6 Best Cash Boxes, Scored on Tray, Capacity, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: KYODOLED 1 mm Cash Box. A pop-up coin tray, 4 bill clips and a low price.
4.8/5Check price →
02
Best heavy-duty: Volcora Large Cash Box. 6.8 lb of steel and 6 keys for a team.
4.8/5Check price →
03
Best removable tray: SentrySafe CB-12. A lift-out tray and the inside size listed.
4.7/5Check price →
04
Best budget: Jssmst Medium Cash Box. The lowest price, small enough for a drawer.
4.4/5Check price →
05
Best combination lock: Goehiaul 9.84″ Cash Box. A 3-digit code and no key to lose.
4.4/5Check price →
06
Best large: Glosen Large Cash Box. The biggest box here, with deep storage under the tray.
4.5/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 6

Best overall

Steel: 1 mm

Tray: Pop-up, 5 coins

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.7
Pop-up 5-coin tray, 4 bill clips, hidden compartment behind
Capacity
4.4
11.8 × 9.45 × 3.54 in, about 0.23 cu ft by its outside size
Security
4.0*
1 mm steel, key lock, 2 keys; owners split on the lock
Value
4.7
Low price; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the classic vendor cash box, from the cash box line with the most owner feedback we found. Open the lid and a 5-compartment coin tray lifts up on its arms. Below it, four spring clips hold bills so the wind can’t take them, and a compartment behind keeps large bills, checks and receipts apart from the change. The body is 1 mm cold-rolled steel with a black powder coat, it weighs 3.8 lb, and it comes with 2 keys. Owners praise how sturdy it is and the value, like the bins for each coin and bill, and say it beats a money bag.

The catch: owners are split on the lock. About as many say it locks well as say the lid won’t stay shut unless you lock it. Like every cash box here, it has no holes or cable to fix it down, so keep it in sight.

Why we like it

✓ Pop-up coin tray and 4 bill clips
✓ 1 mm steel body
✓ Low price

Watch out for

✗ Split reviews on the lock
✗ Lid can pop open unlocked
✗ Nothing to fix it down

Size

11.8 × 9.45 × 3.54 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Tray

Pop-up, 5 coins, 4 bill clips

Weight

3.8 lb

Body

1 mm cold-rolled steel

Skip it if you’d rather not carry a key: see pick 5.

Closing up for the night? Don’t leave the cash in the box.

A cash box is for the table, not for overnight. Anyone can carry it off under one arm and pry the lid open later. Count the takings, then lock them in a safe that bolts down; see our best money safes. If staff handle cash all day, a drop slot means nobody has to open the door; see our best drop safes.

Pick 2 of 6

Best heavy-duty

Weight: 6.8 lb

Keys: 6

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.7
Pop-up 5-coin tray with a lid, 4 bill slots, room behind
Capacity
4.4
12 × 9.5 × 3.5 in, about 0.23 cu ft; the 12 liters listed can’t fit
Security
4.1*
6.8 lb, thicker steel, key lock, 6 keys; owners like the lock
Value
4.4
One of the priciest picks; owners praise the quality

Here’s the deal: the heaviest cash box here. Volcora says it’s 50% heavier and 20% thicker than a standard cash box, at 6.8 lb, with a chip-resistant powder coat. The 5-compartment coin tray has a lid, there are 4 bill slots, and the space behind them holds large bills, receipts, raffle tickets and checks. It comes with 6 keys, handy when several volunteers run the table. Owners praise the quality and durability with almost no complaints, like how organized it keeps the bills, and call the weight a plus.

The catch: it’s one of the priciest picks here, and far fewer owners have reviewed it than the big sellers. The listing says 12 liters, but the outside is 12 × 9.5 × 3.5 inches, about 6.5 liters, so the inside holds less than that. The extra weight is also more to carry from the car.

Why we like it

✓ Heaviest, thickest body here
✓ 6 keys for a team
✓ Lid on the coin tray

Watch out for

✗ One of the priciest picks
✗ 12-liter claim too big
✗ Heavier to carry

Size

12 × 9.5 × 3.5 in

Lock

Key, 6 keys

Tray

Pop-up, 5 coins with a lid, 4 bill slots

Weight

6.8 lb

Body

Steel, powder coat

Skip it if you want the lowest price: see pick 4.

Pick 3 of 6

Best removable tray

Tray: Lift-out

Inside: 11.6 × 9.75 × 2.6 in

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.4
Lift-out tray for bills, coins and receipts, room below
Capacity
4.4
11.6 × 9.75 × 2.6 in inside, about 0.17 cu ft
Security
3.8*
Steel, key lock, 2 keys; owners mostly report lock problems
Value
4.6
Mid-priced; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: a simple cash box from a big safe maker, and one of the few that lists its inside size. A flat tray lifts out to sort bills, coins and receipts, and the space below takes checks and other valuables. Outside it’s 11.75 × 9.875 × 4 inches, inside 11.625 × 9.75 × 2.625 inches, and it weighs 4 lb, with a carry handle and 2 keys. Owners say it works well at yard sales and fairs, and like the divided tray, the sturdy build and the value.

