8 Best Medium Size Safes, Scored on Build, Room, Security and Price

The short version

01
Best overall: Amazon Basics 1.8 Cu Ft Security Safe. An 8-gauge steel door and room for papers lying flat, at a low price.
4.7/5Check price →
02
Most shelves: Bukumo 23.6″ Tall Safe. Three shelves and a light in a tall, narrow body, at a low price.
4.4/5Check price →
03
Best for fire: SentrySafe STW123GDC. The only pick with a lab fire rating: UL, 1 hour at 1700°F.
4.4/5Check price →
04
Best heavy-duty: RPNB 2.12 Cu Ft Fire Safe. 95 lb, five steel bolts and 2.12 cubic feet inside, stated.
4.5/5Check price →
05
Best compact: Homirxan 2.0 Cub Safe. Only 14.2 inches tall, with a thick door and an alarm.
4.2/5Check price →
06
Most extras: FOWORE 19.7″ Digital Safe with Alarm. Alarm, silent mode, battery box, lining and a light.
4.3/5Check price →
07
Best fingerprint: ANBEGE Fingerprint Safe. Opens with a touch, with a code and keys as backups.
4.3/5Check price →
08
Best organizer: DAYI 2.0 Cu Ft Safe. Two shelves, hooks, a carpeted floor and a light.
4.3/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 8

Best overall

Lock: Keypad + key

Steel: 8-gauge door

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.7
8-gauge steel door, 14-gauge body, 37.5 lb; owners rate the quality highly
Capacity
4.7
1.8 cu ft; letter papers lie flat, a shelf
Security
4.3
Keypad and backup key; owners split on how secure it is
Value
4.7
Low-priced for its size; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the medium size safe most homes should start with. It stands 19.7 inches tall, 13.8 wide and 13 deep, so it fits a closet floor or a cabinet, and inside it’s 19.5 inches tall with a shelf: papers lie flat underneath, cash and a jewelry box sit on top. Amazon lists an 8-gauge steel door and a 14-gauge body, thicker steel than most safes at this price, with two live-locking bolts and concealed hinges that resist prying. A keypad opens it, with a backup key if the batteries die, and the hardware to bolt it to the floor or a wall comes in the box. Owners mostly rate the quality, the value and the room highly. It’s also the top pick on our best small safes, with the same scores.

The catch: the inside the listing gives (19.53 × 13.62 × 10.35 inches) works out to about 1.6 cubic feet, a little less than the 1.8 in the title. Some owners find the keypad fiddly or report it not opening, opinions on how secure it is are split, and owners mostly complain about durability, often the key cover. At 37.5 pounds, one person can carry it off, so bolt it down. It has no fire rating and isn’t waterproof.

Why we like it

✓ 8-gauge steel door (per Amazon’s listing)
✓ Letter papers lie flat, with a shelf
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ Keypad can be fiddly
✗ Key cover breaks, some say
✗ No fire rating

Outside

19.7 × 13.8 × 13 in

Inside

19.5 × 13.6 × 10.4 in

Weight

37.5 lb

Lock

Keypad + key

Mount

Floor or wall, hardware included

Skip it if papers you can’t replace go in too: see pick 3.

Check the cubic feet against the outside size.

Five of the eight picks list more room than they hold. Multiply the outside height, width and depth in inches and divide by 1,728: that’s the most the whole box can hold, and the walls, door and shelves take part of it. Four picks here list more cubic feet than even their outside measures; this one lists 1.8, and its own inside size works out to about 1.6.

Pick 2 of 8

Most shelves

Shelves: 3 + light

Size: 23.6 in tall

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
Reinforced steel, 40 lb, recessed hinges; owners call it sturdy
Capacity
4.7
23.6 in tall, 3 shelves; about 2.4 cu ft by its outside size, not 5.0
Security
4.3
Three live-locking bolts, 40 lb, bolts to a wall or floor
Value
4.7
Low-priced for its size; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the tall, narrow medium safe, at a low price. It stands 23.6 inches tall but only 14.57 wide and 12.2 deep, so it takes the floor space of a small safe, and three removable shelves and a light that comes on when the door opens give cash, jewelry, papers and a laptop each their own level. You set a 3- to 8-digit code. Three wrong codes in a row set off a 20-second alarm and lock the keypad for a while, and two override keys open it if the batteries die. Each keyhole has a serial number, so you can order a replacement key. Three live-locking bolts and recessed hinges hold the door, and expansion bolts in the box anchor it to a wall or floor. Owners mostly praise the quality, the easy code setup, the value and the room. It’s also on our best safe lockers, with the same scores.

