Buying guide · Updated for 2026
10 Best Combination Key Lock Boxes, from Big Wall Boxes to Realtor Hangers
A combination key lock box keeps a spare key outside your door behind a code you choose, with no key to lose and no batteries to die. We checked 47 listings on Amazon and picked 10, scored on what owners talk about most: how easy the code is to use, how many keys fit, how hard the box is to break into and what you get for the money.
By the SafesGeek review team. If you buy through our links, we earn a commission at no cost to you. But it never changes our picks.
The short version
Pick 1 of 10
ABUS KeyGarage 787 Wall Mount Key Lock Box
Best combination key lock box
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: Up to 20 keys or 14 cards
Here’s the deal: the combination key lock box to start with if you hand out more than one key. It comes from ABUS, a German lock maker since 1924. It’s 4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 inches, holds up to 20 keys or 14 cards, and has a removable hook to keep keys in order. The housing is metal with a die-cast zinc cover, and a sliding cover keeps dirt off the dials. You set your own 4-digit code. It suits homes, rentals and offices that share several keys, and owners rate it highly. It’s also our top pick in our best key lock boxes, with the same scores.
The catch: 20 keys is a tight squeeze; Amazon’s answer puts the realistic number nearer 12–16. The sliding cover keeps out dirt, not driving rain, so mount it under an eave or porch roof. One owner says the plastic key hook feels cheap.
Why we like it
✓ Holds up to 20 keys or 14 cards
✓ Metal body, zinc cover
✓ ABUS lock maker
Watch out for
✗ 20 keys is a squeeze
✗ Cover isn’t weather tight
✗ Plastic key hook
Size
4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
Up to 20 keys or 14 cards
Mount
Screws to a wall
Build
Metal, die-cast zinc cover, 1.5 lb
Skip it if you’d rather punch in a code than turn dials: see pick 5.
Test it a few times before your spare key goes in.
“Won’t open with the right code” is the top complaint about combination key lock boxes across the market. Set your code with the door open, then close and open it three or four times before you rely on it. Write the code down somewhere safe: most boxes have no way to recover it, and a box that won’t open has to be cut off. Keep a second spare with a friend. In winter, ice in the dials can freeze them; warm water frees them. For a key you also want to hide, see our best diversion safes.
Pick 2 of 10
Iron Lock XXL Wall Mount Key Lock Box
Best for many keys and fobs
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: 20–30 keys plus fobs
Here’s the deal: the biggest inside of any pick, for a rental, a team or a family that shares a lot of keys. The listing says it holds 20 to 30 house keys plus car fobs and access cards, in a 4.7 × 3.6 × 1.9 inch space behind a wide 5-inch door. A built-in tray cradles the keys so they don’t tumble out when the door swings open, and two hooks come with it. A cover slides over the dials to keep off rain and grit. The body is zinc alloy and aluminum, 5.7 inches tall, 4.1 wide and 2.1 deep, and 4 screws and wall anchors come in the box. It’s fully mechanical: you set your own 4-digit code from 10,000 choices. Owners rate the quality, say it’s easy to set and use, and praise the room for fobs.
The catch: the lock. Owners mostly praise the box, but more of those who mention the lock itself complain than praise it: some say it refused to open. The listing gives 21.33 cubic inches inside, less than its own inside size, because the dial mechanism takes up to 1 inch at the top. It isn’t sealed, so the seller suggests mounting it under an eave. Owner feedback is shared with the medium size of the same box.
Why we like it
✓ Most room inside: 20–30 keys plus fobs
✓ Tray stops keys falling out
✓ Screws and anchors included
Watch out for
✗ Some owners say the lock refused to open
✗ Not sealed against rain
✗ Dial mechanism takes room at the top
Size
5.7 × 4.1 × 2.1 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
20–30 keys plus fobs; 4.7 × 3.6 × 1.9 in inside
Mount
4 screws and wall anchors
Build
Zinc alloy, aluminum, 1.6 lb
Skip it if you only keep one or two keys in it: see pick 3.
Pick 3 of 10
Fayleeko Wall Mount Key Lock Box (4-Digit, Gray)
Best value
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: Up to 5 house keys
Here’s the deal: a small wall box in the classic style, at a low price. It’s 4.7 inches tall, 3.54 wide and 1.6 deep, made of zinc alloy and stainless steel, with an ABS shell against rain, dust and sun. You set your own 4-digit code, with 10,000 choices. It holds up to 5 house keys shorter than 3.35 inches, or a car key or access cards, and 4 screws and wall plugs come with it. Owners say it’s easy to install, works well and is good value, and they rate its security.
