10 Best Cash Depository Safes, Scored on Drop, Capacity, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: Viking VS-40DS. Motorized deadbolts, a deep anti-fish tray and 51 lb of steel.
4.7/5Check price →
02
Best value: KAER 2.6 Depository Safe. A deep, toothed anti-fishing baffle at a low price.
4.5/5Check price →
03
Best for big drops: Sanfnz 7.5 Tall Drop Safe. The biggest body here, with a locking top drawer.
4.4/5Check price →
04
Best multi-user keypad: Greenvelly 2.6. 5 staff PINs plus a master PIN.
4.1/5Check price →
05
Best on a budget: VEVOR 1.7 Depository Safe. The lowest price here, with two codes.
4.5/5Check price →
06
Best heavy-duty: Mesa MFL2014E. 79 lb, 1-inch bolts and a relocker.
4.0/5Check price →
07
Best four-bolt door: DAYI DM-52. Four 0.8-inch bolts and wall mounting holes.
4.4/5Check price →
08
Best dual-key under-counter safe: SentrySafe UC-025K. Two keys to open, so no one opens it alone.
4.5/5Check price →
09
Best with an inner lock box: Templeton T867. 6 user codes and a locked box inside.
4.4/5Check price →
10
Best dual-code keypad: Barska AX13656. An option that needs two PIN codes to open.
3.9/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 10

Best overall

Lock: Keypad, motorized, key

Weight: 51 lb

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Deep jagged-tooth anti-fish tray
Capacity
4.1
2,503 cu in listed, about 1.45 cu ft
Security
4.7
51 lb, motorized deadbolts, laser-cut steel
Value
4.6
Mid-priced; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the depository safe owners like best, and the best mix of slot, steel and lock we found. Staff drop envelopes into a deep tray with jagged teeth that stops anyone fishing them back out, so the drawer can take a rush of deposits on a busy weekend. The keypad drives motorized deadbolts, a backup key comes with it, and the body is 51 lb of laser-cut steel. Owners mostly praise the quality, call it easy to set up and quick to open, say it stops employee theft and rate it worth the money. One calls it a medium-duty safe, which is fair for the price.

The catch: the listing doesn’t say whether it comes with anchor bolts, so plan to bolt it to the floor yourself. It holds about 1.45 cubic feet, a few days of deposit bags, not a week’s takings. It has no fire rating, and the keypad needs batteries. Viking’s 61-lb VS-48DS is the bigger version; see our best drop safes.

Why we like it

✓ Owners rate quality and value highly
✓ Motorized deadbolts, 51 lb
✓ Deep jagged-tooth drop tray

Watch out for

✗ Anchor bolts not listed
✗ About 1.45 cu ft inside
✗ Keypad needs batteries

Size

13.8 × 13.8 × 15.8 in

Lock

Keypad, motorized bolts, backup key

Slot

Deep jagged-tooth tray

Mount

Floor (hardware not listed)

Build

Laser-cut steel, 51 lb

Skip it if two people must both be there to open it: see pick 8.

Bolt it down and bank the cash often.

A depository safe stops staff and customers from reaching the cash, not a burglar with time and tools. Bolt it to a concrete floor or a wall through the holes provided, keep it out of sight of the door, and take the cash to the bank or a fire-rated safe at closing; see our best money safes. If robbery at the counter is the worry, a safe that won’t open on demand helps; see our best time delay safes.

Pick 2 of 10

Best value

Lock: Keypad, key

Door: 26 mm bolts

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Deep, long baffle with two rows of teeth
Capacity
4.1
About 1.67 cu ft outside; listed 2.6
Security
4.4
26 mm bolts, 28 lb; 4 anchor bolts included
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners rate quality and value highly

Here’s the deal: the best low-priced depository safe for a small shop or a restaurant. The anti-fishing baffle is deep and long, with a row of big teeth at the drop end and smaller teeth above the door, so deposits can’t be hooked back out. The keypad takes a 3 to 8 digit code, with emergency keys and an external battery box as backups, and it can alarm after wrong codes or run silent. Two holes in the back and two in the bottom take the 4 mounting bolts included, for a floor or a wall. Owners mostly praise the quality, the sturdy build and the easy keypad, and rate it worth the price.