The catch: the “5.0 cubic feet” in the title can’t be right. The whole box measures about 2.4 cubic feet outside, and the listing’s own spec says 4. The fire-resistant bag in the box is a pouch, and owners mostly say the safe itself isn’t fireproof. At 40 pounds, it can be carried off unless you bolt it down.

Why we like it

✓ 3 shelves and a light
✓ Wrong-code alarm and lockout
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ Capacity in the title is inflated
✗ Not fireproof, despite the bag
✗ 40 lb: bolt it down

Outside

23.6 × 14.57 × 12.2 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

40 lb

Lock

Code + 2 override keys

Mount

Wall or floor, expansion bolts included

Skip it if you want the thicker steel door: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 8

Best for fire

Fire: 1 hr · 1700°F (UL)

Inside: Locking drawer

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
Steel with fire insulation, pry-resistant hinge bar, about 87 lb; owners mostly complain about durability
Capacity
4.6
12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in inside, 1.23 cu ft; locking drawer, light
Security
4.6
Four live-locking bolts, 86 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.4
Mid-priced, with a UL fire rating

Here’s the deal: the medium size safe that guards papers from fire as well as theft. It’s UL Classified for 1 hour at 1700°F, ETL verified to survive a 15-foot fall in a fire and stay shut, and ETL verified for 24 hours in 8 inches of water. Outside it’s 16.3 inches wide, 19.3 deep and 17.8 tall; inside it’s 12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 inches, 1.23 cubic feet, with a locking drawer for cash and jewelry and a light. You set your own code on the keypad, and a key is the second lock. Four live-locking bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware come with it. Owners mostly say it’s reliable, roomy and fits easily in a closet. For more safes with a fire rating, see our best fireproof safes.

The catch: the fire insulation eats room and adds weight: about 87 pounds for 1.23 cubic feet. Owners mostly complain about the keypad, and some couldn’t open the safe after it stopped working; more complain about the lock than praise it. Owners also mostly complain about durability, and several say the plastic handle broke. The listing gives two weights, 86.69 and 90 pounds. It takes 4 AAA batteries, and the door needs 14.75 inches to open fully.

Why we like it

✓ UL: 1 hour at 1700°F
✓ Locking drawer and light
✓ ETL: 24 hours in water

Watch out for

✗ Keypad failures, owners say
✗ Plastic handle breaks, some say
✗ Heavy for 1.23 cu ft inside

Outside

16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in

Inside

12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in

Weight

86.69 or 90 lb (listed both)

Lock

Keypad + key

Mount

Floor, bolt-down hardware included

Skip it if you’d rather have no batteries in the lock: our best fireproof safes has a dial model of this safe with the same rating.

Pick 4 of 8

Best heavy-duty

Weight: 95.2 lb

Bolts: five 20 mm

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.7
Steel with 16 mm fire boards, 95.2 lb; few owners yet
Capacity
4.6
24.21 × 15.35 × 9.84 in inside, 2.12 cu ft; 2 adjustable shelves, but shallow
Security
4.6
Five 20 mm solid bolts, 95.2 lb, vibration alarm; listed as floor mount
Value
4.1
Priciest pick; few owners yet

Here’s the deal: the heaviest medium safe here, and the only one besides the SentrySafe that a burglar can’t simply pick up. It weighs 95.2 pounds, with 16 mm heat-resistant fire boards inside a steel body and five 20 mm solid steel bolts behind the door. Inside it’s 24.21 inches tall, 15.35 wide and 9.84 deep, 2.12 cubic feet as stated, with two shelves you can set at 16 heights and thick felt on every surface. A 10-digit touchscreen keypad and two backup keys open it, then you turn a 3-spoke handle. Shake the safe hard and a vibration alarm sounds and the keypad locks for a while; a silent mode keeps daily use quiet, and an external battery compartment means dead batteries won’t lock you out.