The catch: write your code down. The listing warns there’s no way to get it back if you forget it. Owners are split on how easy it is to open, some say it’s smaller than they expected, and a few say it broke within a month.
Why we like it
✓ Easy to install, owners say
✓ Zinc alloy and stainless steel
✓ Low price
Watch out for
✗ Hard to open, some say
✗ No way to recover the code
✗ Smaller than expected, some say
Size
4.7 × 3.54 × 1.6 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
Up to 5 keys under 3.35 in
Mount
4 screws and wall plugs
Build
Zinc alloy, stainless steel, 7.68 oz
Skip it if you want buttons instead of dials: see pick 5.
Pick 4 of 10
Master Lock 5401EC Wall Mount Key Lock Box
Most durable
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: Up to 5 keys
Here’s the deal: the small wall box from the best-known lock brand here, and the one owners most often call built to last. It’s 4.75 inches tall, 3.25 wide and 1.5 deep, with a metal body and a shutter door that keeps rain off the dials. You set your own 4-digit code and change it as often as you like. Inside it’s 3.25 × 2.25 × 1 inches, 7.3 cubic inches, for up to 5 keys. Owners rate the quality, say it’s easy to mount and to set, and praise it for keeping an emergency key by the door.
The catch: it’s small inside. Five keys is the listing’s own limit, and owners are split on whether it holds enough; a car key fob may not fit. The listing says it’s made for a wall or a fixed object but doesn’t say what hardware comes with it. The title calls it the 5401EC; the spec sheet says 5401D.
Why we like it
✓ Owners rate the durability very highly
✓ Shutter door over the dials
✓ Code easy to set, owners say
Watch out for
✗ Only 7.3 cu in inside
✗ Car fobs may not fit
✗ Mounting hardware not listed
Size
4.75 × 3.25 × 1.5 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
Up to 5 keys; 3.25 × 2.25 × 1 in inside
Mount
Wall or fixed object
Build
Metal body, shutter door, 8 oz
Skip it if you need room for a car fob: see pick 2.
Pick 5 of 10
Vewaci 12-Button Wall Key Lock Box (8109)
Best push-button box
Lock: 12 push buttons
Holds: Keys, car keys, cards
Here’s the deal: the pick for anyone who finds dials fiddly. You punch a code into 12 big push buttons, which the listing says are easy to use even in low light, and it’s still fully mechanical: no batteries. The seller suggests a 4- to 8-digit code. An ABS shield covers the buttons against rain, dust and sun, and the body is aluminum alloy, 5.9 inches tall, 3.74 wide and 2.36 deep. Inside, 4.13 × 2.36 × 1.77 inches, with hooks, holds house keys, car keys and cards. Screws and anchors come with it. Owners rate the quality, say it’s easy to install and to use, and that it works well without batteries.
The catch: on simple push-button locks like this, the order of the buttons usually doesn’t matter, and the same body sold under another name says so: the code works in any order. That leaves far fewer codes to guess than a 4-dial box, so use more digits. Owners are split on the lock itself; several say they couldn’t unlock it. Write the code down or photograph it each time you change it, as the seller advises.
Why we like it
✓ Big buttons, no dials to turn
✓ No batteries needed
✓ Hooks inside, screws included
Watch out for
✗ Code works in any order
✗ Some owners couldn’t unlock it
✗ Less owner feedback than the dial boxes
Size
5.9 × 3.74 × 2.36 in
Lock
12 push buttons, 4–8 digits suggested
Holds
Keys, car keys, cards; 4.13 × 2.36 × 1.77 in inside
Mount
Screws and anchors
Build
Aluminum alloy, ABS cover, 1.4 lb
Skip it if you want the hardest code to guess: see pick 1.
Pick 6 of 10
Puroma Key Lock Box (4-Digit, Gray)
Best budget box
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: 4–5 loose keys
Here’s the deal: a low-cost box that goes on the wall or on a doorknob. It’s 5.75 inches tall, 3.07 wide and 1.54 deep, in aluminum-zinc alloy and steel, and weighs 9.6 ounces. A removable shackle hangs it on a knob, or 4 screws and wall plugs fix it to a wall. The code comes set to 0-0-0-0, and you set your own in four steps, with 10,000 possible codes. Amazon’s answer says 4–5 loose house keys fit. Owners rate the quality and value for money, and it’s one of the lowest-priced picks.
