8 Best Fireproof Pistol Safes (and What Their Fire Ratings Mean)

The short version

01
Best overall: SentrySafe STW123GDC. The only pick with a UL fire rating: 1 hour at 1700°F, plus a 24-hour water rating.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Most room: XPEDITION 660FP 2.5 cu ft. About twice the space of most picks, with 45 minutes at 1400°F claimed.
4.9/5Check price →
03
Best fingerprint fire safe: HOLOJOY 7-Pistol Safe. A 7-pistol rack, a fingerprint reader, a code and a key.
4.2/5Check price →
04
Best steel door: Hornady Fireproof Keypad Safe. An 8-gauge door, four 1-inch bolts and anchors in the box.
4.4/5Check price →
05
Best value compact safe: TIGERKING 20″ Fire Safe. A tall, narrow safe owners mostly call well worth the price.
4.5/5Check price →
06
Best compact fingerprint safe: ProtexSafe SK-60. Fingerprint, keypad and key, with six deadbolts.
4.4/5Check price →
07
Best no-battery lock: Uzticams Key-Lock Fire Safe. A plain key lock and a metal rack for 5 handguns.
4.7/5Check price →
08
Smallest pick: ISLANDSAFE 1.29 cu ft. The smallest body here, with a door that opens 180°.
4.4/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 8

Best overall

Fire: UL 1 hour · 1700°F

Water: 24 hr, 8 in

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.9
UL 1 hr at 1700°F; ETL 15-ft fall and 24 hr in 8 in of water
Capacity
4.6
12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in inside, 1.23 cu ft; locking drawer, light
Security
4.6
Four live-locking bolts, 86 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.4
Mid-priced, with a UL fire rating

Here’s the deal: the one pick whose fire rating someone else checked. UL classifies it for 1 hour at 1700°F with the inside kept cool enough for papers, and ETL verifies that it stays shut after a 15-foot fall through a burning floor and keeps out 8 inches of water for 24 hours. Inside it’s 12.6 inches wide, 11.9 deep and 13.8 tall, room for several handguns on the floor of the safe and folders above them, with a small locking drawer and a light. You set your own code on the keypad, and a key is the second lock. Four live-locking bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and about 86 pounds of steel and fire lining make it hard to carry off, and the bolt-down hardware is in the box. It’s also a pick on our best home safes for valuables page, with the same scores.

The catch: owners mostly complain that the keypad is hard to use, and some say it stopped working and left them locked out, so keep the key outside the safe and use fresh name-brand AAA batteries. Owners also mostly complain about durability, mainly a plastic handle that breaks. It isn’t sold as a gun safe, so there’s no rack or pistol pocket; lay the guns on the floor of the safe or add a rack. It’s a slow safe to open in a hurry, and the door needs 14.75 inches of room to swing open.

Why we like it

✓ UL Classified: 1 hr at 1700°F
✓ ETL water and 15-ft fall ratings
✓ Bolt-down kit in the box

Watch out for

✗ Keypad hard to use, owners say
✗ Plastic handle can break
✗ No gun rack or pockets

Size

16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in

Lock

Keypad + backup key

Inside

12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in

Holds

1.23 cu ft, no gun count listed

Build

86 lb, 4 live bolts, UL 1 hr fire

Skip it if you want more room for pistols: see pick 2.

Bolt it down the day it arrives.

These safes weigh about 35 to 95 pounds, so a thief can carry one off with the pistol still inside and open it later. Fix yours to the floor or a wall stud before the guns go in, in a closet or a corner where it can’t be seen from a window. Our guide shows how on concrete, wood and walls.

Pick 2 of 8

Most room

Fire: 45 min · 1400°F

Inside: 2.5 cu ft, listed

SafesGeek score
4.9/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
45 min at 1400°F and 24 hr in 5 in of water, maker’s claims
Capacity
5.0
2.5 cu ft listed; an adjustable shelf and a gun pouch
Security
4.1
18-gauge steel, about 92 lb; 2 bolt-down holes
Value
4.7
Low-priced for its size; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the most room here, in a safe that’s sold for pistols. XPEDITION lists 2.5 cubic feet inside, about twice most picks, in a body 26 inches tall, so there’s room for several handguns, boxes of papers and a shelf you can move. The title lists a gun pouch, too. XPEDITION claims 45 minutes of fire protection at 1400°F and 24 hours in 5 inches of water, with three sealing strips on the door. A keypad opens it, with backup keys, and an alarm sounds after several wrong codes; there’s a silent mode for night. It arrives fully assembled, and two pre-drilled holes take bolts for the floor or a wall. It’s also the fireproof pistol safe pick on our best fireproof gun safes page and a pick on our best large pistol safes page, with the same scores.