The catch: the listing says it “complies with the UL 72 standard” for 30 minutes at 1200°F, but names no lab, so we don’t count it as a fire rating; and it lists the safe as not water resistant. At 25.8 inches tall and 16.8 wide, it’s the largest pick here, and only 9.84 inches deep inside, so files stand sideways. Amazon lists it as floor mount but the listing doesn’t say what hardware comes with it. It’s the priciest pick, and few owners have rated it yet.

Why we like it

✓ 95.2 lb, five 20 mm bolts
✓ 2.12 cu ft inside, stated
✓ Felt-lined, 2 adjustable shelves

Watch out for

✗ No lab named for the fire claim
✗ Priciest pick
✗ Only 9.84 in deep inside

Outside

25.8 × 16.8 × 13.8 in

Inside

24.21 × 15.35 × 9.84 in

Weight

95.2 lb

Lock

Touchscreen keypad + 2 keys

Mount

Floor (hardware not listed)

Skip it if you want a named fire rating: see pick 3.

Pick 5 of 8

Best compact

Size: 14.2 in tall

Door: 45 mm

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
All steel, 45 mm door, concealed hinges, 26 lb; owners rate the quality highly
Capacity
4.4
14.2 in tall, a shelf; about 1.4 cu ft by its outside size, not 2.0
Security
4.3
Three 20 mm bolts, 26 lb, wrong-code alarm; made to anchor
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the smallest medium safe here, for a cabinet or a closet shelf. It measures 13 × 13 × 14.2 inches, so it fits where a tall safe won’t, yet it still takes letter papers on its floor. The body is solid steel with a 45 mm pry-resistant door, three 20 mm bolts and concealed hinges. You set your own code; three wrong codes set off an alarm and lock the safe for 20 seconds, a silence mode keeps it quiet, and two spare keys open it if you forget the code. A removable shelf and a felt-lined floor complete it. Owners mostly praise the quality, the value, the size and how secure it feels. More code safes are on our best digital safes.

The catch: the “2.0 cubic feet” is more than the whole box measures, about 1.4. The listing also contradicts itself: its spec says 14.2 inches tall, one bullet says 14.2 wide. The title says fireproof and waterproof, but the listing gives no rating, and owners mostly say it isn’t either. Owners also mostly find it hard to use, and some report the lock not working. At 26 pounds, bolt it down.

Why we like it

✓ 14.2 in tall: fits a cabinet
✓ 45 mm door, three 20 mm bolts
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ Capacity claim inflated
✗ Not fireproof, owners say
✗ Hard to use, many owners say

Outside

13 × 13 × 14.2 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

26 lb

Lock

Code + 2 spare keys

Mount

Floor, anchoring design

Skip it if you need the room for files and boxes: see pick 2.

Pick 6 of 8

Most extras

Lock: Code, 2 keys, battery box

Alarm: Wrong code + silent mode

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.3
Welded cold-rolled steel, recessed door, 29.3 lb; owners rate the quality highly
Capacity
4.6
19.7 in tall, a shelf; about 1.9 cu ft by its outside size, not 3.3
Security
4.3
Three steel bolts, 29.3 lb, bolts to a wall or floor
Value
4.6
Low-to-mid price; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the medium safe with every convenience on the list. Three wrong codes set off the alarm and lock the safe for a while, a silent mode keeps daily use quiet, and a low-battery warning tells you before it’s a problem. The angled keypad takes your own code, and two spare keys and an external battery box mean a dead battery or a lost key won’t lock you out. It’s 19.68 × 13.78 × 12.2 inches, with a welded body, a recessed pry-resistant door and three solid steel bolts, plus a removable shelf, soft lining that keeps jewelry from scratches and an LED light. Pre-drilled holes on the back and bottom let you anchor it to a wall or floor. Owners mostly praise the quality, the easy setup, the room and the value. It’s also on our best home safes for valuables.

