8 Best Small Safe Boxes with Key, Scored on Build, Room, Security and Price

The short version

01
Best overall: Bonsaii SF004 Key Safe. A steel safe that bolts down, with 2 keys, at the lowest price here.
4.6/5Check price →
02
Biggest: Psisuvry Key Safe with Shelf. The most room, a removable shelf and concealed hinges.
4.2/5Check price →
03
Best double-wall steel: Honeywell 6104. Two steel walls and room for passports and folded papers.
4.7/5Check price →
04
Best for fire: SentrySafe 1160 Fire Chest. A lab fire rating and room for letter paper to lie flat.
4.6/5Check price →
05
Best for papers: Dalmbox Document Safe Box. A deep steel box where a stack of letter paper lies flat.
4.6/5Check price →
06
Best build: Uzticams Mini Key Safe. Thick steel, 11.7 pounds and holes to fix it to a wall.
4.6/5Check price →
07
Best with a cable: SentrySafe P005K. A slim steel box that ties to a desk or a bed frame.
4.1/5Check price →
08
Best waterproof: XPEDITION FP5902K Waterproof Fire Chest. Sealed for 72 hours under water, with room for letter paper to lie flat.
4.5/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 8

Best overall

Lock: Key (2 keys)

Mount: Bolts down

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
SPCC steel, pry-resistant door, hidden hinges, 4.1 lb; owners mostly call it sturdy
Capacity
4.4
8.98 × 6.46 × 6.61 in inside, 0.22 cu ft; papers must be folded
Security
4.1
4.1 lb steel, hidden hinges; key only
Value
5.0
Lowest-priced pick

Here’s the deal: the small safe box with key we’d choose for a closet, a cabinet or a dorm shelf. It’s a little steel safe with a front door, 9.06 × 6.69 × 6.69 inches and 4.1 pounds, that opens with a flat key and nothing else: no keypad, no batteries. Bonsaii lists SPCC steel, a pry-resistant door and hidden hinges, and the inside is listed too: 8.98 × 6.46 × 6.61 inches, about 0.22 cubic feet, enough for cash, passports, jewelry and medicine bottles standing up. Pre-drilled holes on the back and the bottom take the 2 expansion bolts in the box, so you can fix it to a shelf, a wall or the floor. Owners mostly call it sturdy, easy to use and a good size, and it’s the lowest-priced pick here. It’s also on our best mini safes, next to safes of the same size with a keypad.

The catch: it’s light and the steel is thin. The listed inside is almost as big as the outside, which leaves very little wall. Left loose, 4.1 pounds is easy to carry away, so use the bolts. Some owners doubt how much force it would take, and a flat key lock is a privacy lock. Letter paper has to be folded, and there’s no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ Bolts to a shelf, wall or floor
✓ 2 keys, no batteries
✓ Lowest-priced pick

Watch out for

✗ Thin steel, 4.1 lb
✗ Papers must be folded
✗ No fire rating

Outside

9.06 × 6.69 × 6.69 in

Inside

8.98 × 6.46 × 6.61 in

Weight

4.1 lb

Lock

Flat key (2 keys)

Mount

Shelf, wall or floor; 2 bolts included

Skip it if you need more room: see pick 2, or pick 4 for a fire rating.

Lose every key and you’re locked out.

None of these safes has a code or a reset. The key is the only way in, and only pick 6’s listing offers a replacement key. Keep one key on your ring and the spare somewhere away from the safe, never inside it, and never taped underneath. If you tend to lose keys, a safe with a code and a backup key may suit you better; see our best digital safes.

Pick 2 of 8

Biggest

Lock: Key

Outside: about 0.77 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.3
Steel, concealed hinges, reinforced door edges, 11 lb; owners mostly like the quality, some don’t
Capacity
4.9
13.78 × 9.84 × 9.84 in outside, about 0.77 cu ft; removable shelf
Security
4.3
Concealed anti-pry hinges, reinforced door edges; floor or wall mount
Value
4.3
Pricier than most picks; owners split on the value

Here’s the deal: the key safe to get when the little ones are too small. It’s 13.78 × 9.84 × 9.84 inches and 11 pounds, more than three times the outside size of pick 1, with a front door and a removable shelf that keeps cash and jewelry apart from passports and papers. Take the shelf out and a tablet or a stack of folded documents fits. A key opens it, with duplicate keys in the box, and Psisuvry lists concealed anti-pry hinges, reinforced door edges and a floor or wall mount. Owners mostly like the size, the room and how secure it feels. For safes this size with a keypad or a fingerprint lock, see our best small safes.

