8 Best Medium Safes, Scored on Build, Room, Security and Price

The short version

01
Best overall: SentrySafe SFW123DSB Dial Safe. UL-rated for 1 hour at 1700°F, waterproof, with a dial that needs no batteries.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Best budget: Amazon Basics 1.52 Cu Ft Security Safe. An 8-gauge steel door and a keypad, at the lowest price here.
4.7/5Check price →
03
Most room: Amazon Basics 2.13 Cu Ft Fire & Water Safe. 2.13 cubic feet inside, with a 1-hour fire rating from Intertek.
4.7/5Check price →
04
Best for fire: Master Lock STW205GYC. The only 2-hour UL fire rating here, in a 192 lb body.
4.3/5Check price →
05
Most shelves: Bukumo 23.7″ Fire Safe. Three shelves and a light in a tall, narrow body, at a low price.
4.4/5Check price →
06
Best fingerprint: TIGERKING Fingerprint Fire Safe. Opens with a touch, with an 81.9 lb body and four 1-inch bolts.
4.5/5Check price →
07
Best with a fire bag: FOWORE 16.54″ Safe. A fire and water bag in the box, plus an alarm, at a low price.
4.3/5Check price →
08
Best compact: Mitlvge 2.0 Cu Ft Fire Safe. Only about 14 inches tall, with a fire-lined body.
4.2/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 8

Best overall

Fire: 1 hr · 1700°F (UL)

Lock: Dial + key, no batteries

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.6
Steel with fire insulation, pry-resistant hinge bar, 86 lb; owners split on the build
Capacity
4.6
13.8 × 12.6 × 11.9 in inside, 1.23 cu ft; a shelf
Security
4.6
Four live-locking bolts, 86 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.7
Low-priced for a UL-rated safe; owners mostly call it good value

Here’s the deal: the medium safe that covers fire, water and theft in one closet-size box. It’s UL Classified for 1 hour at 1700°F, ETL verified to survive a 15-foot fall in a fire and stay shut, and ETL verified for 24 hours in 8 inches of water. Outside it’s 16.3 inches wide, 19.3 deep and 17.8 tall; inside it’s 12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 inches, 1.23 cubic feet, with a shelf, so papers lie flat with cash and jewelry above. A dial combination opens it, with a key as the second lock, so there are no batteries to die. Four live-locking bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware come with it. Owners mostly call it good value, secure and roomy enough for full-size papers. For more dial safes, see our best combination safes.

The catch: owners mostly find the dial hard to open, and some say the door is stiff. They’re split on the build, and several say the plastic handle feels flimsy. At 86 pounds it’s hard to carry off, but heavy to move into a closet, too. The listing calls it a dial safe, while Amazon’s lock field says electronic. Owner feedback is shared with SentrySafe’s bigger dial model.

Why we like it

✓ UL: 1 hour at 1700°F
✓ ETL: 24 hours in water
✓ Dial lock: no batteries

Watch out for

✗ Dial is hard to open, owners say
✗ Plastic handle feels flimsy, some say
✗ 86 lb to carry in

Outside

16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in

Inside

12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in

Weight

86 lb

Lock

Dial + key

Mount

Floor, bolt-down hardware included

Skip it if you’d rather open it with a code: see pick 2, or pick 3 for a keypad with a fire rating.

Check the cubic feet against the outside size.

Four of the eight picks list more room than they hold. Multiply the outside height, width and depth in inches and divide by 1,728: that’s the most the whole box can hold, and the walls, door and shelves take part of it. This one states 1.23 cubic feet, and its inside size, 13.8 × 12.6 × 11.9 inches, backs that up.