The catch: the listed 3.3 cubic feet is more than the outside measures, about 1.9. At 29.3 pounds, owners are split on the weight, and it must be bolted down. Some owners call it fireproof, but FOWORE gives the safe no fire rating. Owner feedback is shared across FOWORE’s sizes.

Why we like it

✓ Alarm, silent mode, low-battery warning
✓ Battery box and 2 spare keys
✓ Soft lining and LED light

Watch out for

✗ Capacity claim inflated
✗ Light at 29.3 lb: bolt it down
✗ No fire rating

Outside

19.68 × 13.78 × 12.2 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

29.3 lb

Lock

Code, 2 keys, battery box

Mount

Wall or floor, pre-drilled

Skip it if you want thicker steel for about the same price: see pick 1.

Pick 7 of 8

Best fingerprint

Lock: Fingerprint + code + keys

Weight: 13 lb

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.1
Steel body, reinforced door panel, 13 lb; no owner topics yet
Capacity
4.6
17.72 in tall, a shelf and 2 dividers; listed 1.8 cu ft is about its outside size
Security
4.3
Fingerprint, code and keys, 3 pry-resistant bolts; 13 lb, expansion screws
Value
4.6
Low-priced; few owners yet

Here’s the deal: the medium safe that opens with a touch. Its own listing calls it a medium safe box: 14.96 inches wide, 12.2 deep and 17.72 tall, with a shelf and two removable dividers. The reader stores up to 50 fingerprints and reads one in about 0.2 seconds, so the whole family can use it without sharing a code, and a keypad code and backup keys are the other two ways in. A magnetic light turns on when the door opens and comes off to use elsewhere, a low-battery warning and an external power port help prevent lockouts, and a soft liner covers the floor. Pre-drilled holes and expansion screws fix it inside a closet or cabinet. More safes that open with a finger are on our best fingerprint safes.

The catch: at 13 pounds, it’s the lightest pick by far, and ANBEGE itself says it guards against casual access by kids, guests and roommates, not burglars. Bolt it down, and don’t count on it against tools. The listed 1.8 cubic feet is about the size of the whole box, so the inside is smaller. Few owners have rated it so far, and it has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ Fingerprint, code or key
✓ Up to 50 fingerprints
✓ Shelf, 2 dividers, removable light

Watch out for

✗ 13 lb: the lightest here
✗ Made for casual access, maker says
✗ Few owner reviews yet

Outside

17.72 × 14.96 × 12.2 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

13 lb

Lock

Fingerprint + code + keys

Mount

Closet or cabinet, expansion screws included

Skip it if theft is the worry, not curious hands: see pick 4.

Pick 8 of 8

Best organizer

Inside: 2 shelves + hooks

Bolts: four 1.2-inch

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.1
One-piece bent steel, 33.1 lb; owners split on sturdiness, more complaints
Capacity
4.6
17.8 in tall, 2 shelves and hooks; about 1.8 cu ft by its outside size, not 2.0
Security
4.4
Four 1.2-inch live bolts, alarm on wrong codes or force, 33.1 lb; owners mostly say it’s secure
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners mostly rate the value

Here’s the deal: the medium safe that’s easiest to organize. Inside, two removable shelves, built-in hooks, a carpeted floor and a sensor light give papers, cash, jewelry and keys each a place. It’s 15 inches wide, 11.9 deep and 17.8 tall. Four live-locking bolts, 1.2 inches across, hold a pry-resistant door, and a 70-decibel alarm sounds after three wrong codes or a forced attack. You open it with a 3- to 8-digit code or a backup key, and a fire and water bag for papers comes in the box. Owners mostly like the size and how it works, and more say it’s secure than not. For more safes with lots of room, see our best home safes.

The catch: owners are split on sturdiness, with more complaints than praise, and some say it isn’t worth the money. The “2.0 cubic feet” is a little more than the whole box measures, about 1.8. The bag is a pouch; the safe itself has no fire rating. At 33.1 pounds, bolt it down; Amazon lists it as wall mount.