The catch: the listing overstates it in three places. It’s sold as 1.3 cubic feet (1.2 in the specs), but the outside size comes to about 0.77 cubic feet, and the “interior” size it gives is the same as the outside. It’s titled fireproof with no rating, time or temperature, and more owners doubt the fire protection than praise it, so we give it no credit for fire. And it’s described as an in-wall safe, but at 9.84 inches deep it won’t sit between wall studs. Owners are split on ease of use and on the value. Amazon pools its owner feedback with Psisuvry’s keypad safes, so not every comment is about this one.

Why we like it

✓ About 0.77 cu ft outside
✓ Removable shelf
✓ Concealed hinges, floor or wall mount

Watch out for

✗ Sold as 1.3 cu ft; it’s about 0.77
✗ “Fireproof” with no rating named
✗ Owners split on ease of use

Outside

13.78 × 9.84 × 9.84 in

Inside

Not listed (shelf included)

Weight

11 lb

Lock

Key (duplicate keys)

Mount

Floor or wall

Skip it if a small shelf is all the space you have: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 8

Best double-wall steel

Inside: 0.17 cu ft

Weight: 7.9 lb

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
Double steel walls with insulation, reinforced hinge, 7.9 lb; owners split on durability
Capacity
4.3
0.17 cu ft; 12.7 × 8.8 × 4.1 in outside
Security
4.3
Key lock, 2 keys, reinforced hinge; owners split on the lock; no way to fix it down
Value
4.6
Mid-priced here; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: a flat steel box for the papers and small things you want in one place. It’s 12.7 × 8.8 × 4.1 inches and 7.9 pounds, with 0.17 cubic feet inside, which owners say is enough for passports, folded documents, cash and a phone, and small enough to slide under a sofa. Honeywell builds it with two steel walls and insulation between them, a reinforced hinge to resist tampering, a foam-padded floor and a scratch-resistant finish. A key lock with 2 keys opens it, and a handle on the front makes it easy to carry. Owners mostly like the build, the size, the security and the value. It’s also on our best small lock boxes with key, with the same scores.

The catch: Honeywell calls it fire resistant, but the listing names no rating, no time and no temperature, so we give it no credit for fire. Owners are split on the lock, with some reporting a lock that failed, and on durability: some say the handle broke while carrying it. The bullets say nothing about bolting it down, and at 7.9 pounds it can be carried off. One spec line calls the lock an electronic combination; the title, the bullets and the keys say key lock.

Why we like it

✓ Two steel walls, reinforced hinge
✓ 0.17 cu ft: passports and folded papers
✓ Owners rate the value highly

Watch out for

✗ “Fire resistant” with no rating named
✗ Handle can break, some owners say
✗ No way to fix it down

Outside

12.7 × 8.8 × 4.1 in

Inside

0.17 cu ft

Weight

7.9 lb

Lock

Key (2 keys)

Mount

None: carry handle

Skip it if you want a real fire rating: see pick 4.

Pick 4 of 8

Best for fire

Fire: UL 30 min at 1550°F

Inside: 0.2 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.6
17 lb fire-insulated body, UL Classified for 30 min at 1550°F; owners mostly call it sturdy
Capacity
4.4
13 × 8.75 × 3 in inside, about 0.2 cu ft; letter paper lies flat
Security
4.0
Privacy key lock, 2 keys; owners mostly complain about the lock; no way to fix it down
Value
4.6
Mid-priced here; a lab fire rating for the money

Here’s the deal: the only small safe box with a key here that has a lab fire rating. SentrySafe has it UL Classified to keep papers safe for 30 minutes at 1550°F, and ETL Verified to protect CDs, DVDs and USB drives for the same time. It’s a chest of about 15.1 × 11.25 × 5.75 inches and 17 pounds with carrying grips, and the inside, 13 × 8.75 × 3 inches, lets letter paper lie flat next to passports and cash. A key lock with 2 keys keeps the lid shut, and SentrySafe promises to replace it after a fire. Owners mostly call it sturdy and well made. It’s the top pick on our best fireproof document safes.