The catch: opening it. Owners often find it hard to open; some say it stopped opening with the right code after a few uses, and a few had to have it cut off. Chunky modern car keys won’t fit inside.
Why we like it
✓ Wall or doorknob
✓ 10,000 codes
✓ Low price
Watch out for
✗ Hard to open, many owners say
✗ Some jam for good
✗ Car key fobs won’t fit
Size
5.75 × 3.07 × 1.54 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
4–5 loose keys (Amazon’s answer)
Mount
Doorknob shackle or 4 wall screws
Build
Aluminum-zinc alloy and steel, 9.6 oz
Skip it if you’ll open it every day: see pick 4.
Pick 7 of 10
Kingsley Guard-a-Key Realtor’s Lockbox
Best realtor lock box
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: 2–4 keys
Here’s the deal: a slim hanging box agents use for showings. It’s 5.3 inches tall, 2.6 wide and 1 deep, and weighs 9.44 ounces. The vinyl-covered shackle goes around a doorknob, and owners also hang it on gas meter pipes, hose bibs and railings; it can mount on a wall too. It has a 4-digit code with 10,000 combinations that you can change as often as you like. Amazon’s answer says 2–4 keys fit comfortably, and a plain car key fits. Owners praise how well it works, its durability and the room inside. If you hand out keys after hours at an office instead, see our best rent drop boxes.
The catch: owners are split on ease of use, and some find the dials hard to work. You need the old code to set a new one, and modern smart car fobs are too big. A box on a doorknob can be cut off with bolt cutters, so it’s for showings and short stays, not for good.
Why we like it
✓ Hangs on knobs, pipes, railings
✓ Slim, weather-resistant finish
✓ Change the code anytime
Watch out for
✗ Dials can be hard to use
✗ Need the old code to change it
✗ No room for smart fobs
Size
5.3 × 2.6 × 1 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
2–4 keys (Amazon’s answer), about 10 cu in
Mount
Shackle, or a wall
Build
Metal, vinyl shackle, 9.44 oz
Skip it if you want it fixed to the wall: see pick 3.
Pick 8 of 10
Fortis Lock Wall Mount Key Lock Box (YH2090)
Best new wall dial box
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: A few keys or cards
Here’s the deal: a plain metal wall box, newer than the others, that owners so far rate well. It’s 4.53 inches tall, 3.69 wide and 1.5 deep, with a weather-resistant metal body and a fully mechanical 4-digit code you set yourself, so there are no batteries. Owners say it’s well made, sturdy, easy to set up and good value, and one says it’s a good fit for rental or contractor access.
The catch: thin facts and thin feedback. The listing says it holds 57 keys or cards in 25.07 cubic inches, but that’s its whole outside size (4.53 × 3.69 × 1.5 inches), so expect a handful of keys, as in other boxes this size. It doesn’t list the inside size, the build metal or the mounting hardware, and far fewer owners have reviewed it than the other wall boxes.
Why we like it
✓ Owners rate the quality so far
✓ No batteries
✓ Low price
Watch out for
✗ Capacity claim is the outside size
✗ Little owner feedback yet
✗ Mounting hardware not listed
Size
4.53 × 3.69 × 1.5 in
Lock
4-digit dials, resettable
Holds
A few keys or cards (inside not listed)
Mount
Wall
Build
Weather-resistant metal, 0.36 kg
Skip it if you want the wall box with the most owner feedback: see pick 4.
Pick 9 of 10
Kidde AccessPoint KeySafe Original (001015)
Best security
Lock: Push buttons
Holds: Up to 5 keys
Here’s the deal: a key safe with buttons instead of dials, fixed to a wall for good. It’s 7 inches wide, 2.7 tall and 3.2 deep, with a titanium-gray finish and mounting hardware. You press your code on 10 push buttons, with over 1,000 combinations, and it holds up to 5 keys. Owners rate the durability very highly, and many keep one so family or paramedics can get in to an elderly parent. One owner says it works at 20 below zero in a Minnesota winter. It’s also on our best key lock boxes, with the same scores.
The catch: setting the code. You change it with small dials inside, and some owners find them stiff or need a video to work it out. Owners are split on ease of use, and the spec says it isn’t water resistant, so a rubber cover helps in rain.
Why we like it
✓ Push buttons, no dials to freeze
✓ Very durable, owners say
✓ Works in deep cold, one owner says
Watch out for
✗ Code is fiddly to change
✗ Ease of use is split
✗ Not water resistant, spec says
Size
7 × 2.7 × 3.2 in
Lock
Push buttons, 1,000+ codes
Holds
Up to 5 keys; inside size not listed
Mount
Wall, hardware included
Build
Metal, titanium-gray finish
Skip it if you need room for lots of keys: see pick 1.