Why we like it

✓ 2 shelves, hooks and a light
✓ Four 1.2-inch live bolts
✓ Alarm on wrong codes or force

Watch out for

✗ Sturdiness complaints
✗ Capacity claim a little high
✗ No fire rating

Outside

17.8 × 15 × 11.9 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

33.1 lb

Lock

Code + backup key

Mount

Wall

Skip it if you want the sturdiest build for the price: see pick 1.

PickLockSteelOutsideInsideWeightMountShelves
Amazon Basics 1.8 Cu Ft Security Safe
Best overall
4.7/5
Check price
Keypad + key8-gauge door19.7 × 13.8 × 13 in19.5 × 13.6 × 10.4 in37.5 lbFloor or wall, hardware included–
Bukumo 23.6″ Tall Safe
Most shelves
4.4/5
Check price
Code + 2 override keys–23.6 × 14.57 × 12.2 inNot listed40 lbWall or floor, expansion bolts included3 + light
SentrySafe STW123GDC
Best for fire
4.4/5
Check price
Keypad + key–16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 inLocking drawer86.69 or 90 lb (listed both)Floor, bolt-down hardware included–
RPNB 2.12 Cu Ft Fire Safe
Best heavy-duty
4.5/5
Check price
Touchscreen keypad + 2 keys–25.8 × 16.8 × 13.8 in24.21 × 15.35 × 9.84 in95.2 lbFloor (hardware not listed)–
Homirxan 2.0 Cub Safe
Best compact
4.2/5
Check price
Code + 2 spare keys–13 × 13 × 14.2 inNot listed26 lbFloor, anchoring design–
FOWORE 19.7″ Digital Safe with Alarm
Most extras
4.3/5
Check price
Code, 2 keys, battery box–19.68 × 13.78 × 12.2 inNot listed29.3 lbWall or floor, pre-drilled–
ANBEGE Fingerprint Safe
Best fingerprint
4.3/5
Check price
Fingerprint + code + keys–17.72 × 14.96 × 12.2 inNot listed13 lbCloset or cabinet, expansion screws included–
DAYI 2.0 Cu Ft Safe
Best organizer
4.3/5
Check price
Code + backup key–17.8 × 15 × 11.9 in2 shelves + hooks33.1 lbWall–

A medium size safe is a home safe about 13 to 17 inches wide and 14 to 26 inches tall: big enough for papers lying flat, cash, jewelry and a passport or two, small enough for a closet floor or a cabinet. Here’s how to choose one.

Small safes are about 10 inches tall and hold under a cubic foot; big safes stand waist-high or taller and hold 5 to 12 cubic feet. A medium size safe for home sits between: roughly 1.2 to 2.4 cubic feet by its real size. Pick 5 is the most compact at 14.2 inches tall, pick 4 the largest at 25.8. Want smaller? See our best small safes. Want taller? See our best tall safes.

Less than the titles say. Five of the eight picks list more room than they hold, so do the math: multiply the outside height, width and depth in inches and divide by 1,728; that’s the most the whole box can hold. Pick 1 is about 1.6 cubic feet inside, pick 3 1.23 and pick 4 2.12, all from their stated insides; picks 2, 5, 6, 7 and 8 measure about 2.4, 1.4, 1.9, 1.9 and 1.8 outside, so their insides are smaller still. Letter papers lying flat need about 9 × 12 inches of floor; every pick here has that.

It will stop a quick grab, not a thief with power tools. None has a burglary rating, so they score 4.3 to 4.6 out of 5 on security. Weight matters most at this size: picks 3 and 4 weigh about 87 and 95 pounds, while the others weigh 13 to 40 pounds and are only as strong as the bolts that hold them down. For heavy steel with floor bolts in the box, see our best safes that bolt to the floor.

Use every hole. Picks 1, 2 and 6 bolt to a floor or wall with the hardware or holes they come with, pick 3 bolts to the floor with its kit, pick 7 fixes inside a closet or cabinet with expansion screws, and picks 4, 5 and 8 are listed for floor or wall mounting without naming the hardware. Drill from inside the safe into concrete or a floor joist, so the bolt heads are behind the locked door, and put it in a closet corner, out of sight.

