7 Best Car Key Lock Boxes, from Turo Window Boxes to Hitch Vaults

The short version

01
Best car key lock box: Lifronkit 4-Digit Car Window Lock Box. The roomiest window box here, with a backup key if you forget the code.
4.7/5Check price →
02
Most secure: HitchSafe HS7000 Key Vault. A steel drawer hidden in your trailer hitch.
4.5/5Check price →
03
Best for Turo hosts: Thlevel G22 Smart Car Key Lock Box. Guest codes from an app that expire on their own.
4.1/5Check price →
04
Best magnetic key box: MAILADA Magnetic Key Lock Box. A spare key under the car, held by 3 strong magnets.
4.6/5Check price →
05
Best magnetic box with a signal bag: FEUNLEM Magnetic Key Box. The lowest-priced pick, with a bag that blocks your fob.
3.9/5Check price →
06
Best big-button keypad: KeyGuard SL-591 Car Window Lock Box. The classic window box with phone-style push buttons.
4.3/5Check price →
07
Best wheel-code window box: RINKOU 3-Wheel Car Key Lock Box. A metal window box with number wheels, no buttons and no batteries.
4.8/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 7

Best car key lock box

Lock: 4-digit code + backup key

Holds: 5–12 keys (listed)

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
4-digit code, backup key if you forget it; owners say it’s easy to use
Capacity
4.6
5–12 keys; 4.13 × 1.69 × 3.35 in inside, the roomiest stated here
Security
4.1
Aluminum alloy and ABS; held on by the closed window
Value
4.6
Low price; owners say it works well

Here’s the deal: the car key lock box to start with if you hand a car to guests or family. You hook it over the top of the window glass and roll the window up, or screw it to a wall. It has the most room inside of any window box here, 4.13 × 1.69 × 3.35 inches, enough for 5 to 12 medium keys, a fob, cards or cash. A 4-digit code opens it, and a cover keeps rain off the buttons. If you forget the code, an emergency key opens the box so you can reset it, which most window boxes don’t have. The body is aluminum alloy with a tough ABS coating, and the listing says it hangs on the window without scratching it. Owners say it works well, is easy to use and the code is simple to set.

The catch: it’s new, with little owner feedback yet. The listing itself says it doesn’t block a keyless fob’s signal, so a push-to-start car can be opened while the fob sits in the box: put the fob in a signal-blocking bag first. It’s only as strong as a closed window and a light metal shell. Keep the emergency key somewhere else, never inside the box. One line of the listing calls it “SL-591”, but its 4-digit lock, backup key and deeper box differ from the SL-591 push-button box (pick 6).

Why we like it

✓ Most room of the window boxes
✓ Backup key if you forget the code
✓ Low price

Watch out for

✗ Little owner feedback yet
✗ Doesn’t block a keyless fob
✗ Light aluminum and ABS shell

Size

7.1 × 4.4 × 4.4 in (listed)

Lock

4-digit code + emergency key

Holds

5–12 keys; 4.13 × 1.69 × 3.35 in inside

Mount

Window hook or wall screws

Build

Aluminum alloy, ABS cover, 1.6 lb

Skip it if your car has keyless entry and you’d rather not buy a signal bag: see pick 3.

Keyless car? A fob in the box can open the door.

If your car unlocks when you walk up with the key in your pocket, a fob sitting in a lock box on the window can be close enough to do the same for anyone who pulls the handle. Most window and magnetic boxes don’t block the signal; several listings say so themselves. Put the fob in a signal-blocking bag before it goes in the box: picks 3 and 5 come with one. Then test it: lock the car, put the bagged fob in the box and pull the handle. A plain metal key doesn’t need any of this. For keys that stay at the house, see our best key lock boxes.

Pick 2 of 7

Most secure

Lock: 4-digit code

Holds: A key fob + cards

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
4-digit code, fits with no tools; fit depends on your hitch
Capacity
4.3
A key fob, cash and up to 2 cards
Security
4.6
Solid steel, hidden in the trailer hitch
Value
4.3
Upper-priced for a lock box

Here’s the deal: the only steel box here, and the only one a passer-by can’t see. It’s a drawer that slides into your vehicle’s 2-inch trailer hitch, solid steel with a rust-resistant coating, and two bolt bars hold it in the receiver; a rubber hitch cover hides it. It locks with a 4-digit code and installs in seconds with no tools. It holds your keys, cash and up to 2 cards while you swim, hike or hand the car to a Turo guest. Owners call it well built, easy to install and a great way to stash a key. It’s also on our best key lock boxes list, with the same scores. If you also leave a handgun in the vehicle, see our best car gun safes.