The catch: the size. The title says 2.6 cubic feet, the specs say 1.8, and the outside is 11.8 × 13.8 × 17.7 inches, about 1.67 cubic feet, so the inside holds less than either. It weighs 28 lb, light enough to carry off if it isn’t bolted down. It has no fire rating; the fire bag it comes with is only a bag.

Why we like it

✓ Deep baffle with two rows of teeth
✓ 4 anchor bolts included
✓ Owners rate quality and value highly

Watch out for

✗ Listed 2.6 cu ft; outside only 1.67
✗ Light at 28 lb
✗ No fire rating

Size

11.8 × 13.8 × 17.7 in

Lock

Keypad, emergency keys

Slot

Front, toothed baffle

Mount

Floor or wall, 4 bolts included

Build

Steel, 26 mm bolts, 28 lb

Skip it if you need a bigger safe for several shifts: see pick 3.

Pick 3 of 10

Best for big drops

Height: 31.5 in

Weight: 58 lb

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Front drawer with an anti-fishing baffle
Capacity
4.4
About 3.06 cu ft outside; listed 7.5
Security
4.6
58 lb, 3 × 28 mm bolts, recessed door
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: the biggest body among our picks, for a store or a restaurant with several shifts of deposits. It stands 31.5 inches tall: staff drop envelopes through a front drawer with an anti-fishing baffle, and a separate locking drawer on top keeps reports or petty cash apart. It weighs 58 lb, with three 28 mm bolts, a recessed door and hidden hinges. The keypad is backlit, it locks out after wrong codes, a mute mode keeps it quiet, and two emergency keys come with it. Pre-drilled holes in the back and the bottom take the 4 anchor screws included. Owners mostly praise the quality, the size and the easy keypad.

The catch: the label. The listing says 7.5 cubic feet, but the outside is 12.2 × 13.78 × 31.5 inches, about 3.06, so the inside holds well under 3. The same body is sold under several other brand names in shorter heights. Owners are split on how well it works and on value: some report a keypad that stopped working. It has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ Biggest body here: 31.5 in tall
✓ Separate locking top drawer
✓ 58 lb, 4 anchor screws included

Watch out for

✗ Listed 7.5 cu ft; outside about 3.06
✗ Some owners report keypad failures
✗ Owners split on value

Size

12.2 × 13.78 × 31.5 in

Lock

Keypad, 2 emergency keys

Slot

Front drawer, anti-fishing baffle

Mount

Floor, wall or under a counter, anchors included

Build

Steel, 3 × 28 mm bolts, 58 lb

Skip it if you want the safe owners rate highest: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 10

Best multi-user keypad

Lock: 5 PINs + master, keys

Weight: 80 lb listed

SafesGeek score
4.1/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Pull-out drop slot with anti-fishing baffles
Capacity
4.3
About 2.38 cu ft outside; listed 2.6
Security
4.4
3 bolts; 80 lb listed
Value
4.4
Low-priced; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: a low-priced way to give each manager their own code. The keypad stores 5 personal PINs and 1 master PIN, so a shift lead can open it without knowing the owner’s code, and two keys come with it. The safe is split into two parts: staff pull the drop slot to make a deposit without opening the main door, and anti-fishing baffles stop anyone reaching back in. The listing gives 80 lb, three locking bolts and an alarm. Mounting holes let you fix it to a wall or inside a cabinet.

The catch: owners have said little about it so far. The listing says 2.6 cubic feet, but the outside is 14 × 14 × 21 inches, about 2.38, so the inside holds less. It lists the door as 0.5 mm thick, which can’t be right for 80 lb of steel, so treat both numbers with care. The listing doesn’t say if bolts come with it.

Why we like it

✓ 5 personal PINs plus a master PIN
✓ Deposits without opening the door
✓ Low price for a multi-user keypad

Watch out for

✗ Little owner feedback
✗ Listed 2.6 cu ft; outside about 2.38
✗ Door thickness listing is unclear

Size

14 × 14 × 21 in

Lock

Keypad (5 PINs + master), 2 keys

Slot

Pull-out slot, baffles

Mount

Wall or cabinet, holes provided

Build

Steel, 3 bolts, 80 lb listed

Skip it if you’d rather have a brand owners have said more about: see pick 9.