Pick 2 of 8

Best budget

Lock: Keypad + key

Steel: 8-gauge door

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.7
8-gauge steel door, 14-gauge body, 37.7 lb; owners rate the quality highly
Capacity
4.6
1.52 cu ft, 16.5 in tall, a shelf
Security
4.3
Two live bolts, 37.7 lb, bolts to a floor or wall
Value
4.7
Lowest-priced pick; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the low-priced medium safe most homes can start with. It stands 16.5 inches tall, 13.8 wide and 13 deep, so it fits a closet floor or a cabinet, and a shelf splits papers below from cash and jewelry above. Amazon lists an 8-gauge steel door and a 14-gauge body, thicker steel than most safes at this price, with two live door bolts and concealed hinges against prying. A keypad takes your own code, with a backup key if the batteries die, and the holes and bolts to fix it to a floor or a wall come in the box. Owners mostly rate the quality, the value and the room highly, and most call it secure.

The catch: it has no fire rating and isn’t water resistant. At 37.7 pounds, one person can carry it off, so bolt it down. Some owners report it not opening, and owners mostly complain about durability, often the key cover. The 1.52 cubic feet is believable: the whole box measures about 1.7. Owner feedback is shared with Amazon Basics’ other sizes of this safe.

Why we like it

✓ 8-gauge steel door (per Amazon’s listing)
✓ Lowest-priced pick
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ No fire rating
✗ Key cover breaks, some say
✗ 37.7 lb: bolt it down

Outside

16.5 × 13.8 × 13 in

Inside

10.35 in deep

Weight

37.7 lb

Lock

Keypad + key

Mount

Floor or wall, hardware included

Skip it if papers you can’t replace go in too: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 8

Most room

Inside: 2.13 cu ft, stated · Fire: 1 hr

1700°F (Intertek)

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.7
136 lb steel body with fire insulation; owner feedback pooled with other Amazon Basics safes
Capacity
4.7
2.13 cu ft inside, stated; a shelf and a drawer
Security
4.6
Six live-locking bolts, 136 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.3
Upper-priced; owner feedback is pooled with other Amazon Basics safes

Here’s the deal: the roomiest medium safe here, with a fire rating behind it. Intertek tested it for 1 hour at 1700°F and for 24 hours in 8 inches of water. Inside it holds 2.13 cubic feet, stated, with a removable shelf, a drawer and a light, so files, a laptop and a jewelry box each get a place. Six live-locking bolts hold the door, and at 136 pounds with bolt-down hardware in the box, it isn’t going anywhere once it’s fixed down. A keypad opens it. It’s also on our best fireproof and waterproof home safes, with the same security and value scores.

The catch: at 24 inches tall, 20.87 wide and 19 deep, it’s the bulkiest pick here, so measure your closet first, and plan on two people to move it. It’s upper-priced. The listing calls the lock a keypad in the title and a “preset digital dial combination” in a bullet. Owner feedback is pooled with other Amazon Basics safes; owners there mostly like how it works and the size, but are split on ease of use, and more complain about durability than praise it.

Why we like it

✓ 2.13 cu ft inside, stated
✓ Intertek: 1 hour at 1700°F
✓ Six live-locking bolts, 136 lb

Watch out for

✗ Bulky: 20.87 in wide, 19 in deep
✗ Upper-priced
✗ Keypad complaints in pooled feedback

Outside

24 × 20.87 × 19 in

Inside

2.13 cu ft

Weight

136 lb

Lock

Keypad

Mount

Floor, bolt-down hardware included

Skip it if your closet is tight: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 8

Best for fire

Fire: 2 hr · 1850°F (UL)

Weight: 192 lb

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.9
192 lb steel body with 2-hour fire insulation, pry-resistant hinge bar; little owner feedback yet
Capacity
4.7
19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in inside, 2.0 cu ft
Security
4.7
Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.0
Pricey; little owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: the medium safe for papers you can never replace. It’s UL Classified for 2 hours at 1850°F, twice the time of the other rated picks, and ETL verified for 24 hours in 5 inches of water. Inside it’s 19.6 inches tall, 14.8 wide and 11.9 deep, 2.0 cubic feet, so file folders stand upright. Six 1-inch door bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and a 192-pound body make it the hardest pick here to break into or carry off, and bolt-down hardware comes with it. A keypad opens it. For more safes rated for two hours, see our best 2-hour fireproof safes.