The catch: the lock is its weak spot. Far more owners complain about the lock than praise it, and it can stick. SentrySafe calls it a privacy lock. Its main job is to keep the lid closed in a fire, not to stop a thief, and there’s nothing to bolt it down. The title says 0.25 cubic feet, but the inside size in the bullets comes to about 0.2. Owners are split on the size and the weight, and it has no water rating.

Why we like it

✓ UL Classified: 30 min at 1550°F
✓ Letter paper lies flat
✓ After-fire replacement promise

Watch out for

✗ Lock is owners’ main complaint
✗ Privacy lock, not theft-proof
✗ No water rating

Outside

15.1 × 11.25 × 5.75 in

Inside

13 × 8.75 × 3 in

Weight

17 lb

Lock

Privacy key (2 keys)

Mount

None: carrying grips

Skip it if fire isn’t your worry and you want a safe that bolts down: see pick 1 or pick 6.

Pick 5 of 8

Best for papers

Inside: 11.8 × 9.65 × 4.53 in

Weight: 7 lb

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.4
Steel with a fire-resistant layer, powder coat, 7 lb; owners mostly call it sturdy
Capacity
4.6
11.8 × 9.65 × 4.53 in inside, about 0.3 cu ft; letter paper lies flat
Security
4.1
Key lock; owners split on security; nothing to fix it down
Value
4.4
Mid-priced here; owners split on the value

Here’s the deal: the safe box with key for a thick stack of papers. It’s a steel box of 13.2 × 11 × 5.1 inches and 7 pounds, and Dalmbox lists the inside as 11.8 × 9.65 × 4.53 inches, about 0.3 cubic feet: letter paper lies flat, with 4.5 inches of depth for folders, a hard drive, passports and cash on top. A key opens it, a handle on the outside makes it easy to carry, and the low, flat shape slides into a drawer or under a desk. Owners mostly call it sturdy, well made and the right size, and say the lock works smoothly. For boxes this size with a code, see our best lockable storage boxes.

The catch: Dalmbox calls it fire resistant, with a fire-resistant layer between the steel, but the listing names no rating, no time and no temperature, so we give it no credit for fire. Owners are split on how secure it is, and some find it pricey for what it is. The bullets say nothing about bolting it down, and at 7 pounds with a handle it’s easy to walk off with. The listing doesn’t say how many keys come with it.

Why we like it

✓ Letter paper lies flat
✓ 4.5 in deep inside
✓ Owners mostly call it sturdy

Watch out for

✗ “Fire resistant” with no rating named
✗ Owners split on security
✗ No way to fix it down

Outside

13.2 × 11 × 5.1 in

Inside

11.8 × 9.65 × 4.53 in

Weight

7 lb

Lock

Key

Mount

None: carry handle

Skip it if the papers need a real fire rating: see pick 4.

Pick 6 of 8

Best build

Weight: 11.7 lb

Mount: Wall

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.7
Thick steel, internal hinges, fire-resistant lining, 11.7 lb for a mini safe; the few owners so far praise the quality
Capacity
4.1
10.2 × 4.9 × 5.5 in inside, about 0.16 cu ft
Security
4.4
11.7 lb, internal hinges, covered key lock; pre-drilled to fix to a wall
Value
4.1
Premium price; little room for the money

Here’s the deal: the small key safe that’s hardest to bend or carry off. Uzticams gives the outside as 10.6 × 6.7 × 6.7 inches, yet it weighs 11.7 pounds, almost three times as much as pick 1, from thicker steel and upgraded internal hinges. A mechanical key lock sits under a metal cover, 2 keys come in the box, and the listing says you can order a replacement key by the keyhole number, the only pick here that offers that. Pre-drilled holes on the back fix it inside a cabinet, a closet or on a wall, and the inside is lined on all six sides. The few owners so far praise the quality and the size. For more safes with a fire claim in this size, see our best small fireproof safes.