Pick 5 of 10

Best on a budget

Lock: Keypad, 2 codes, 2 keys

Weight: 28 lb

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Saw-tooth tilting baffle in the drop drawer
Capacity
4.1
1.7 cu ft listed, which is its outside size
Security
4.1
28 lb, thickened door; owners split on durability
Value
4.7
Lowest-priced; owners split on quality

Here’s the deal: the lowest price here for a real drop-drawer safe. Deposits go into a front drawer with a saw-tooth tilting baffle, so nothing can be fished back out, and the keypad takes two codes, with two override keys. It’s carbon steel with a thickened door and pry-proof bolts, and two holes in the back let you bolt it to a wall, a floor or a cabinet. Owners say it’s easy to program, compact, and gives them peace of mind for the price.

The catch: it’s the lightest steel here, and owners are split on quality and reliability: some say it stopped working after a couple of months. The 1.7 cubic feet listed is the outside size (14.17 × 11.81 × 17.72 inches), so the inside holds less. A few owners find the inside hard to reach. It has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest price here
✓ Saw-tooth anti-fishing drawer
✓ 2 codes, 2 override keys

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on reliability
✗ 1.7 cu ft is the outside size
✗ Lightest steel here

Size

14.17 × 11.81 × 17.72 in

Lock

Keypad (2 codes), 2 keys

Slot

Drop drawer, saw-tooth baffle

Mount

Wall, floor or cabinet, 2 holes

Build

Carbon steel, 28 lb

Skip it if you’d pay more for steel owners trust: see pick 2.

Pick 6 of 10

Best heavy-duty

Bolts: 1 in solid steel

Weight: 79 lb

SafesGeek score
4.0/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Front-loading hopper with an anti-fish baffle
Capacity
4.0
0.9 cu ft inside, an honest label
Security
4.7
79 lb, 1-inch solid bolts, spring-loaded relocker
Value
4.1
Premium price; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: a commercial depository safe from a US safe maker, built heavier than the low-priced drop safes. Deposits go into a front-loading hopper that works like a mailbox door, so bulky bank bags fit and the baffle behind it stops fishing. The door runs on 1-inch solid steel bolts, and an internal spring-loaded relocker is designed to lock the bolts if someone attacks the lock. It’s all steel and weighs 79 lb. Mesa gives an honest 0.9 cubic feet inside.

The catch: the price, several times that of the low-priced picks, and owners have said little about it so far. The listing is short: it doesn’t say how many user codes the keypad takes or whether anchor bolts come with it, so plan to drill your own. 0.9 cubic feet is room for a few days of deposit bags. The electronic lock runs on a battery.

Why we like it

✓ 1-inch solid steel bolts
✓ Relocker behind the lock
✓ Hopper takes bulky bags

Watch out for

✗ Premium price
✗ Little owner feedback
✗ User codes not listed

Size

20 × 20 × 14 in

Lock

Electronic, relocker

Slot

Front-loading hopper, baffle

Mount

Wall (hardware not listed)

Build

All steel, 1 in bolts, 79 lb

Skip it if you want the safe owners talk about most: see pick 7.

Pick 7 of 10

Best four-bolt door

Bolts: 4 × 0.8 in

Weight: 49 lb

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.4
Front slot with an anti-fishing design; details not listed
Capacity
4.3
About 2.4 cu ft outside; listed 2.6
Security
4.3
4 bolts, 49 lb; owners split on sturdiness
Value
4.4
Low-priced; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: the depository safe owners talk about most in our data, with the most bolts on the door. A one-piece steel body and a pry-resistant door hold four live-locking bolts of 0.8 inch. Staff drop cash and checks through a front slot with an anti-fishing design. It opens with a code, an emergency key or a backup power supply, and wall mounting holes let you fix it to concrete or wood. Owners mostly like the size and say it works well.