Pick 10 of 10
RUDY RUN Large Outdoor Key Lock Box
Best for fobs and cards
Lock: 4-digit dials
Holds: 5+ keys, fobs, cards
Here’s the deal: a wall box built to take more than house keys. It holds at least 5 keys plus fobs, cards or access tags behind a 4-digit code you set yourself. It’s zinc alloy and stainless steel, about 5 × 4 × 2 inches and 1 pound, built to resist rust outdoors, and it comes with 4 screws and 4 nylon plugs for concrete, brick or other hard walls. Owners say the instructions are clear and it’s easy to install, rate the quality very highly, call it sturdy and say the code is simple to set and reset.
The catch: reliability. Owners complain more than praise here: while many say it opens and closes smoothly, some say it wouldn’t open at all. The listing doesn’t give the inside size.
Why we like it
✓ Room for fobs and cards too
✓ Sturdy zinc and stainless steel
✓ Owners say it’s easy to install
Watch out for
✗ Some owners say it wouldn’t open
✗ Inside size not listed
✗ Dials are slow in the dark
Size
5 × 4 × 2 in
Lock
4-digit dials, 10,000 codes
Holds
5+ keys, fobs, cards
Mount
4 screws + 4 nylon plugs
Build
Zinc alloy and stainless steel, 1 lb
Skip it if you’d rather punch buttons than turn dials: see pick 5.
Compare the specs
| Pick | Lock | Holds | Size | Mount | Build |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ABUS KeyGarage 787 Wall Mount Key Lock Box Best combination key lock box 4.8/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | Up to 20 keys or 14 cards | 4.7 × 3.3 × 1.7 in | Screws to a wall | Metal, die-cast zinc cover, 1.5 lb |
| Iron Lock XXL Wall Mount Key Lock Box Best for many keys and fobs 4.7/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | 20–30 keys plus fobs | 5.7 × 4.1 × 2.1 in | 4 screws and wall anchors | Zinc alloy, aluminum, 1.6 lb |
| Fayleeko Wall Mount Key Lock Box Best value 4.6/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | Up to 5 house keys | 4.7 × 3.54 × 1.6 in | 4 screws and wall plugs | Zinc alloy, stainless steel, 7.68 oz |
| Master Lock 5401EC Wall Mount Key Lock Box Most durable 4.7/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | Up to 5 keys | 4.75 × 3.25 × 1.5 in | Wall or fixed object | Metal body, shutter door, 8 oz |
| Vewaci 12-Button Wall Key Lock Box Best push-button box 4.3/5 Check price | 12 push buttons | Keys, car keys, cards | 5.9 × 3.74 × 2.36 in | Screws and anchors | Aluminum alloy, ABS cover, 1.4 lb |
| Puroma Key Lock Box Best budget box 4.5/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | 4–5 loose keys | 5.75 × 3.07 × 1.54 in | Doorknob shackle or 4 wall screws | Aluminum-zinc alloy and steel, 9.6 oz |
| Kingsley Guard-a-Key Realtor’s Lockbox Best realtor lock box 4.5/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | 2–4 keys | 5.3 × 2.6 × 1 in | Shackle, or a wall | Metal, vinyl shackle, 9.44 oz |
| Fortis Lock Wall Mount Key Lock Box Best new wall dial box 4.5/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | A few keys or cards | 4.53 × 3.69 × 1.5 in | Wall | Weather-resistant metal, 0.36 kg |
| Kidde AccessPoint KeySafe Best security 4.7/5 Check price | Push buttons | Up to 5 keys | 7 × 2.7 × 3.2 in | Wall, hardware included | Metal, titanium-gray finish |
| RUDY RUN Large Outdoor Key Lock Box Best for fobs and cards 4.7/5 Check price | 4-digit dials | 5+ keys, fobs, cards | 5 × 4 × 2 in | 4 screws + 4 nylon plugs | Zinc alloy and stainless steel, 1 lb |
Specs as each maker or listing states them, Nov 2026. Tap a name to jump to its review.
Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds
How to choose a combination key lock box
A combination key lock box has one job: get a key to the right person at your door, without a key under the mat. Six questions decide which one fits you.
Dials or push buttons?