The catch: it’s one of the priciest picks, and you get the least room for the money: 10.2 × 4.9 × 5.5 inches inside, about 0.16 cubic feet. The title promises 30 minutes at 1800°F, but that’s the maker’s own claim with no lab named; the UL 94 test the listing cites is a flame test of the lining, not a fire rating for the safe, so we give it no credit for fire. One spec line gives the size as 6.69 × 6.69 × 11.09 inches, which doesn’t match the bullets. It has far less owner feedback than the other picks, and a few report trouble with the lock.

Why we like it

✓ 11.7 lb of thick steel
✓ Fixes to a wall or cabinet
✓ Replacement keys offered

Watch out for

✗ Premium price for its size
✗ Fire claim names no lab
✗ Few owner reviews so far

Outside

10.6 × 6.7 × 6.7 in

Inside

10.2 × 4.9 × 5.5 in

Weight

11.7 lb

Lock

Covered key (2 keys)

Mount

Wall or cabinet, pre-drilled

Skip it if you want the most room for the money: see pick 1 or pick 2.

Pick 7 of 8

Best with a cable

Lock: Key

Tether: Steel cable

SafesGeek score
4.1/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.3
Solid steel, 1.6 lb; owners like the quality
Capacity
3.7
0.05 cu ft: 6.6 × 5.3 × 2.4 in inside
Security
4.1
Solid steel and a tether cable; owners split, some say it pries open
Value
4.6
Low price; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: the personal safe with a key to take to a dorm, an office or a coffee shop table. It’s a solid steel box of 8 × 5.9 × 2.6 inches and 1.6 pounds, a flat key opens it, and a steel cable ties it to a desk leg or a bed frame, which no other pick here can do. Inside, 6.6 × 5.3 × 2.4 inches holds keys, cash, cards, a USB drive or a phone. Owners mostly like the quality, the compact size and the value. The same box with a 3-digit code is on our best travel safes.

The catch: more owners find it awkward to open than easy, and they’re split on security: some say it can be pried open. At 1.6 pounds it relies on the cable. It holds very little, and it costs a little more than pick 1, which holds four times as much.

Why we like it

✓ Steel cable included
✓ Slim: 2.6 in thin
✓ Owners rate the value

Watch out for

✗ Awkward to open, many say
✗ Can be pried, some say
✗ Holds very little

Outside

8 × 5.9 × 2.6 in

Inside

6.6 × 5.3 × 2.4 in

Weight

1.6 lb

Lock

Flat key (2 keys)

Mount

Tether cable

Skip it if the safe stays at home: see pick 1, which bolts down.

Pick 8 of 8

Best waterproof

Water: 72 h under water

Inside: about 0.37 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Build
4.6
Steel with fire insulation and a water-tight gasket; owners praise the quality
Capacity
4.6
12.8 × 11.61 × 4.33 in inside, about 0.37 cu ft; letter paper lies flat
Security
4.0
Privacy key lock, 2 keys; nothing to fix it down
Value
4.3
Priciest pick; owners praise the quality

Here’s the deal: the small safe box with key to get when a flood or a burst pipe worries you as much as prying eyes. XPEDITION seals this steel chest with a gasket and says it keeps what’s inside dry through 72 hours under water. It’s 15.75 × 15.35 × 6.69 inches outside, and the inside, 12.8 × 11.61 × 4.33 inches or about 0.37 cubic feet, lets letter paper lie flat with room for folders, passports, cash and a hard drive on top. A privacy key lock with 2 keys keeps the lid shut, a handle makes it easy to carry, and at 6.69 inches tall it slides under a bed. Owners praise the quality, the size and the fire and water protection. For more chests sealed against floods, see our best fireproof waterproof safes.

The catch: the title promises 1 hour at 1700°F, but the listing names no lab, so we give it no credit for fire; for a lab rating, see pick 4. It’s sold as 0.94 cubic feet, which is the outside size; the inside comes to about 0.37. The key lock is for privacy, there’s nothing to bolt it down, and owners are split on the weight, which the listing doesn’t give. One spec line lists an alarm system that the bullets never mention. It’s the priciest pick, and it has less owner feedback than most picks here.