The catch: the lock. More owners report trouble with it than praise it, and some say a key broke off. The title says 0.21 cubic feet and the bullets say 0.17; the inside size works out to 0.17. The listing names no bill clips, so bills can blow around outdoors.

Why we like it

✓ Inside size listed
✓ Lift-out tray, room below
✓ Made by a safe brand

Watch out for

✗ Lock complaints beat praise
✗ No bill clips listed
✗ Capacity listed two ways

Size

11.75 × 9.875 × 4 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Tray

Lift-out, bills and coins

Weight

4 lb

Body

Steel

Skip it if you sell outdoors and want clips for the bills: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 6

Best budget

Size: 7.87 × 6.3 × 3.54 in

Tray: 5 slots

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.1
Lift-out 5-slot tray, room below
Capacity
4.0
7.87 × 6.3 × 3.54 in, about 0.1 cu ft
Security
3.8*
Steel, key lock; 1.9 lb, easy to carry off
Value
4.9
Lowest-priced pick; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: small, cheap and part of the most-reviewed cash box line we found. It’s 7.87 × 6.3 × 3.54 inches and 1.9 lb, steel with a stainless steel handle and a key lock. A lift-out 5-slot tray sorts coins and small bills, with room below. It fits in a desk drawer for office petty cash or a kid’s first stand, and Jssmst says it also works as a key box. Owners praise the quality, how well it works and the value. Jssmst sells it in other sizes too, and they share their owner reviews.

The catch: owners are split on the size. Many find it smaller than they expected, so check the inches against what you’ll put in it. The 173 cubic inches listed is its outside size. At 1.9 lb, it’s the easiest box here to walk off with.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest-priced pick
✓ Fits a desk drawer
✓ Steel with a key lock

Watch out for

✗ Smaller than many expect
✗ No bill clips
✗ Easy to carry off

Size

7.87 × 6.3 × 3.54 in

Lock

Key

Tray

Lift-out, 5 slots

Weight

1.9 lb

Body

Steel

Skip it if you run a busy sale with a lot of bills: see pick 1.

Pick 5 of 6

Best combination lock

Lock: 3-digit code

Tray: 5 coins

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.3
Lift-out 5-coin tray, room below for bills and checks
Capacity
4.1
9.84 × 7.87 × 3.54 in, about 0.16 cu ft
Security
4.0*
3-digit combination, no key to lose; owners split on the lock
Value
4.4
Low price; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: a mid-size box that opens with a 3-digit code you set yourself, so there’s no key to lose or pass around. It’s 9.84 × 7.87 × 3.54 inches and 2.4 lb, metal with a stainless steel handle. A lift-out 5-compartment coin tray sits over space for bills, checks and receipts. Owners like the size, say it does the job, and call it sturdy and easy to use.

The catch: owners are split on the lock, with as many reporting trouble as praising it, and split on the value. A 3-digit code is a privacy lock with only 1,000 possible codes. Most combination cash boxes we checked draw more lock complaints than praise; this one is split.

Why we like it

✓ No key to lose
✓ Code you set yourself
✓ Low price

Watch out for

✗ Split reviews on the lock
✗ Only 1,000 possible codes
✗ No bill clips

Size

9.84 × 7.87 × 3.54 in

Lock

3-digit combination

Tray

Lift-out, 5 coins

Weight

2.4 lb

Body

Metal

Skip it if you want room for a full day of bills: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 6

Best large

Size: 13.4 × 11.4 × 5.1 in

Body: Aluminum frame

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Tray
4.6
Removable tray, 4 coin bins, spring clips for bills, storage below
Capacity
4.7
13.4 × 11.4 × 5.1 in, about 0.45 cu ft by its outside size; the biggest box here
Security
3.8*
Aluminum frame with MDF panels, key lock, 2 keys
Value
4.1
Priciest pick; owners like how well it works

Here’s the deal: the biggest box on this page, built like a small carry case instead of a steel box. It’s 13.4 × 11.4 × 5.1 inches and 4.2 lb, with an aluminum frame, MDF panels and a carry handle. A removable tray has 4 coin compartments and spring clips that hold the bills while you carry it, and a deep space underneath takes bundles of bills, checks and receipts. It locks with a key, and it comes with 2. Owners say it works well and has room for every kind of bill.

The catch: it’s the priciest pick here, about twice the price of most boxes on this page, and far fewer owners have reviewed it than the big sellers. The panels are MDF, a wood board, not steel, so it’s easier to break into than the steel boxes. At 13.4 inches wide, it also takes more room on the table.

Why we like it

✓ Biggest box here
✓ Deep storage under the tray
✓ Spring clips hold the bills

Watch out for

✗ Priciest pick
✗ MDF panels, not steel
✗ Takes more table space

Size

13.4 × 11.4 × 5.1 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Tray

Removable, 4 coins, spring clips

Weight

4.2 lb

Body

Aluminum frame, MDF panels

Skip it if you want steel and a low price: see pick 1.