The catch: owners are split on how sturdy and secure it is: some call it solid, others call it flimsy for a safe. The listing says 2.6 cubic feet, but the outside is 13.5 × 15 × 20.5 inches, about 2.4, so the inside holds less. It doesn’t explain how the anti-fishing design works. It has no fire rating; the fire bag is only a bag.

Why we like it

✓ 4 live-locking bolts
✓ Code, key or backup power
✓ Wall mounting holes for concrete

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on sturdiness
✗ Listed 2.6 cu ft; outside about 2.4
✗ Slot design not explained

Size

13.5 × 15 × 20.5 in

Lock

Keypad, emergency key

Slot

Front, anti-fishing

Mount

Wall, concrete or wood

Build

One-piece steel, 4 bolts, 49 lb

Skip it if you’d rather have steel owners agree on: see pick 1.

Pick 8 of 10

Best dual-key under-counter safe

Lock: 2 different keys

Weight: 20 lb

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Anti-fish hopper; two keys, so no one opens it alone
Capacity
3.8
0.23 cu ft, an honest label
Security
4.4
Solid steel, 20 lb, continuous hinge; bolt-down kit
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners split on the keys

Here’s the deal: a small depository safe for under a register, from a big safe brand, and the one to choose when two people must both be there to open it. It takes two different keys, so a manager and an owner each hold one and nobody opens it alone. Deposits go through an anti-fish hopper. It’s solid steel with a continuous hinge against prying, weighs 20 lb, and comes with bolt-down hardware for a floor, a counter or a wall. Owners mostly say it’s high quality and built like a tank, and call it the right size for a point of sale.

The catch: the two keys. Owners mostly complain about the lock: the keys are stiff to turn, you have to learn the order, and some report a key that wouldn’t open it. Owners are split on how easy it is to use. It’s small: the inside is 6.5 × 5.8 × 10.5 inches, room for a shift’s envelopes, not bank bags. Our cash drop boxes page has more boxes this size; see our best cash drop boxes.

Why we like it

✓ Two keys: no one opens it alone
✓ Anti-fish hopper
✓ Solid steel, bolt-down kit

Watch out for

✗ Owners mostly complain about the lock
✗ Small 0.23 cu ft inside
✗ Too small for bank bags

Size

8.5 × 12.3 × 6 in

Lock

2 different keys

Slot

Anti-fish hopper

Mount

Floor, counter or wall, bolts included

Build

Solid steel, 20 lb

Skip it if one manager should open it with a code: see pick 1.

Pick 9 of 10

Best with an inner lock box

Lock: Keypad, 6 codes

Inside: 1.5 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Anti-fishing drop drawer; 6 user codes
Capacity
4.1
1.5 cu ft listed
Security
4.4
Thick steel, triple bolts; weight not listed
Value
4.0
Premium price; no owner summary

Here’s the deal: for an office or a store where several managers count the drops and something must stay locked away even from them. Staff drop deposits through an anti-fishing drawer, the keypad holds 6 user codes so each manager has their own, and a separate lock box inside keeps the change fund, keys or records apart. The door has triple bolts, and backup keys come with it.

The catch: the price, near the top of this list, and there’s no owner summary yet to show what owners like or dislike. Templeton sells a near-identical T863 without the inner box, whose owners are split on how long the keypad lasts. The listing calls it freestanding and doesn’t mention mounting holes or bolts, and it doesn’t give the weight. The keypad needs batteries.

Why we like it

✓ Separate lock box inside
✓ 6 user codes
✓ Anti-fishing drop drawer

Watch out for

✗ Premium price
✗ No owner summary yet
✗ Mounting not listed

Size

17.32 × 16.53 × 17.32 in

Lock

Keypad (6 codes), backup keys

Slot

Drop drawer

Mount

Freestanding (holes not listed)

Build

Thick steel, triple bolts

Skip it if you’d rather pay less for staff codes: see pick 4.