Why we like it

✓ Sealed for 72 hours under water
✓ Letter paper lies flat
✓ Owners praise the quality

Watch out for

✗ Fire claim names no lab
✗ Sold as 0.94 cu ft; about 0.37 inside
✗ No way to fix it down

Outside

15.75 × 15.35 × 6.69 in

Inside

12.8 × 11.61 × 4.33 in

Weight

Not listed

Lock

Privacy key (2 keys)

Mount

None: carry handle

Skip it if you want a lab fire rating: see pick 4, or pick 1 for a safe that bolts down.

PickLockMountOutsideInsideWeightFireTether
Bonsaii SF004 Key Safe
Best overall
4.6/5
Check price
Key (2 keys)Bolts down9.06 × 6.69 × 6.69 in8.98 × 6.46 × 6.61 in4.1 lb––
Psisuvry Key Safe with Shelf
Biggest
4.2/5
Check price
KeyFloor or wallabout 0.77 cu ftNot listed (shelf included)11 lb––
Honeywell 6104
Best double-wall steel
4.7/5
Check price
Key (2 keys)None: carry handle12.7 × 8.8 × 4.1 in0.17 cu ft7.9 lb––
SentrySafe 1160 Fire Chest
Best for fire
4.6/5
Check price
Privacy key (2 keys)None: carrying grips15.1 × 11.25 × 5.75 in0.2 cu ft17 lbUL 30 min at 1550°F–
Dalmbox Document Safe Box
Best for papers
4.6/5
Check price
KeyNone: carry handle13.2 × 11 × 5.1 in11.8 × 9.65 × 4.53 in7 lb––
Uzticams Mini Key Safe
Best build
4.6/5
Check price
Covered key (2 keys)Wall10.6 × 6.7 × 6.7 in10.2 × 4.9 × 5.5 in11.7 lb––
SentrySafe P005K
Best with a cable
4.1/5
Check price
KeyTether cable8 × 5.9 × 2.6 in6.6 × 5.3 × 2.4 in1.6 lb–Steel cable
XPEDITION FP5902K Waterproof Fire Chest
Best waterproof
4.5/5
Check price
Privacy key (2 keys)None: carry handle15.75 × 15.35 × 6.69 inabout 0.37 cu ftNot listed––

A small safe box with key is a steel safe you can lift with one hand, opened by a key and nothing else. It’s for keeping cash, passports, jewelry, medicine and papers away from kids, guests, roommates and coworkers. Here’s how to choose one and what to expect from it.

Lay out what’s going in and measure the longest thing. A passport is 4.9 × 3.5 inches, a US bill is 6.1 inches long, and letter paper is 8.5 × 11. Pick 7 takes cash, cards and a phone. Picks 1 and 6 hold cash, passports, jewelry and bottles, with papers folded. Pick 3 takes passports and folded papers. Picks 4, 5 and 8 let letter paper lie flat, and pick 2 is the only one with a shelf. Check the listing’s sums too: pick 2 is sold as 1.3 cubic feet and measures about 0.77 outside, pick 4’s title says 0.25 where the inside comes to about 0.2, and pick 8’s 0.94 is the outside, with about 0.37 inside.

It will stop a curious kid, a guest or a coworker, not someone with a screwdriver and time. Small key locks are privacy locks, and a light safe can simply be taken, which is why these picks score 4.0 to 4.4 out of 5 on security. If a break-in is the worry, see our best small safes, or hide it: our best hidden safes has boxes that look like books and cans.

Four picks have an answer. Pick 1 bolts to a shelf, a wall or the floor with the 2 bolts in the box, pick 2 mounts to the floor or a wall, pick 6 fixes to a wall or the inside of a cabinet, and pick 7 ties to furniture with a steel cable. Picks 3, 4, 5 and 8 have a handle or grips and nothing else, so keep them out of sight: a closet shelf or a locked drawer.

It’s the part owners complain about most on small key safes: a key that sticks, or a lock that’s easy to force. Owners mostly complain about the lock on pick 4, they’re split on pick 3, and more owners find pick 7 awkward to open than easy. Try the lock a few times with the door open before you trust it, and don’t force a key that sticks. If you’d like a code with the key as a backup, see our best digital safes, or our best mini safes for keypad safes of the same size.