The catch: fit. Owners are split; it needs a standard 2-inch receiver, and all Toyota pickups need a longer bolt set sold separately. Some large fobs barely fit, and a keyless-entry fob needs a signal-blocking bag (sold separately) so the car can’t be opened while it’s inside. You can’t use the hitch while it’s in.

Why we like it

✓ Steel, hidden in the trailer hitch
✓ No tools to fit
✓ Holds a fob, cash and cards

Watch out for

✗ Only fits a 2 in hitch receiver
✗ Toyota pickups need extra bolts
✗ Fob needs a signal-blocking bag

Size

Fits 2 in receivers

Lock

4-digit code

Holds

A key fob + cards; 1.25 × 3.56 × 1.75 in inside (Amazon’s answer)

Mount

Slides into the hitch, 2 bolt bars

Build

Steel, rust-resistant, rubber cover

Skip it if you don’t have a trailer hitch: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 7

Best for Turo hosts

Lock: App eKeys + PIN codes

Comes with: Signal-blocking pouch

SafesGeek score
4.1/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.7
App eKeys and PIN codes that expire on their own; unlock history; USB-C if batteries die
Capacity
4.3
5 house keys, 3 cards and 1 fob, listed
Security
4.3
Zinc alloy, IP65, signal-blocking pouch included
Value
4.3
Priciest window box here; too new for owner feedback

Here’s the deal: made for hosts who never want to meet a guest. In the free TTLock app you make a time-limited eKey or a 6- to 9-digit PIN code for each rental, and it stops working on its own when the rental ends, even with your phone far away. When your phone is back in Bluetooth range, the box sends you a list of every time it was opened; no Wi-Fi is needed. It hooks over the window glass with a padded hook, no tools. The body is zinc alloy, sealed to IP65 against rain, car washes and cold, and it comes with a signal-blocking pouch, so a keyless fob inside can’t open the car. It holds up to 5 house keys, 3 cards and 1 fob. It runs on 3 AAA batteries, and a USB-C cable powers it if they die.

The catch: it’s the newest pick, with too little owner feedback to judge the app or the lock yet. It’s the priciest window box here, it needs batteries (not included) and a phone with the app, and the unlock history only reaches you over Bluetooth. Plan your codes before you leave. For more app-controlled boxes, see our best smart safes.

Why we like it

✓ Guest codes that expire on their own
✓ Unlock history in the app
✓ Signal-blocking pouch included

Watch out for

✗ Too new for owner feedback
✗ Needs 3 AAA batteries and an app
✗ Priciest window box

Size

3.7 × 2.4 × 5.1 in

Lock

App eKeys, 6–9 digit PIN codes

Holds

5 house keys, 3 cards, 1 fob (listed)

Mount

Padded window hook

Build

Zinc alloy, IP65, 3 AAA + USB-C

Skip it if you’d rather not deal with an app or batteries: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 7

Best magnetic key box

Lock: 4-digit dials

Holds: Keys or a fob

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.3
4-digit dials; you reach under the car to get it
Capacity
4.4
Owners say a key fob fits; inside size not listed
Security
4.0
Polypropylene; hidden, but pulls off and breaks open once found
Value
4.7
Low price; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the spare key for the day you lock yourself out. Three strong N52 magnets hold it to a flat steel spot under the car, and owners say the magnets are the best thing about it: it stays put on rough roads, and one owner says it stayed on through a 14,000-mile road trip. A 4-dial code, 10,000 combinations, keeps a finder out, and a removable cable shackle lets you hang it on a doorknob or a gate instead; adhesive tape comes on it too. It’s 6.1 inches tall, 3.35 wide and 1.7 deep, thick polypropylene, and sealed against rain. Owners say it’s well made and lasts, that a key fob fits, and that it’s worth the money.

The catch: it’s plastic. Hidden is its only defense: once someone finds it, it pulls off and can be broken open somewhere else. You have to reach under the car to use it, so it’s a spare for you, not a handoff box for guests. The magnets need a flat steel surface, and many cars have plastic underneath, so find a spot on the frame first. Our data had no stock status for this listing, so check it’s available.