The catch: it’s the priciest pick by a wide margin, and at 192 pounds it needs two or three people and a clear path to get it into place. Few owners have rated it yet, so we can’t say how the keypad holds up. The listing doesn’t mention a backup key.

Why we like it

✓ UL: 2 hours at 1850°F
✓ Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb
✓ 2.0 cu ft inside, stated

Watch out for

✗ Priciest pick
✗ 192 lb: hard to move in
✗ Few owner reviews yet

Outside

23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in

Inside

19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in

Weight

192 lb

Lock

Keypad

Mount

Floor, bolt-down hardware included

Skip it if the price is too much: see pick 3 for a 1-hour rating with more room.

Pick 5 of 8

Most shelves

Shelves: 3 + light

Size: 23.7 in tall

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
Thick steel door, fire-lined body, 43 lb; owners rate the quality and durability
Capacity
4.7
22.5 × 13.8 × 11 in inside, about 2 cu ft; 3 shelves
Security
4.3
43 lb, alarm, 2 plugged holes to anchor it to a wall
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners mostly call it good value

Here’s the deal: the tall, narrow medium safe, at a low price. It stands 23.7 inches tall but only 15 wide and 12.2 deep, so it takes the floor space of a small safe, and three removable shelves and a light that comes on when the door opens give papers, cash, jewelry and a laptop up to 14 inches each their own level. The body is fire-lined steel with a thick door, 43 pounds in all. A keypad opens it, with spare keys and an external battery case as backups, and three wrong codes set off an alarm, with a mute mode for quiet use. Owners mostly praise the quality, the durability, the room and the value, and say it fits their closets well.

The catch: the “5.0 cubic feet” in the title can’t be right: its own inside size, 22.5 × 13.8 × 11 inches, works out to about 2. It claims 35 minutes at 1700°F, “independently tested”, but names no lab, so we don’t count it as a fire rating. It anchors only to a wall, through two factory-sealed holes in the back; there are no floor holes. At 43 pounds, anchor it. The door needs about 24 inches of depth to open.

Why we like it

✓ 3 shelves and a light
✓ Wrong-code alarm and mute mode
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ Capacity in the title is inflated
✗ No lab named for the fire claim
✗ Wall anchor only, no floor holes

Outside

23.7 × 15 × 12.2 in

Inside

22.5 × 13.8 × 11 in

Weight

43 lb

Lock

Keypad + spare keys

Mount

Wall, 2 sealed holes in the back

Skip it if you want a named fire rating: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 8

Best fingerprint

Lock: Fingerprint + code + key

Weight: 81.9 lb

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.6
81.9 lb steel body, 0.77-inch door, fire-lined; owners call it sturdy
Capacity
4.6
26 in tall, 2 shelves; the listed 3.47 cu ft is about its outside size
Security
4.4
81.9 lb, four 1-inch bolts, 4 anchor bolts, alarm
Value
4.6
Upper-mid price; owners of this line rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the medium safe that opens with a touch, in a heavy body. It stores up to 29 fingerprints, so the family can use it without sharing a code, with a PIN and an emergency key as backups. The steel body weighs 81.9 pounds, with a 0.77-inch door and four 1-inch live-locking bolts, and four expansion bolts in the box anchor it to the floor. A tamper alarm sounds after three wrong entries or a hard shake. Inside, two removable shelves and an LED light keep papers, cash and jewelry in order. Owners mostly praise the quality, the sturdiness, the easy setup and the value. More safes that open with a finger are on our best fingerprint safes.

The catch: at 26 inches tall it’s the tallest pick here, and the listed 3.47 cubic feet is about the size of the whole box, so the inside is smaller. It says it “complies with the UL 72 standard” for 30 minutes at 1700°F but names no lab, so we don’t count it as a fire rating, and it isn’t water resistant. Owners are split on the locking mechanism, and some report trouble opening it.