Pick 10 of 10

Best dual-code keypad

Lock: 2 PINs, dual-PIN mode

Bolts: 3 deadbolts

SafesGeek score
3.9/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Front load, anti-fishing baffles; dual-PIN mode
Capacity
4.0
1.03 cu ft listed
Security
4.4
3 pry-resistant deadbolts; hardware included
Value
4.0
Premium price; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the keypad safe for a business that wants two people at every opening without juggling two keys. It stores 2 PIN codes, and a dual-PIN mode needs both codes before the door opens, so one person alone can’t empty it. Deposits load from the front behind anti-fishing baffles, 3 pry-resistant steel deadbolts hold the door, and it locks out after too many wrong codes. Mounting hardware, a floor mat, a 9V battery and 2 backup keys come with it.

The catch: the price, and owners have said little about it so far. Owners of a sister Barska depository safe mostly complain that the keypad stopped working within a year, so keep the backup keys somewhere you can reach. It holds 1.03 cubic feet, and the listing doesn’t give the weight.

Why we like it

✓ Dual-PIN mode: two codes to open
✓ 3 pry-resistant deadbolts
✓ Mounting hardware included

Watch out for

✗ Premium price
✗ Little owner feedback
✗ Weight not listed

Size

14 × 13.5 × 12 in

Lock

Keypad (2 PINs, dual mode), 2 keys

Slot

Front load, baffles

Mount

Floor, hardware included

Build

Steel, 3 deadbolts

Skip it if you’d rather use two keys and no batteries: see pick 8.

PickLockWeightSizeSlotMountBuildDoor
Viking VS-40DS
Best overall
4.7/5
Check price
Keypad, motorized, key51 lb13.8 × 13.8 × 15.8 inDeep jagged-tooth trayFloor (hardware not listed)Laser-cut steel, 51 lb–
KAER 2.6 Depository Safe
Best value
4.5/5
Check price
Keypad, key–11.8 × 13.8 × 17.7 inFront, toothed baffleFloor or wall, 4 bolts includedSteel, 26 mm bolts, 28 lb26 mm bolts
Sanfnz 7.5 Tall Drop Safe
Best for big drops
4.4/5
Check price
Keypad, 2 emergency keys58 lb12.2 × 13.78 × 31.5 inFront drawer, anti-fishing baffleFloor, wall or under a counter, anchors includedSteel, 3 × 28 mm bolts, 58 lb–
Greenvelly 2.6
Best multi-user keypad
4.1/5
Check price
5 PINs + master, keys80 lb listed14 × 14 × 21 inPull-out slot, bafflesWall or cabinet, holes providedSteel, 3 bolts, 80 lb listed–
VEVOR 1.7 Depository Safe
Best on a budget
4.5/5
Check price
Keypad, 2 codes, 2 keys28 lb14.17 × 11.81 × 17.72 inDrop drawer, saw-tooth baffleWall, floor or cabinet, 2 holesCarbon steel, 28 lb–
Mesa MFL2014E
Best heavy-duty
4.0/5
Check price
Electronic, relocker79 lb20 × 20 × 14 inFront-loading hopper, baffleWall (hardware not listed)All steel, 1 in bolts, 79 lb–
DAYI DM-52
Best four-bolt door
4.4/5
Check price
Keypad, emergency key49 lb13.5 × 15 × 20.5 inFront, anti-fishingWall, concrete or woodOne-piece steel, 4 bolts, 49 lb–
SentrySafe UC-025K
Best dual-key under-counter safe
4.5/5
Check price
2 different keys20 lb8.5 × 12.3 × 6 inAnti-fish hopperFloor, counter or wall, bolts includedSolid steel, 20 lb–
Templeton T867
Best with an inner lock box
4.4/5
Check price
Keypad, 6 codes–17.32 × 16.53 × 17.32 inDrop drawerFreestanding (holes not listed)Thick steel, triple bolts–
Barska AX13656
Best dual-code keypad
3.9/5
Check price
2 PINs, dual-PIN mode–14 × 13.5 × 12 inFront load, bafflesFloor, hardware includedSteel, 3 deadbolts–

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

A cash depository safe has one job: let staff put cash in all shift without letting anyone but the manager take it out. Six questions decide which cash depository safe fits your business.

This decides the lock. One manager: any keypad (picks 1, 2 and 5). Several managers who each need their own code: a multi-user keypad (picks 4 and 9). Two people who must both be there: two keys (pick 8) or a dual-PIN keypad (pick 10). We found no dial (mechanical) depository safe worth listing: almost every one sold now has a keypad with backup keys.