Dials (picks 1–4, 6–8 and 10) give 10,000 four-digit codes and work in any weather, but they’re slow in the dark and can stick. Push buttons (picks 5 and 9) are quicker to punch in, but on simple mechanical boxes the order of the code usually doesn’t matter, which leaves far fewer codes to guess; use more digits. Neither needs batteries. For codes you send each guest from an app, see our best key lock boxes.
Wall box or shackle?
A wall box screws next to the door and stays there: the right choice for a home spare, a rental or a caregiver (picks 1–5 and 8–10). A shackle box hangs on a doorknob, a pipe or a railing, so realtors move it from house to house (pick 7); pick 6 does both. A shackle box goes on in seconds but comes off with bolt cutters.
How many keys will it hold?
Most small wall boxes take about 5 house keys, and modern car fobs often don’t fit. For a ring of keys and fobs, the roomiest here holds 20–30 keys with 4.7 × 3.6 × 1.9 inches inside (pick 2), and the ABUS takes up to 20 keys or 14 cards (pick 1). Check the inside size, not the outside: one listing gives its outside size as its capacity (pick 8). For dozens of labeled keys indoors, see our best key cabinets.
How secure is a combination key lock box?
Enough to stop a passer-by, not a determined thief. Every pick is a small zinc or aluminum shell on a few screws, so every one scores 4.1 to 4.4 out of 5 on security. Keep only a door key inside, never a car key that matches the car in the driveway, mount the box out of sight from the street, and change the code when a guest or worker no longer needs it. For cash or papers, see our best small safes or our best small lock boxes with key.
What if the code stops working?
Boxes that won’t open with the right code are the top complaint across the market. Test the box several times with the door open before you rely on it, write the code down somewhere safe, and keep a second spare with someone you trust. On most boxes a forgotten code means cutting the box off. In winter, warm water frees frozen dials.
Where should I mount it?
On a solid wall next to the door, under an eave or porch roof, out of direct rain and out of sight from the street. Use all the screw holes, and wall anchors in brick or concrete. A box near a gate or garage works too. If you want a key for a car instead, see our best car key lock boxes.
One last tip: if what you really need is a place for parcels and mail, not keys, see our best locking mailboxes. And for app-controlled storage for valuables, see our best smart safes.
Quick answers
How do I set the code on a combination key lock box?
It depends on the box. On most dial boxes you open the box on the factory code (often 0-0-0-0), move a reset lever or button inside, turn the dials to your new code and move the lever back. Some need the old code to set a new one (pick 7). On push-button boxes you usually reset the buttons from inside. Test the new code several times with the door open.
What if I forget the code?
On most combination key lock boxes there’s no way to recover it, and the box has to be cut or drilled off. Write the code down or take a photo of it each time you change it, and keep it away from the box.
Can a car key fob fit in a combination key lock box?
Often not in a small 5-key box. The roomiest here hold fobs: 20–30 keys plus fobs (pick 2) and keys, car keys and cards (pick 5). Measure your fob against the inside size. For a box that stays with the car, see our best car key lock boxes.
Do combination lock boxes freeze in winter?
They can. Ice in the dials or buttons can stop them turning. A cover over the dials and a spot under an eave help; warm water frees a frozen lock. Test it in bad weather before a guest needs it.
Can someone open a combination key lock box without the code?
A determined thief can pry, smash or cut one open; they’re small zinc or aluminum boxes, not safes. Push-button boxes where the order doesn’t matter are also easier to guess. Mount it out of sight and keep only a door key inside.
How many keys does a combination key lock box hold?
Most small ones hold about 5 house keys. The biggest here take 20–30 keys plus fobs (pick 2) or up to 20 keys or 14 cards (pick 1), and the slim realtor box holds 2–4 (pick 7).
Find your fit
A combination key lock box keeps a spare key at your door behind a code you choose, with no batteries. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.
How we picked
We looked at 47 products that came up on Amazon in our searches for “combination key lock box”. About 27 were single key lock boxes with a code; the rest were key cabinets, multipacks and a fireproof document box, which we set aside. Then we counted what owners talk about most: how the lock opens and how often it fails, how many keys fit, how strong the box is, and the value. Those became our four scores.
Several boxes are one factory body sold under two brands; we kept one of each, the listing with the most owner feedback, and only one size of each box. We left out two push-button boxes and the best-known portable Master Lock box because owners mostly say they won’t open or are hard to use. Six picks come from our key lock box guide, with the same scores.
How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 47 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.
We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.
SafesGeek Review Team
We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.
Sources: Amazon listings (Nov 2026); our guides Best key lock boxes, Best key cabinets and Best car key lock boxes.