Why we like it

✓ Fingerprint, PIN or key
✓ 81.9 lb, four 1-inch bolts
✓ Owners call it sturdy

Watch out for

✗ No lab named for the fire claim
✗ Listed capacity is about its outside size
✗ Lock complaints from some owners

Outside

26 × 13.8 × 17 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

81.9 lb

Lock

Fingerprint + PIN + key

Mount

Floor, 4 expansion bolts included

Skip it if a lab fire rating matters more than the fingerprint: see pick 1.

Pick 7 of 8

Best with a fire bag

Extra: Fire and water bag

Alarm: Wrong code + silent mode

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.3
Cold-rolled steel, 50 mm door, 25 lb; owners rate the quality
Capacity
4.4
16.54 in tall, a shelf; about 1.6 cu ft by its outside size, not 2.8
Security
4.3
Three 20 mm bolts, alarm, 25 lb; bolts to a wall or floor
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the low-priced medium safe that comes with a fire and water bag for your papers. It’s 16.54 inches tall, 13.78 wide and 12.2 deep, with a cold-rolled steel body, a 50 mm door and three 20 mm bolts. Three wrong codes lock the keypad and set off an alarm, and a silent mode keeps daily use quiet. You set your own code, with two spare keys and an external battery compartment as backups. A removable shelf and an LED light sit inside, and two pre-drilled holes in the back and two in the bottom fix it to a wall or floor. Owners mostly praise the quality, the value, how secure it feels and the room. For more fire bags, see our best fireproof bags.

The catch: the listed 2.8 cubic feet is far more than the whole box measures, about 1.6. The bag is a pouch; the safe itself has no fire rating, and owners mostly say it isn’t fireproof. At 25 pounds it’s the lightest pick, so bolt it down. The listing swaps width and depth in one bullet. Owner feedback is shared across FOWORE’s sizes.

Why we like it

✓ Fire and water bag in the box
✓ Alarm and silent mode
✓ Battery box and 2 spare keys

Watch out for

✗ Capacity claim inflated
✗ Not fireproof, owners say
✗ 25 lb: the lightest here

Outside

16.54 × 13.78 × 12.2 in

Inside

Not listed

Weight

25 lb

Lock

Keypad, 2 keys, battery box

Mount

Wall or floor, pre-drilled

Skip it if you want thicker steel for about the same price: see pick 2.

Pick 8 of 8

Best compact

Size: About 14 in tall

Inside: Felt lining + light

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.3
Alloy steel with a fire lining, 27 lb; owners rate the quality
Capacity
4.4
13.3 × 12.9 × 12.1 in inside by the listing: about 1.2 cu ft, not 2.0; a shelf
Security
4.3
27 lb, three 0.98-in bolts, alarm; anchors to a wall
Value
4.6
Low-to-mid price; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: the smallest medium safe here, for a cabinet or a closet shelf. It’s about 14 inches tall, 13.7 wide and 12.9 deep, yet the floor still takes letter papers, and a removable shelf, a felt lining and an LED light sit inside. Three solid 0.98-inch bolts and concealed hinges hold the door. A keypad opens it, with two backup keys and an external battery box, so dead batteries won’t lock you out, and wrong codes set off an alarm and a lockout, with a silent mode. Each key has a serial number for replacements. Pre-drilled holes anchor it to a wall, and plugs seal them again for fire. Owners mostly praise the quality, how secure it feels, the value and the easy setup.

The catch: the “2.0 cubic feet” is not what fits: its own inside size works out to about 1.2. It claims 35 minutes at 1700°F, “built to meet” UL standards with SGS-tested materials, but it has no UL listing, so we don’t count it as a fire rating; the inside is nearly as big as the outside, which leaves little room for insulation. The listing also swaps height and depth between its spec and a bullet. At 27 pounds, anchor it. Few owners have rated it so far.

Why we like it

✓ About 14 in tall: fits a cabinet
✓ Battery box and 2 backup keys
✓ Felt lining and LED light

Watch out for

✗ Capacity claim inflated
✗ Fire claim has no UL listing
✗ Few owner reviews yet

Outside

14 × 13.7 × 12.9 in

Inside

13.3 × 12.9 × 12.1 in

Weight

27 lb

Lock

Keypad + 2 keys

Mount

Wall, pre-drilled

Skip it if you need more room for files: see pick 5.