Why we like it

✓ 3 strong magnets, owners rate them highly
✓ Fits a key fob, owners say
✓ Cable shackle for a knob or gate

Watch out for

✗ Plastic: easy to break once found
✗ You reach under the car to use it
✗ Needs a flat steel spot

Size

6.1 × 3.35 × 1.7 in

Lock

4-digit dials

Holds

Keys or a fob (inside size not listed)

Mount

3 N52 magnets, cable shackle or tape

Build

Thick polypropylene, waterproof

Skip it if you hand keys to rental guests: see pick 3.

Pick 5 of 7

Best magnetic box with a signal bag

Lock: 4-digit code

Comes with: Signal-blocking bag

SafesGeek score
3.9/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.3
4-digit code; you reach under the car to get it
Capacity
4.3
3.54 × 2.75 × 1.1 in inside; fobs, cash and cards
Security
4.0
ABS plastic; hidden, but pulls off once found
Value
4.6
Lowest-priced pick; signal bag included

Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced pick, and the only magnetic box here that comes with a bag to block a keyless fob’s signal, plus a waterproof bag. Four strong magnets hold it under the car or to any steel surface, or you can screw it to a wall. Inside, 3.54 × 2.75 × 1.1 inches with a sponge lining holds a car key or fob, an AirTag, cash or cards. A 4-digit code you can reset keeps it shut, and a cover holds the lid closed. It’s 4.53 inches tall, 3.74 wide and 1.57 deep and weighs 9.6 ounces.

The catch: it’s new, with too little owner feedback to know how the lock and magnets hold up. It’s ABS plastic, so once someone finds it, it can be pulled off and pried open. Like any magnetic box, it needs a flat steel spot, and you have to reach under the car to use it.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest-priced pick
✓ Signal-blocking bag included
✓ 4 magnets or wall screws

Watch out for

✗ Too new for owner feedback
✗ Plastic: easy to break once found
✗ You reach under the car to use it

Size

4.53 × 3.74 × 1.57 in

Lock

4-digit code

Holds

3.54 × 2.75 × 1.1 in inside

Mount

4 magnets or wall screws

Build

ABS, sponge lining, 9.6 oz

Skip it if you want the magnetic box with the most owner feedback: see pick 4.

Pick 6 of 7

Best big-button keypad

Lock: Phone-style push buttons

Holds: Keys, a fob, cards

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
Big push buttons, easy to use; owners split on reliability, some say it locks itself
Capacity
4.4
Keys, a fob, cards and cash, listed; inside size not listed
Security
4.1
Zinc, metal frame; the code works in any order, owners report
Value
4.1
Upper-priced for this body; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: the classic window box, from the brand that sells it as the SL-591. Big phone-style push buttons make the code easy to punch in, and owners mostly agree it’s easy to use and simple to set up. It hooks over the window glass or screws to a wall, a cover hides the buttons, and it locks itself when you close it. It’s solid zinc with a metal frame and an ABS coating that protects your paint, 5 inches tall, 4.5 wide and 2.6 deep, 1.2 pounds. It holds house keys, car keys, fobs, cards, IDs or cash. Owners rate the build quality.

The catch: reliability. Owners are split: for many it works fine, while others say it stopped opening or broke, and the plastic cover can snap off. Some say it locks itself before they want it to, and that the code works in any order, which makes it easier to guess. It doesn’t block a keyless fob’s signal. The same body is sold under at least seven other brands for much less, so owners are split on the value.

Why we like it

✓ Big, easy push buttons
✓ Owners rate the build quality
✓ Window hook or wall screws

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on reliability
✗ Code works in any order
✗ Cover can snap off

Size

5 × 4.5 × 2.6 in

Lock

Phone-style push buttons

Holds

Keys, fobs, cards, cash (inside not listed)

Mount

Window hook or wall screws

Build

Zinc, metal frame, ABS coating, 1.2 lb

Skip it if you want more room or a backup key: see pick 1.