The catch: the fire and water figures are XPEDITION’s own; the listing doesn’t name a lab. The steel is 18-gauge, thinner than the heavier picks, so bolt it down. Few owners have rated it, and they name no topics yet, so there’s little owner feedback to go on. The keypad runs on a 9V battery that isn’t included. The listing gives 95 pounds in one place and 92 in another.

Why we like it

✓ 2.5 cu ft listed inside
✓ Keypad, backup keys and an alarm
✓ Arrives fully assembled

Watch out for

✗ Fire figure is the maker’s own
✗ 18-gauge steel
✗ Little owner feedback

Size

16.5 × 15 × 26 in

Lock

Keypad + backup keys

Inside

2.5 cu ft, listed

Holds

Pistols, papers; shelf and gun pouch

Build

18-gauge steel, 92 lb, 45 min fire

Skip it if you want a fire rating from a lab: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 8

Best fingerprint fire safe

Fire: 2 hours, maker’s claim

Rack: 7 pistols

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
2 hours, the maker’s figure; “meets UL standards” but no UL rating named
Capacity
4.9
Removable 7-pistol rack and a shelf; listed 4 cu ft is more than the outside size
Security
4.4
86 lb, four 20 mm bolts plus 2 fixed bolts; floor mount
Value
4.1
Priciest pick; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the safe that’s set up for pistols out of the box. A removable rack holds 7 handguns upright, with an adjustable shelf above for papers, a velvet lining and a light that comes on when you open it. It opens three ways: fingerprint, code or key, and an external battery pack gets you in if the inside batteries die. HOLOJOY says the 2-centimeter fire boards in the body and door, and a 7-centimeter insulated door, give 2 hours of heat protection. Four 20 mm bolts on the front and 2 fixed bolts on the hinge side hold the door, an alarm sounds if someone tampers with it, and at 86 pounds it’s one of the heaviest picks. The door swings open 240°, so the rack is easy to reach.

The catch: the title says “UL fire-rated”, but the listing only says it’s built “to meet UL standards” and names no UL rating, so we count the 2 hours as HOLOJOY’s own figure. It lists 4 cubic feet, but its outside is 17.7 × 15.8 × 21.7 inches, about 3.5 cubic feet (÷ 1,728), so the inside is smaller than the label. It’s the priciest pick, few owners have rated it, and the listing doesn’t say whether bolts come with it.

Why we like it

✓ Rack for 7 pistols
✓ Fingerprint, code and key
✓ Backup battery pack

Watch out for

✗ “UL” claim has no UL rating behind it
✗ Listed 4 cu ft is more than the outside
✗ Priciest pick

Size

17.7 × 15.8 × 21.7 in

Lock

Fingerprint, code, key

Inside

Not listed (4 cu ft claimed)

Holds

7 pistols on the rack + a shelf

Build

Carbon steel, 86 lb, 2 hr fire claim

Skip it if you want a UL fire rating: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 8

Best steel door

Fire: 30 min · 1400°F

Door: 8-gauge steel

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
30 min at 1400°F, Hornady’s figure; no lab named; not water resistant
Capacity
4.6
10.2 × 13.2 × 15 in inside, about 1.2 cu ft; removable shelf
Security
4.6
16-gauge body, 8-gauge door, four 1-in bolts; anchor bolts included
Value
4.1
Mid-priced; owners mostly call it worth the money

Here’s the deal: the heaviest steel among the maker-rated picks, from a brand gun owners know. The door is 8-gauge steel and the body 16-gauge, with four 1-inch locking lugs, and Hornady puts concrete anchor bolts in the box. Hornady sells it for owners who need to lock up more than one or two handguns but have no room for a full gun safe. Inside it’s 10.2 × 13.2 × 15 inches with a removable shelf and a carpet lining, and a light comes on when it opens. A 4- to 6-digit keypad and a spring-assisted door get you in fast, and 2 backup keys come with it. Hornady rates it for 30 minutes at up to 1400°F. Owners mostly praise the quality and call it sturdy, easy to set up and worth the money. It’s also a pick on our best pistol ammo safes page, with the same security and value scores.