PickFireLockOutsideInsideWeightMountSteel
SentrySafe SFW123DSB Dial Safe
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
1 hr · 1700°F (UL)Dial + key, no batteries16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 in86 lbFloor, bolt-down hardware included–
Amazon Basics 1.52 Cu Ft Security Safe
Best budget
4.7/5
Check price
–Keypad + key16.5 × 13.8 × 13 in10.35 in deep37.7 lbFloor or wall, hardware included8-gauge door
Amazon Basics 2.13 Cu Ft Fire & Water Safe
Most room
4.7/5
Check price
–Keypad24 × 20.87 × 19 in2.13 cu ft, stated · Fire: 1 hr136 lbFloor, bolt-down hardware included–
Master Lock STW205GYC
Best for fire
4.3/5
Check price
2 hr · 1850°F (UL)Keypad23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in192 lbFloor, bolt-down hardware included–
Bukumo 23.7″ Fire Safe
Most shelves
4.4/5
Check price
–Keypad + spare keys23.7 × 15 × 12.2 in22.5 × 13.8 × 11 in43 lbWall, 2 sealed holes in the back–
TIGERKING Fingerprint Fire Safe
Best fingerprint
4.5/5
Check price
–Fingerprint + code + key26 × 13.8 × 17 inNot listed81.9 lbFloor, 4 expansion bolts included–
FOWORE 16.54″ Safe
Best with a fire bag
4.3/5
Check price
–Keypad, 2 keys, battery box16.54 × 13.78 × 12.2 inNot listed25 lbWall or floor, pre-drilled–
Mitlvge 2.0 Cu Ft Fire Safe
Best compact
4.2/5
Check price
–Keypad + 2 keys14 × 13.7 × 12.9 inFelt lining + light27 lbWall, pre-drilled–

A medium safe is a home safe about 14 to 26 inches tall that holds roughly 1.2 to 2.2 cubic feet inside: big enough for papers lying flat, cash, jewelry and a passport or two, small enough for a closet floor or a cabinet. Here’s how to choose one.

Small safes are about 10 inches tall and hold under a cubic foot; big safes stand waist-high or taller and hold 5 to 12 cubic feet. A medium safe for home sits between. Pick 8 is the most compact at about 14 inches tall, pick 6 the tallest at 26. Want smaller? See our best small safes. Want taller? See our best tall safes.

Less than many titles say. Four of the eight picks list more room than they hold, so do the math: multiply the outside height, width and depth in inches and divide by 1,728; that’s the most the whole box can hold. Picks 1, 3 and 4 state 1.23, 2.13 and 2.0 cubic feet inside, and their sizes back that up. Pick 5 lists 5.0 but its inside works out to about 2, pick 8 lists 2.0 but holds about 1.2, pick 7 lists 2.8 but measures about 1.6 outside, and pick 6’s listed 3.47 is about its outside size. Letter papers lying flat need about 9 × 12 inches of floor; every pick here has that.

Only those tested by a named lab. Picks 1 and 4 are UL Classified, for 1 hour at 1700°F and 2 hours at 1850°F, and pick 3 was tested by Intertek for 1 hour at 1700°F. Picks 5, 6 and 8 claim 30 to 35 minutes but name no lab, so we don’t count them, and pick 7’s fire bag is a pouch for papers, not a rated safe. A fire safe keeps the inside under 350°F, where paper starts to char, and a house fire runs far hotter. For more rated safes, see our best fireproof safes.

It will stop a quick grab, not a thief with power tools. None has a burglary rating, so they score 4.3 to 4.7 out of 5 on security. Weight matters most at this size: picks 1, 3, 4 and 6 weigh 82 to 192 pounds, while picks 2, 5, 7 and 8 weigh 25 to 43 pounds and are only as strong as the bolts that hold them down. For heavy steel with floor bolts in the box, see our best safes that bolt to the floor.