Pick 7 of 7

Best wheel-code window box

Lock: 3 number wheels

Holds: Fobs, keys, cards

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Access
4.4
3 number wheels, no batteries; hooks on a window, gate or fence
Capacity
4.4
Key fobs, key cards and spare keys, listed; 6.1 in tall, inside size not listed
Security
4.1
Metal body, zinc wheels; only 1,000 possible codes
Value
4.4
Low price; owners rate it well, no owner topics yet

Here’s the deal: a window box with a different lock. Instead of push buttons or a keypad, you turn 3 zinc number wheels, so there are no batteries to die and no buttons to wear out. The body is metal, 6.1 inches tall, 3.93 wide and 4.13 deep, 1.8 pounds, and RINKOU says it’s rainproof, dust-resistant and rust-free. It hooks over a car window for a Turo guest, or hangs on a gate or fence at home. It holds key fobs, key cards or spare car keys, and owners rate it well so far.

The catch: 3 wheels give only 1,000 possible codes, fewer than a 4-digit box, so a patient thief can try them all; change the code after every guest. The listing doesn’t give the inside size, so measure your fob against the 6.1 × 3.93 × 4.13 in outside. Amazon shows no owner topics for it yet, so its reliability is the maker’s word. It doesn’t block a keyless fob’s signal and has no backup key. Wheels can be slow to set in the dark.

Why we like it

✓ No batteries, no buttons
✓ Metal body with zinc wheels
✓ Window, gate or fence

Watch out for

✗ Only 1,000 possible codes
✗ Inside size not listed
✗ No signal-blocking bag

Size

6.1 × 3.93 × 4.13 in

Lock

3-digit number wheels

Holds

Key fobs, cards, spare keys (inside not listed)

Mount

Window hook, gate or fence

Build

Metal body, zinc alloy wheels, 1.8 lb

Skip it if you want a 4-digit code and a backup key: see pick 1.

PickLockHoldsSizeMountBuildComes with
Lifronkit 4-Digit Car Window Lock Box
Best car key lock box
4.7/5
Check price
4-digit code + backup key5–12 keys (listed)7.1 × 4.4 × 4.4 in (listed)Window hook or wall screwsAluminum alloy, ABS cover, 1.6 lb–
HitchSafe HS7000 Key Vault
Most secure
4.5/5
Check price
4-digit codeA key fob + cardsFits 2 in receiversSlides into the hitch, 2 bolt barsSteel, rust-resistant, rubber cover–
Thlevel G22 Smart Car Key Lock Box
Best for Turo hosts
4.1/5
Check price
App eKeys + PIN codes5 house keys, 3 cards, 1 fob (listed)3.7 × 2.4 × 5.1 inPadded window hookZinc alloy, IP65, 3 AAA + USB-CSignal-blocking pouch
MAILADA Magnetic Key Lock Box
Best magnetic key box
4.6/5
Check price
4-digit dialsKeys or a fob6.1 × 3.35 × 1.7 in3 N52 magnets, cable shackle or tapeThick polypropylene, waterproof–
FEUNLEM Magnetic Key Box
Best magnetic box with a signal bag
3.9/5
Check price
4-digit code3.54 × 2.75 × 1.1 in inside4.53 × 3.74 × 1.57 in4 magnets or wall screwsABS, sponge lining, 9.6 ozSignal-blocking bag
KeyGuard SL-591 Car Window Lock Box
Best big-button keypad
4.3/5
Check price
Phone-style push buttonsKeys, a fob, cards5 × 4.5 × 2.6 inWindow hook or wall screwsZinc, metal frame, ABS coating, 1.2 lb–
RINKOU 3-Wheel Car Key Lock Box
Best wheel-code window box
4.8/5
Check price
3 number wheelsFobs, keys, cards6.1 × 3.93 × 4.13 inWindow hook, gate or fenceMetal body, zinc alloy wheels, 1.8 lb–

A car key lock box has one job: get a key to the right person at the car, with nobody else able to take it. Six questions decide which one fits you.

A window box hooks over the glass and the window rolls up to hold it, so a guest finds it right away: that’s the Turo pick (picks 1, 3 and 6). A hitch vault hides in a 2-inch trailer receiver and is the only steel box here (pick 2). A magnetic box sticks under the car, out of sight, as your own spare for the day you lock yourself out (picks 4 and 5). Rental guests rarely find, or want to crawl under, a magnetic box.

Measure it first. Modern fobs are thick, and owners of some window boxes say theirs didn’t fit. The roomiest stated inside here is 4.13 × 1.69 × 3.35 inches (pick 1); the hitch vault takes one fob plus cards.