The catch: the fire figure is Hornady’s own, with no lab named, and the specs say it isn’t water resistant. Owners mostly complain about the lock. The listing gives 62 pounds in one place and 49 in another. It runs on 4 AA batteries, which aren’t included.

Why we like it

✓ 8-gauge door, four 1-in bolts
✓ Concrete anchors included
✓ Light inside, 2 backup keys

Watch out for

✗ Fire figure is the maker’s own
✗ Lock complaints from owners
✗ Not water resistant

Size

15 × 12 × 16.5 in

Lock

Keypad + 2 backup keys

Inside

10.2 × 13.2 × 15 in

Holds

Several handguns + a shelf

Build

16-ga body, 8-ga door, 30 min fire

Skip it if you want room for more pistols: see pick 2.

Pick 5 of 8

Best value compact safe

Fire: 30 min · 1200°F

Inside: 18.1 in tall

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.0
30 min at 1200°F, “laboratory certified” with no lab named
Capacity
4.4
10 × 9.8 × 18.1 in inside, about 1 cu ft; a shelf
Security
4.4
53 lb, four 1-inch live bolts, recessed hinge side; no bolt-down hardware listed
Value
4.6
Low-priced; owners mostly call it good value

Here’s the deal: the safe owners like best for the price. Owners mostly praise the quality, call it sturdy, spacious and easy to set up, and say it’s well worth the money. It’s a tall, narrow safe, 12.2 inches wide and 20 tall, so it fits in a closet corner, and inside it’s 18.1 inches tall with a removable shelf, room for handguns below and papers above. TIGERKING names pistols among the things it holds. Four 1-inch live bolts lock the door, and the hinge side sits behind the safe’s edge, so cutting the outside hinges doesn’t open it. A keypad opens it, with two emergency keys. TIGERKING says it’s lab certified for 30 minutes at 1200°F. It’s also a pick on our best fireproof ammo safes page, with the same scores.

The catch: the fire figure is the lowest here, and the listing doesn’t name the lab, so it scores low on protection. The 1.8 cubic feet it lists is more than the inside: 10 × 9.8 × 18.1 inches is about 1 cubic foot (÷ 1,728). Owners are split on the lock: some praise it, others had trouble opening the safe. The listing doesn’t mention bolt-down hardware, and it gives 53 pounds in one place and 27 kg (about 60 pounds) in another. The specs say it isn’t water resistant.

Why we like it

✓ Owners mostly call it good value
✓ Narrow: fits a closet corner
✓ Hinge side recessed

Watch out for

✗ Lowest fire figure here, no lab named
✗ Listed 1.8 cu ft is about 1 inside
✗ Owners split on the lock

Size

12.2 × 14.2 × 20 in

Lock

Keypad + 2 emergency keys

Inside

10 × 9.8 × 18.1 in

Holds

Handguns + papers; a shelf

Build

53 lb, four 1-in bolts, 30 min fire

Skip it if fire protection comes first: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 8

Best compact fingerprint safe

Fire: 30 min · 1700°F

Lock: Fingerprint, keypad, key

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
30 min at 1700°F, Protex’s figure; not for a long full-house fire, the listing says
Capacity
4.6
1.32 cu ft listed; A4 papers and handguns
Security
4.4
66 lb, 6 deadbolts, anti-drill plate
Value
4.1
Mid-priced; only a few owner ratings

Here’s the deal: a fingerprint fire safe in a compact body. It opens with a fingerprint (it stores 25), a keypad or one of 2 override keys, and Protex names handguns and A4 papers among what it holds. Six solid deadbolts and an anti-drill steel plate guard the door, and it weighs 66 pounds. Protex rates it for 30 minutes at up to 1700°F, and it’s honest about the limit: the listing says it isn’t designed for a long full-house fire. It’s 11.8 × 14.5 × 21.8 inches outside and lists 1.32 cubic feet inside, which fits in that body.