PickSteelTraySizeLockWeightBodyKeys
KYODOLED 1 mm Cash Box
Best overall
4.8/5
Check price
1 mmPop-up, 5 coins11.8 × 9.45 × 3.54 inKey, 2 keys3.8 lb1 mm cold-rolled steel–
Volcora Large Cash Box
Best heavy-duty
4.8/5
Check price
–Pop-up, 5 coins with a lid, 4 bill slots12 × 9.5 × 3.5 inKey, 6 keys6.8 lbSteel, powder coat6
SentrySafe CB-12
Best removable tray
4.7/5
Check price
–Lift-out11.75 × 9.875 × 4 inKey, 2 keys4 lbSteel–
Jssmst Medium Cash Box
Best budget
4.4/5
Check price
–5 slots7.87 × 6.3 × 3.54 inKey1.9 lbSteel–
Goehiaul 9.84″ Cash Box
Best combination lock
4.4/5
Check price
–5 coins9.84 × 7.87 × 3.54 in3-digit code2.4 lbMetal–
Glosen Large Cash Box
Best large
4.5/5
Check price
–Removable, 4 coins, spring clips13.4 × 11.4 × 5.1 inKey, 2 keys4.2 lbAluminum frame–

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

A cash box has one job: keep cash sorted and close at hand while you sell, then go home with you. Four questions decide which one.

A pop-up tray lifts up when you open the lid, so you see the coins and the bills at once; picks 1 and 2 have one, with clips or slots that hold bills in the wind. A lift-out tray (picks 3 to 5) is simpler: lift it out to reach the space below. Outdoors, bill clips matter more than anything; indoors, a lift-out tray is fine.

Most cash boxes are about 11.8 × 9.5 × 3.5 inches, roughly 0.23 cubic feet by their outside size, which is enough for a day at a market or a fundraiser. For petty cash in a drawer or a kid’s stand, a 7.87-inch box (pick 4) is plenty. Go by the outside inches: many listings call a box under 10 inches “large”, and capacity claims are often the outside size or more.

A key is quick and simple, and a box with several keys (pick 2 comes with 6) suits a team. A combination (pick 5) means no key to lose, but most combination cash boxes we checked draw more lock complaints than praise. Either way, the lock keeps honest people honest; it won’t stop a screwdriver.

Not in the cash box. Lock the takings in a safe that bolts down; see our best money safes. A business where several people handle cash may want one of our best office safes, and petty cash can live in one of our best mini safes. For the trip to the bank, use one of our best locking bags.

One last tip: many cash boxes on Amazon are the same 11.8-inch steel box under different brand names, so don’t pay more for a name alone. Compare the steel, the tray, the keys and the extras.

Still not sure? Get the KYODOLED 1 mm Cash Box.
A pop-up coin tray, 4 bill clips, 1 mm steel and a low price.
Check price on Amazon →
What is a cash box used for?

Handling cash where there’s no register: yard sales, farmers markets, craft fairs, school fundraisers, a food truck or petty cash at the office. It keeps coins and bills sorted while you make change, and it locks when you step away.

Is a cash box safe for keeping money at home?

Not on its own. It’s light and easy to carry off, and the lock is a privacy lock. For cash at home, see our best money safes, or for small amounts our best small safes.

Are cash boxes fireproof?

No. None of the cash boxes we checked has a fire rating. To keep cash and papers through a fire, you need a fire-rated safe; see our best fireproof safes.

Can a cash box be bolted down?

None of the picks here has mounting holes or a security cable. Keep it in sight while you sell. For cash that has to stay put all day, see our best drop safes.

Can I keep medicine in a cash box?

Many people do, since a small key-lock box keeps pills away from kids. For boxes made for it, see our best medicine lock boxes.

Cash box or lock box?

A cash box has a tray for coins and bills and a handle to carry it. A lock box is a plain box with a lock for anything else; see our best lockable storage boxes.

Find your fit

A cash box keeps bills and coins sorted and locked at the table or the till. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Cash sorted and locked at the table
→ Cash boxes (you're here)
Lockable boxes with a coin tray and bill slots for events, shops and clubs.
If you want
Cash kept overnight
→ Money safes
Heavier safes that bolt down, for the takings after you close.
If you want
Cash dropped in at the shop
→ Drop safes
Staff drop cash through a slot without opening the door.
If you want
Cash locked for the bank run
→ Locking bags
Locking deposit bags that keep cash and checks shut on the way to the bank.

How to choose a cash box →

We looked at 274 products that came up on Amazon across 28 searches for “cash box”, “cash box with lock” and “cash box with money tray”. Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews of all those boxes: the lock, how sturdy the box is, the size, the money tray and the value. Those became our four scores.

Most of what we found is one 11.8 × 9.45 × 3.54 inch steel box with a pop-up tray, sold under about ten brand names. We kept one box per body and size, which leaves six picks; the others are the same boxes under another name.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 274 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. One exception: when every pick is weak on the same stat, we still show that score, marked with *, but leave it out of the overall, because it can’t tell the picks apart. We only picked boxes we could score on all four, and we skipped listings you can’t buy right now.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.