Most don’t. With keyless entry, a fob in a box on the window or under the car can be close enough to unlock the doors for anyone who tries the handle. Picks 3 and 5 come with a signal-blocking bag; for the others, buy one and test it before your first guest. A plain metal key needs nothing.

Push buttons are quick to punch in, but on simple mechanical boxes the order of the code may not matter (pick 6). Dials work without batteries but can be slow in the dark. An app box makes a new code for every guest that expires on its own and shows when the box was opened (pick 3). Whatever you choose, change the code after every rental. For more app-controlled storage, see our best smart safes.

Enough to stop a passer-by, not a determined thief. Window boxes are light zinc or aluminum, held on by the closed window; magnetic boxes are plastic and rely on staying hidden. Only the hitch vault is steel (pick 2). Don’t leave anything in the box except the key, and for valuables at the beach use a travel safe with a steel cable; see our best travel safes. If you also need to lock a handgun in the car, see our best gun lock boxes for car.

Codes that won’t open are the top complaint about car key lock boxes across the market. Test the box a few times before you rely on it, write the code down somewhere safe, and keep a second spare at home. A backup key (pick 1) or a USB-C power port (pick 3) gets you in when the code or the batteries fail. For several cars, a key cabinet in the office keeps every spare on a numbered hook; see our best key cabinets.

One last tip: if guests return keys after hours to your office rather than to the car, a steel drop box with a slot is safer than leaving the key at the car; see our best rent drop boxes.

Still not sure? Get the Lifronkit 4-Digit Car Window Lock Box.
The most room of the window boxes, a backup key if you forget the code, and a low price.
Check price on Amazon →
Can someone open my car while the fob is in the lock box?

They can if your car has keyless entry and the box doesn’t block the signal: the fob is close enough for the door to unlock when someone pulls the handle. Put the fob in a signal-blocking bag inside the box. Picks 3 and 5 include one.

Will a window lock box scratch my car?

The window boxes here have a pad or padded hook on the back to protect the glass and paint. Hook it over a clean window and roll the window all the way up. Take it off before you drive.

Where do I put a magnetic key box under the car?

On a flat steel part of the frame, away from the exhaust and the wheels. Many cars have plastic panels underneath that a magnet won’t hold. Pick 4 can also hang from a cable shackle.

How do I change the code?

It depends on the lock. Push-button boxes are usually reset from inside with a small screwdriver, dial boxes by a few steps inside the box, and the smart box from the app (pick 3). Write the new code down: on most boxes a forgotten code means cutting it open, unless it has a backup key (pick 1).

Is a car key lock box allowed for Turo?

The window boxes here are sold for Turo and other car-sharing hosts, for check-in without meeting the guest. Check your platform’s current rules on key handoff, and change the code after every trip. For keys that stay at your home, see our best key lock boxes.

Do car key lock boxes work in rain and cold?

Most have a cover over the buttons or are sealed against rain; the smart box is rated IP65 (pick 3). Ice or dirt can still jam a lock, so test it in bad weather before a guest needs it. For hiding a key in plain sight around the house instead, see our best diversion safes.

Find your fit

A car key lock box lets guests pick up the car key without you being there. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Car keys handed over, no meetup
→ Car key lock boxes (you're here)
Window boxes, hitch vaults and smart boxes for rentals and car sharing.
If you want
A spare house key
→ Key lock boxes
Wall and doorknob boxes for the spare house key.
If you want
Keys returned after hours
→ Rent drop boxes
Steel boxes with a slot for keys and payments dropped off after hours.
If you want
Keys for many cars
→ Key cabinets
A wall cabinet that keeps every key on a numbered hook.

How to choose a car key lock box →

We looked at 163 products that came up on Amazon in our searches for “car key lock box”. About 35 were window boxes, magnetic under-car boxes and hitch boxes made for a car key; the rest were house key boxes, key cabinets and gun safes, which we set aside. Then we counted what owners talk about most: how the lock opens and how often it fails, whether a fob fits, how strong the box is, and the value. Those became our four scores.

Most window boxes are one factory body, the SL-591, sold under at least eight brands; we kept one, the listing with the most owner feedback. We left out the second most-reviewed window box and two magnetic boxes because owners mostly say they won’t open, and magnetic key hiders with no lock at all. The hitch vault comes from our key lock box guide, with the same scores.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 163 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.