For papers you can’t replace, yes: fire safes are rated to keep the inside under 350°F, where paper starts to char, and a house fire runs far hotter. Only pick 3 has a lab rating, 1 hour at 1700°F. Pick 4 claims 30 minutes at 1200°F with no lab named, and several others say “fireproof” in the title with no rating at all; their owners mostly say they aren’t. The fire bags that come with some are pouches. A good split: valuables in a steel safe, papers in a rated bag inside it; see our best fireproof bags, or a fire-rated safe from our best fireproof safes.

The lock is what owners of home safes complain about most: keypads that stop taking a code, or a door that won’t open once set. Every pick has a backup key, so keep it somewhere other than the safe, and test your code a few times before you fill it. Picks 4, 6 and 7 add a battery box or an external power port, so dead batteries don’t lock you out. Pick 7 opens with a fingerprint, with a code and keys behind it.

One last tip: if you mainly keep jewelry, cash and watches, see our best home safes for valuables. And if you need room for a whole household’s papers and more, see our best big safes.

Still not sure? Get the Amazon Basics 1.8 Cu Ft Security Safe.
An 8-gauge steel door, room for papers lying flat, a closet-friendly size, at a low price.
Check price on Amazon →
What is the best medium size safe?

For most homes, pick 1: an 8-gauge steel door, room for papers lying flat and bolts to fix it down, at a low price. Choose pick 2 for three shelves in a tall, narrow body, pick 3 if papers need a fire rating, pick 4 for the most weight, pick 5 for the smallest body, pick 6 for an alarm and a battery box, pick 7 for a fingerprint lock and pick 8 for shelves and hooks.

What size is a medium safe?

About 13 to 17 inches wide and 14 to 26 inches tall, holding roughly 1.2 to 2.4 cubic feet inside. Check the outside size: many listings claim more cubic feet than the whole box measures.

How heavy is a medium size safe?

Plain steel ones weigh 13 to 40 pounds; fire-rated or heavy-duty ones weigh 85 to 95 pounds, like picks 3 and 4. The light ones need to be bolted down.

Is a medium size safe fireproof?

Most aren’t. Of the eight here, only pick 3 has a lab fire rating: UL Classified for 1 hour at 1700°F. For more fire-rated safes, see our best fireproof safes.

Where should I put a medium size safe for home?

Out of sight, bolted to the floor or a wall: a closet corner, a cabinet or a utility room. Avoid the master bedroom floor, where burglars often look first, and a damp basement, which is hard on papers.

What if the batteries die or I forget the code?

Every pick has a backup key that opens it without the code, so keep it somewhere other than the safe. Picks 4 and 6 also have an external battery box, and pick 7 an external power port.

Find your fit

A medium size safe fits a closet and holds papers, cash and jewelry. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Papers, cash and jewelry in a closet-size safe
→ Medium size safes (you're here)
Safes about 13 to 17 inches wide and 14 to 26 inches tall, with a code and a backup key.
If you want
A fire rating
→ Fireproof safes
Rated for an hour at 1700°F, with live-locking bolts and a bolt-down kit.
If you want
Heavy steel that bolts to the floor
→ Safes that bolt to the floor
Safes up to about 175 pounds, with live bolts and floor bolts in the box.
If you want
Room for much more
→ Big safes
Floor-standing safes up to about 12 cubic feet, with shelves and inner lock boxes.

How to choose a medium size safe →

We looked at 201 products that show up on Amazon in our searches for a medium size safe and a medium size safe for home, the plain searches and filtered ones. Most were small keypad safes, fire chests, lock boxes, cash boxes and gun safes. We kept home safes about 13 to 17 inches wide and 14 to 26 inches tall, with a code or fingerprint lock and a backup key. We set aside small and mini safes, big floor safes, lock boxes, cash boxes, fire chests, gun safes and key safes.

Many medium safes are sold under more than one brand with the same outside size, so we kept one of each body and one size of each line, choosing the one with the best owner feedback. We checked each listed capacity against the outside size, and we don’t count fire claims with no named lab.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 201 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these ourselves. We read the listings and what owners report.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.