A drawer (picks 3, 5 and 9) or a hopper (picks 6 and 8) never leaves an open path to the money. A deep tray with teeth (pick 1) or baffles (picks 2, 4 and 10) make it hard to hook anything back out. Check the slot width too: a hopper takes bulky bank bags, a narrow slot takes envelopes only.

Less than the label says. Go by the outside inches: several listings claim more room than the outside allows, like 7.5 cubic feet for a body of about 3. For a shift’s envelopes, about 1 to 1.5 cubic feet does (picks 1, 5, 9 and 10). For several shifts and bank bags, choose a taller body (pick 3).

Bolt it down, always. These safes weigh 20 to 80 lb, so a loose one can be carried off. Under a register: pick 8. In a back office: any floor model, bolted into concrete. Several picks don’t list their anchor bolts, so buy concrete anchors to match the holes. If the safe must stay hidden, see our best office safes.

None of these safes has a fire rating or a burglary rating. For cash and checks that stay overnight, move them into a fire-rated safe; see our best fireproof safes, or slip the bank bag into one of our best fireproof bags. If robbery at the counter is the worry, a delay lock helps more than steel.

Into the bank. Carry it there in one of our best locking bags. The cash staff hand out during the day belongs in a register drawer or a cash box, not the depository safe; see our best cash drawers and best cash boxes.

One last tip: many depository safes on Amazon are the same steel body under several brand names, so don’t pay more for a name alone. Compare the steel, the anti-fishing design, the lock and the outside inches.

Still not sure? Get the Viking VS-40DS.
Motorized deadbolts, a deep anti-fish tray and 51 lb of steel.
Check price on Amazon →
What is a cash depository safe?

A safe with a slot, drawer or hopper that staff drop cash, checks and deposit bags into without being able to open the door. Only the manager has the code or key. Stores, restaurants, gas stations, laundromats and offices use one so no cash sits in the register and no one employee holds it all.

Is a depository safe the same as a drop safe?

Yes, mostly. Sellers use both names for the same kind of safe. A small one for a counter is usually called a cash drop box; see our best cash drop boxes. For bigger floor models, see our best drop safes.

What if the keypad stops working?

Use the backup key. Every keypad pick comes with emergency keys, and several have an outside battery box. Keypads are the most common complaint across depository safes, so keep the keys off-site or in another safe, never inside this one, and change the batteries once a year.

Can staff fish cash back out of the slot?

Not easily. Every pick has a baffle, a drawer or a hopper behind the slot. A drawer or a hopper is the surest kind.

Is a cash depository safe fireproof?

No. We found no depository safe with a fire rating; listings that say fireproof only add a fire bag. Bank the cash daily, or move it to a fire-rated safe at closing; see our best money safes.

Does a depository safe stop robbery?

It helps, because staff can truthfully say they can’t open it. For more, a time delay lock makes a robber wait; see our best time delay safes.

Find your fit

A cash depository safe lets staff drop cash in all shift while only the manager takes it out. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Staff drop cash, the manager opens
→ Cash depository safes (you're here)
Keypad, dual-key and multi-user drop-slot safes for stores, restaurants and offices.
If you want
Cash kept safe from fire
→ Fireproof safes
A UL-rated fire safe for cash, checks and records overnight.
If you want
A bigger floor drop safe
→ Drop safes
Floor drop safes up to 115 lb, some with two doors.
If you want
The day's takings locked away
→ Money safes
Money safes for cash after closing, with fire-rated picks.

How to choose a cash depository safe →

We looked at 103 products that came up on Amazon across 4 searches for “cash depository safe”, plain and with Amazon’s filters for dial locks, under-counter mounting and the price band where the commercial safes sit. Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews: quality and sturdiness, the keypad and how long it lasts, the size, and the value. Those became our four scores.

Many listings are the same steel body under several brand names, often in a few heights, so we kept one per body and one per brand. We left out cash boxes, wall drop boxes, home safes without a drop slot, and safes whose owners mostly complain about the lock, unless the safe does something no other pick does. The dial-lock search found no dial depository safe, only keypad safes.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 103 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.