The catch: only a few owners have rated it, so there’s almost no owner feedback. The fire figure is Protex’s own, with no lab named, and the specs say it isn’t water resistant. The listing doesn’t mention bolt holes, so ask the seller how it fixes down before you buy. Protex asks you to register a finger at several angles for the reader to work well, and to take the key out after use so the lock doesn’t jam.

Why we like it

✓ Fingerprint, keypad and key
✓ 6 deadbolts, anti-drill plate
✓ Honest about its fire limit

Watch out for

✗ Only a few owner ratings
✗ Fire figure is the maker’s own
✗ Bolt holes not mentioned

Size

11.8 × 14.5 × 21.8 in

Lock

Fingerprint (25), keypad, 2 keys

Inside

1.32 cu ft, listed

Holds

Handguns + A4 papers

Build

Steel, 66 lb, 6 deadbolts, 30 min fire

Skip it if you want a fingerprint safe with a pistol rack: see pick 3.

Pick 7 of 8

Best no-battery lock

Lock: Key, no batteries

Rack: 5 handguns

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
60 min at 1800°F claimed, no lab named, on a 34.6 lb safe: partly counted
Capacity
4.4
Metal rack for 5 handguns and a shelf; listed 2 cu ft is more than the outside size
Security
4.1
34.6 lb, key lock; factory-drilled holes to bolt down
Value
4.4
Low-priced; owners mostly praise the quality

Here’s the deal: the one pick with nothing electronic to fail. A plain key opens it, so there are no batteries, codes or keypads to go wrong. A metal pistol rack in the box holds 5 handguns apart from your papers, with a soft lining and a removable shelf. It’s 13.8 × 12.2 × 17.7 inches, small enough for a closet or under a desk, and factory-drilled holes take bolts for the floor or a wall, with fire-resistant covers for the holes you don’t use. Owners mostly praise the quality and like the size. For more safes without batteries, see our best mechanical gun safes.

The catch: Uzticams claims 60 minutes at 1800°F with no lab named, on a safe that weighs 34.6 pounds. The UL-rated 1-hour safe on this page weighs about 86 pounds, because fire lining is heavy, so we only partly count the claim. It’s also light enough to carry off, so bolt it down. It lists 2 cubic feet, but its outside is about 1.7 (13.8 × 12.2 × 17.7 ÷ 1,728), so the inside is smaller. Owners are split on ease of use, and some report trouble with the lock. A key is slower in the dark than a keypad.

Why we like it

✓ Key lock: no batteries to die
✓ Metal rack for 5 handguns
✓ Owners mostly praise the quality

Watch out for

✗ 60-min claim on a 34.6 lb safe
✗ Listed 2 cu ft is more than the outside
✗ Light: bolt it down

Size

13.8 × 12.2 × 17.7 in

Lock

Key, no batteries

Inside

Not listed (2 cu ft claimed)

Holds

5 handguns on the rack + a shelf

Build

Steel, 34.6 lb, 60 min fire claim

Skip it if you want a keypad and heavier steel: see pick 4.

Pick 8 of 8

Smallest pick

Fire: 30 min · 1200°F

Size: 14.9 × 12.6 × 11.8 in

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.0
30 min at 1200°F, “tested and certified” with no lab named
Capacity
4.1
1.29 cu ft listed = the outside size; inside not listed
Security
4.3
Four bolts, two per side; mounting holes with sealed caps; weight not listed
Value
4.3
Mid-priced; little owner detail

Here’s the deal: the smallest body here, for one or two compact handguns and the papers that matter most, on a closet shelf or in a cabinet. ISLANDSAFE names guns in the title and says it’s tested and certified for 30 minutes at 1200°F, with fire board behind a thick door. Four solid bolts, two on each side, lock it, and caps seal the mounting holes so fire, smoke and water can’t get in through them once it’s bolted down. The door opens a full 180°, the inside is lined with soft felt, and a shelf adjusts to 8 heights. A keypad opens it.

The catch: the 1.29 cubic feet it lists is the outside size (14.9 × 12.6 × 11.8 ÷ 1,728), so the inside is smaller and not listed: measure your pistol first. The fire figure is the lowest here, with no lab named. The listing doesn’t give the weight or say what backs up the keypad. Owners rate it well, but Amazon shows no owner topics for it, so we can’t say what they like or don’t.