Only pick 4 has a lab rating: UL Classified for 30 minutes at 1550°F. Picks 2, 3, 5, 6 and 8 are called fireproof or fire resistant, but none names a lab, and picks 1 and 7 make no fire claim. A thin steel box passes heat straight to what’s inside. If papers are the reason you want a safe, see our best fireproof document safes, and for floods too, our best fireproof waterproof safes.

Not quite. The safes here have a door or a lid of heavier steel, and most can be fixed down. For lighter boxes with a key, down to pocket size, see our best small lock boxes with key. For a cash float with bill slots and a coin tray, see our best cash boxes. And none of these safes is built or rated for a firearm: for a handgun, see our best gun lock boxes.

One last tip: taking it on a trip? Pick 7 has a cable for a hotel room or a dorm, and our best travel safes has more that lock to furniture.

Still not sure? Get the Bonsaii SF004 Key Safe.
A steel safe that bolts down, with 2 keys and no batteries, at the lowest price here.
Check price on Amazon →
What is the best small safe box with key?

For most homes, pick 1: a small steel safe with 2 keys that bolts to a shelf, a wall or the floor. Choose pick 2 for the most room, pick 3 for passports and folded papers in double-wall steel, pick 4 for a lab fire rating, pick 5 for a stack of flat papers, pick 6 for the heaviest steel, pick 7 for a box that ties to furniture with a cable, and pick 8 for a chest sealed against water.

How secure is a small safe with a key?

Secure enough to keep kids, guests and coworkers out, not a thief with tools. A small key lock is a privacy lock, and a light safe can be carried away. Fix it down if you can (picks 1, 2 and 6 mount to a wall or floor, pick 7 has a cable), or keep it out of sight.

What if I lose the key?

There’s no code or reset on any of these safes. Pick 6’s listing offers a replacement key by the keyhole number; the others don’t promise one. Most picks come with 2 keys: keep one on your ring and the spare somewhere away from the safe, never inside it.

Is a small safe box with a key fireproof?

Most aren’t. Of these eight, only pick 4 has a lab rating: UL Classified for 30 minutes at 1550°F. Five others are called fireproof or fire resistant with no lab named. For more boxes with a real rating, see our best fireproof document safes.

What fits in a personal safe with a key?

It depends on the size. Pick 7 holds cash, cards, keys and a phone. Picks 1 and 6 hold cash, passports, jewelry and medicine bottles. Pick 3 holds passports and folded papers. Picks 4, 5 and 8 hold letter paper flat, and pick 2 takes a tablet or a stack of documents, with a shelf to keep small things apart.

Can I keep a gun in a small safe box with a key?

We wouldn’t. None of these safes is sold or rated for a firearm, and a small key lock won’t hold a determined teen for long. Use a box built for a handgun: see our best gun lock boxes.

Find your fit

A small safe box with key keeps cash, passports and papers private with no batteries and no code. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A small safe that opens with a key
→ Small safe boxes with key (you're here)
Steel safes with a key lock, from a slim cable box to a key safe with a shelf.
If you want
A code with a backup key
→ Digital safes
Keypad safes that open with a code and keep a key as the backup.
If you want
A stronger small safe
→ Small safes
Small safes with steel doors, a keypad or fingerprint lock and bolt-down holes.
If you want
A fire rating
→ Fireproof document safes
Chests with a real fire rating where papers lie flat.

How to choose a small safe box with key →

We looked at 185 products that show up on Amazon in our searches for a small safe box with key, a small safe with key, a safe box with key and a personal safe with key, the plain searches and filtered ones. Many weren’t small key safes at all: cash boxes with a tray, book safes, boxes for hanging a house key outside, gun safes and keypad safes. We kept small safes that open with a key and nothing else, in different forms: a bolt-down safe, a bigger safe with a shelf, a double-wall box, a fire chest, a document box, a heavy mini safe, a cable box and a waterproof chest. We set aside safes with a keypad or a code, cash boxes, book safes, key holders and gun boxes.

Many small key safes are sold under several brands with the same body: we found the 9.06 × 6.69 × 6.69 inch safe under seven names, so we kept one, the listing with the most owner feedback. We left out boxes whose owners mostly complain about the lock or about them breaking, except the fire chest, where the lab fire rating is the reason to buy and the weak lock is stated.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 185 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these ourselves. We read the listings and what owners report.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.