vinyl shackle, 9.44 oz
Iron Lock U-Shackle
Best portable lock box
4.5/5
Check price
4-digit dialsA key ring + a fob4.53 × 2.5 × 4.5 in3.25 × 3 × 1.4 inZinc alloy and aluminum, 1.2 lb
igloohome Keybox 3
Best smart lock box
3.9/5
Check price
Keypad + BluetoothHouse keysNot listedNot listedElectronic, 4 AAA, 9V backup
Master Lock 5441
Best Bluetooth wall box
4.1/5
Check price
Keypad + BluetoothHouse keys8.1 × 5.3 × 2.1 inNot listedElectronic, CR123A battery

A key lock box solves a small problem, as long as it opens when you need it. Five questions decide which one you need.

A wall box screws to the house and stays put. A portable box hangs on a doorknob, gate or pipe and moves with you, which suits realtors and short stays, but it can be cut off.

Dials are simple and cheap but can jam or freeze. Push buttons have no dials to freeze. Smart boxes let you send guests their own codes from your phone, but they need batteries.

Most boxes fit 2–5 loose keys, fewer on a ring, and modern car fobs often don’t fit. For a ring of keys or access cards, take the large box.

For family and caregivers, a fixed box with one code works. For a stream of guests or workers, a smart box with one-time codes saves changing the code each time.

Out of direct rain if you can, and out of sight from the street. Mount it into wood or masonry with the screws provided. For valuables, not keys, see our best wall safes.

One last tip: keep a second spare key somewhere else. If the box jams or freezes, you won’t be locked out twice.

Still not sure? Get the ABUS KeyGarage 787.
A metal wall box from a long-time lock maker, with a cover over the dials and room for a whole ring of keys.
Check price on Amazon →
Are key lock boxes safe?

They keep casual hands away from a spare key. A determined thief can pry or cut one off, so mount it out of sight and keep valuables in a safe; see our best small safes.

Why won’t my key lock box open?

Check the code first. Then ice or dirt in the dials, or a jammed latch, are the usual causes; warm water frees frozen dials. If it’s jammed for good, owners cut it off.

Can I keep a car key fob in a lock box?

Only in a few. Picks 4, 6 and 9 take a fob, and pick 5 holds one inside your trailer hitch. Most small boxes fit plain keys only.

Do smart lock boxes need Wi-Fi?

Not these two. They use Bluetooth and keypad codes, and the igloohome makes guest codes that work offline.

How do I change the code?

Open the box and follow the steps inside; it takes a minute on most. The Kingsley needs the old code to set a new one, and the Kidde uses small dials inside. For hidden storage, see our best hidden book safes.

Find your fit

A key lock box lets you share a key with guests, family or a contractor without being there. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A key shared without being there
→ Key lock boxes (you're here)
Wall-mount and shackle boxes with a code, so the right people get the key.
If you want
Valuables locked up
→ Small safes
Small steel safes for cash, papers and valuables.
If you want
Something hidden
→ Hidden safes
Book, outlet and can safes that look like everyday things.
If you want
It in the wall
→ Wall safes
Safes set into the wall for cash and jewelry.

How to choose a key lock box →

We looked at 262 products that came up on Amazon across 13 searches for “key lock box”, “key lock box for outside”, “realtor lock box” and “key lock box with code”, and added the best smart lock boxes from our other searches. We picked the best box for each job: wall, doorknob, realtor, push-button, large, night use, car keys and smart. We skipped the same box sold in a second mount, smart boxes that more owners complain about than praise, listings you can’t buy right now and products Amazon flags as frequently returned. To check what fits and what fails, we used owner feedback and Amazon’s answers to owners’ questions. Then we checked each listing’s specs.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 262 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these lock boxes ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.