Use every hole. Picks 1, 3 and 4 bolt to the floor with their kits, pick 6 with four expansion bolts, picks 2 and 7 to a floor or wall, and picks 5 and 8 to a wall only. Drill from inside the safe into concrete, a floor joist or a wall stud, so the bolt heads are behind the locked door, and put it in a closet corner, out of sight.

A dial needs no batteries and can’t short out, but it’s slow, and owners of pick 1 mostly find it hard to open. A keypad is quick, and every keypad pick but pick 4 lists a backup key or an external battery box, so dead batteries don’t lock you out. A fingerprint lock, like pick 6’s, is the fastest for a family, with a PIN and a key behind it. Keep any backup key somewhere other than the safe, and test your code a few times before you fill it.

One last tip: if you mainly keep documents, a fire- and water-rated safe matters more than size; see our best fireproof and waterproof home safes. And if you need room for a whole household’s papers and more, see our best big safes.

Still not sure? Get the SentrySafe SFW123DSB Dial Safe.
A UL fire rating, a water rating and a dial with no batteries, in a closet-size body.
Check price on Amazon →
What is the best medium safe?

For most homes, pick 1: UL-rated for 1 hour at 1700°F, waterproof, with four live-locking bolts and a dial that needs no batteries. Choose pick 2 for the lowest price, pick 3 for the most room with a fire rating, pick 4 for a 2-hour fire rating, pick 5 for three shelves, pick 6 for a fingerprint lock, pick 7 for a fire bag in the box and pick 8 for the smallest body.

What size is a medium safe?

About 14 to 26 inches tall, holding roughly 1.2 to 2.2 cubic feet inside. Check the outside size: many listings claim more cubic feet than the whole box measures.

How heavy is a medium safe?

Plain steel ones weigh 25 to 43 pounds; fire-rated or heavy ones weigh 82 to 192 pounds, like picks 1, 3, 4 and 6. The light ones need to be bolted down.

Is a medium safe for home fireproof?

Only some are. Of the eight here, picks 1, 3 and 4 have a lab fire rating, from UL or Intertek. Others say “fireproof” or claim 30 to 35 minutes with no lab named. For more fire-rated safes, see our best fireproof safes.

Where should I put a medium safe?

Out of sight, bolted to the floor or a wall: a closet corner, a cabinet or a utility room. Avoid the master bedroom floor, where burglars often look first, and a damp basement, which is hard on papers.

What if the batteries die or I forget the code?

Pick 1 has a dial, so it needs no batteries, and a key. Picks 2, 5, 6, 7 and 8 have backup keys, and picks 5, 7 and 8 an external battery box too. Keep the key somewhere other than the safe.

Find your fit

A medium safe fits a closet and holds papers, cash and jewelry. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Papers, cash and jewelry in a closet-size safe
→ Medium safes (you're here)
Safes about 14 to 26 inches tall, from lab fire-rated safes to low-priced keypad safes.
If you want
A fire rating
→ Fireproof safes
Rated for an hour at 1700°F, with live-locking bolts and a bolt-down kit.
If you want
Heavy steel that bolts to the floor
→ Safes that bolt to the floor
Safes up to about 175 pounds, with live bolts and floor bolts in the box.
If you want
Room for much more
→ Big safes
Floor-standing safes up to about 12 cubic feet, with shelves and inner lock boxes.

How to choose a medium safe →

We looked at 230 products that show up on Amazon in our searches for a medium safe, a medium safe for home and a medium size safe, the plain searches and filtered ones. Most were small keypad safes, fire chests, lock boxes, cash boxes and gun safes. We kept home safes about 14 to 26 inches tall that hold roughly 1 to 2 cubic feet inside, with a backup key or a lock that needs no batteries. We set aside small and mini safes, big floor safes over 26 inches tall, lock boxes, cash boxes, fire chests, gun safes and drop safes.

Many medium safes are sold under more than one brand with the same outside size, so we kept one of each body and one size of each line, choosing the one with the best owner feedback. We checked each listed capacity against the outside size, and we don’t count fire claims with no named lab.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 230 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these ourselves. We read the listings and what owners report.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.