Why we like it

✓ Smallest body here
✓ Sealed caps for the bolt holes
✓ 180° door, felt lining

Watch out for

✗ Listed 1.29 cu ft is the outside size
✗ Lowest fire figure, no lab named
✗ Weight not listed

Size

14.9 × 12.6 × 11.8 in

Lock

Keypad

Inside

Not listed

Holds

1–2 compact handguns + papers

Build

4 bolts, felt lining, 30 min fire

Skip it if you have a full-size pistol and papers to store: see pick 1.

PickFireWaterSizeLockInsideHoldsBuild
SentrySafe STW123GDC
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
UL 1 hour · 1700°F24 hr, 8 in16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 inKeypad + backup key12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in1.23 cu ft, no gun count listed86 lb, 4 live bolts, UL 1 hr fire
XPEDITION 660FP 2.5 cu ft
Most room
4.9/5
Check price
45 min · 1400°F–16.5 × 15 × 26 inKeypad + backup keys2.5 cu ft, listedPistols, papers; shelf and gun pouch18-gauge steel, 92 lb, 45 min fire
HOLOJOY 7-Pistol Safe
Best fingerprint fire safe
4.2/5
Check price
2 hours, maker's claim–17.7 × 15.8 × 21.7 inFingerprint, code, keyNot listed (4 cu ft claimed)7 pistols on the rack + a shelfCarbon steel, 86 lb, 2 hr fire claim
Hornady Fireproof Keypad Safe
Best steel door
4.4/5
Check price
30 min · 1400°F–15 × 12 × 16.5 inKeypad + 2 backup keys10.2 × 13.2 × 15 inSeveral handguns + a shelf16-ga body, 8-ga door, 30 min fire
TIGERKING 20″ Fire Safe
Best value compact safe
4.5/5
Check price
30 min · 1200°F–12.2 × 14.2 × 20 inKeypad + 2 emergency keys18.1 in tallHandguns + papers; a shelf53 lb, four 1-in bolts, 30 min fire
ProtexSafe SK-60
Best compact fingerprint safe
4.4/5
Check price
30 min · 1700°F–11.8 × 14.5 × 21.8 inFingerprint, keypad, key1.32 cu ft, listedHandguns + A4 papersSteel, 66 lb, 6 deadbolts, 30 min fire
Uzticams Key-Lock Fire Safe
Best no-battery lock
4.7/5
Check price
––13.8 × 12.2 × 17.7 inKey, no batteriesNot listed (2 cu ft claimed)5 handguns on the rack + a shelfSteel, 34.6 lb, 60 min fire claim
ISLANDSAFE 1.29 cu ft
Smallest pick
4.4/5
Check price
30 min · 1200°F–14.9 × 12.6 × 11.8 inKeypadNot listed1–2 compact handguns + papers4 bolts, felt lining, 30 min fire

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

A fireproof pistol safe does two jobs: it keeps the heat of a fire away from what’s inside, and it keeps hands off the gun. Six questions help you pick the right one.

Paper and the things you keep with it: passports, deeds, cash, and the pistol itself. A UL fire rating means the inside stayed below 350°F, cool enough for paper, for the stated time. It’s also why ammo inside can still get hot: see our guide on ammo in a gun safe. Many “fireproof” pistol boxes on Amazon just come with a fire bag; a bag can help papers, but it doesn’t make a steel box a fire safe. Our best fireproof bags page explains what a bag can do.

A UL rating is tested by a lab you can look up, for a stated time and temperature, with the inside temperature measured. Only pick 1 has one here. The others give their own figures: 2 hours (pick 3), 60 minutes (pick 7), 45 minutes (pick 2) and 30 minutes (picks 4, 5, 6 and 8), at 1200 to 1800°F. Weigh those figures against the safe’s weight, since fire lining is heavy, and read our guide are safes fireproof for how ratings work. If you want a UL rating and don’t need gun fittings, see our best fireproof safes.

It stops kids, visitors and a quick grab, but none of these picks has a burglary rating: the fire lining sits between fairly thin steel walls. They score 4.1 to 4.6 out of 5 on security. What makes the most difference is bolting it down, out of sight: picks 1 and 4 include the hardware, picks 2, 7 and 8 list bolt holes, and for picks 3, 5 and 6 ask the seller what comes with it. For a safe built against tools, see our best burglary rated safes.

Go by the inside size, not the label. Three listings here give a capacity equal to or bigger than the outside of the safe (picks 3, 7 and 8), so check by multiplying the outside inches and dividing by 1,728. A full-size pistol lies flat in a space about 9 by 6 inches. Picks 3 and 7 come with a rack that stands pistols up, which fits more in less space; pick 2 has the most room overall. For more safes sized for several handguns, see our best large pistol safes.

A keypad (picks 1, 2, 4, 5 and 8) is the usual choice: use fresh batteries and keep the backup key outside the safe. A fingerprint reader (picks 3 and 6) is quicker once you’ve registered each finger well. A plain key (pick 7) has nothing to fail, but it’s slow in the dark. Our best fingerprint pistol safes page compares readers.

A front-door fire safe takes longer to open than a small pistol box with a lid. If you keep a handgun for home defense, many owners keep it in a quick-access box by the bed and use the fire safe for spare guns, papers and valuables. Makers of quick-access safes warn against storing a loaded gun in them: see our guide on a loaded gun in a safe and our best quick access gun safes.

Still not sure? Get the SentrySafe STW123GDC.
The only pick with a UL fire rating, 1 hour at 1700°F, with a water rating, a backup key and bolt-down hardware in the box.
Check price on Amazon →
Is any pistol safe truly fireproof?

No safe is fireproof forever. A fire rating says how long the inside stays cool enough for paper at a stated heat. Pick 1 is UL rated for 1 hour at 1700°F; the other picks give their own figures of 30 minutes to 2 hours.

Does a fire bag make a pistol box fireproof?

No. A bag can shield papers, but it doesn’t make a thin steel box a fire safe. Look for a fire time and temperature on the safe itself, and a lab name if you can get one.

Can I keep ammo in a fireproof pistol safe?

A modest supply, yes, if the maker allows it, but a fire safe made for paper can still get hot enough inside to set off ammo. Our guide on ammo in a gun safe explains what really happens in a fire.

Should a fireproof pistol safe be bolted down?

Yes. These safes weigh about 35 to 95 pounds, so a thief can carry one off. Picks 1 and 4 include the hardware; picks 2, 7 and 8 list bolt holes.

Will a fireproof pistol safe keep my gun from rusting?

Fire lining can hold moisture, so a closed fire safe can get damp inside. Put a small dehumidifier pack in with the guns and check them every few weeks.

Which fireproof pistol safe holds the most guns?

Pick 2 has the most listed room, 2.5 cubic feet. Pick 3 has a rack for 7 pistols, and pick 7 a rack for 5.

Find your fit

These safes keep a handgun and your papers out of a house fire, and each one is made to be fixed down. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A fire safe sized for pistols
→ Fireproof pistol safes (you're here)
Eight front-door safes for handguns and papers, from a UL-rated 1-hour safe to a 7-pistol fingerprint safe.
If you want
A UL fire rating for papers
→ Fireproof safes
Home safes with a UL or lab fire rating of 1 to 2 hours, built for documents.
If you want
A pistol in reach at night
→ Quick access gun safes
Safes that open in seconds by wristband, fingerprint or push buttons.
If you want
Rifles and pistols together
→ Fireproof gun safes
Gun safes with fire figures, and what each figure is based on.

How to read a fire rating →

We looked at 227 products: the 46 that came up on Amazon in our search for “pistol safe fireproof”, plus 181 listings from our other fire and gun safe searches that mention both fire and handguns. Most of the first search were fingerprint pistol boxes that come with a fire bag, car boxes and tall gun cabinets. We kept front-door safes that state a fire time in the listing (all but one with a temperature), say they hold handguns or come from a gun brand, and are made to be fixed down. We kept one size per product line and one pick per brand, and skipped fire chests, which are light and made for papers, and a pistol box whose listing gives no fire time.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 227 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these safes ourselves. Sizes, weights and fire figures are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so. Four of the eight picks have little or no owner feedback by topic, and we say so for each.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.