7 Best Gun Safe Keypads, Scored on Fit, Reliability, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: S&G 6730 dial lock. A pro-grade dial that never needs a battery.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Best keypad lock: S&G Spartan PivotBolt. Fits most gun safes and relocks by itself.
4.5/5Check price →
03
Most secure keypad: AMSEC ESL10XL. UL listed, with a relocker and a 15-minute lockout.
4.8/5Check price →
04
Best budget keypad kit: WAHLIN PARTS solenoid kit. A low-priced fix for round-keypad safes.
4.4/5Check price →
05
Best fingerprint upgrade: YOSEC E-115F. Fingerprint or code on a round-keypad safe.
4.0/5Check price →
06
Best for a larger round keypad: WAH YUE HING kit. A solenoid kit for safes with the 3.94″ keypad.
3.9/5Check price →
07
Lowest-priced keypad kit: TeukRiGa kit. The cheapest way to bring a round-keypad safe back.
4.2/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 7

Best overall

Lock: Mechanical dial

Power: No batteries

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.7
Sold for gun safes; owners mostly say it fits, Big Horn too
Reliability
4.9
No batteries; owners mostly say it works perfectly
Security
4.7
Group 2 lock, relock trigger, brass bolt
Value
4.7
Low mid-price; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: the lock to get if you’re done with batteries. The 6730 is a Group 2 mechanical combination lock with a dial: nothing to charge and nothing to fail when the power is out. S&G says it has a relock trigger against punch attacks, a solid brass bolt and locking arms, and that it held up to expert manipulation for over 20 hours. Three key-changeable wheels allow up to 1,000,000 combinations, and you can change the combination at the lock. The kit has the lock, the D300 dial, the dial ring and the mounting hardware, with a two-year warranty. Owners mostly say it works perfectly, was easy to install and fits, one on a Big Horn safe, and many bought it to replace a digital keypad. One owner says it took under 30 minutes.

The catch: a dial is slower than a keypad. You turn it through the combination every time, and owners are split on how easy that is. Owners are also split on the instructions and the included hardware, and some note that the change key you need to set a new combination isn’t in the box. For a handgun you need in seconds, see our best biometric gun safes.

Why we like it

✓ No batteries to die
✓ Group 2, with a relock trigger
✓ Owners mostly say it fits

Watch out for

✗ Slower than a keypad
✗ Mixed instruction reviews
✗ Change key not included

Type

Mechanical dial, Group 2

Fits

Home, gun and commercial safes

Codes

1 combination, 3 wheels

Bolt

Solid brass

Extras

Relock trigger, dial and ring, 2-year warranty

Skip it if you want to open the safe in seconds: see pick 2.

Look behind the old lock before you order.

With the safe door open, take off the old keypad and photograph what’s behind it: a rectangular lock body with a bolt (picks 1 to 3 replace those) or a round keypad wired to a small solenoid pin (picks 4 to 7). Note the keypad size and the plug on its cable: some kits use a 4-pin plug, older ones a 14-pin. Across the safe locks we checked, more owners complain about the instructions than praise them, so watch the maker’s install video first, and don’t close the door until the new lock has opened several times.

Pick 2 of 7

Best keypad lock

Lock: Keypad, 2 users

Fits: Magic Module footprint

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.7
Magic Module footprint; mounts any direction
Reliability
4.7
Owners mostly praise the quality
Security
4.6
Relocks itself, penalty lockout, EMP-tested
Value
4.6
Mid-priced, battery included

Here’s the deal: S&G’s keypad lock made for home gun safes, at a mid price. It matches S&G’s “Magic Module” footprint, which S&G says most safe locks share, and it mounts left, right, up or down, so it’s a straight swap on most gun safes. The PivotBolt relocks on its own when you close the boltwork, and a penalty lockout stops random code guessing. S&G says it kept working after the U.S. military’s highest electromagnetic pulse (EMP) tests. The kit has the chrome keypad, the lock body, a battery and the hardware, with a two-year warranty. Owners mostly praise the quality and say it’s a nice replacement with a perfect fit.

The catch: owners complain about the instructions more than they praise them, so watch S&G’s install video before you start. It holds two user codes, and the listing doesn’t state a UL listing; pick 3 does. S&G also sells a Direct Drive version that you lock by hand; we left it out because its listing’s details don’t match the lock.

Why we like it

✓ Fits the common footprint
✓ Relocks by itself
✓ Battery included

Watch out for

✗ Hard-to-follow instructions
✗ No UL listing stated
✗ Two users only

Type

Electronic keypad, PivotBolt

Fits

Magic Module footprint, any direction

Codes

2 users

Bolt

Pivot bolt, relocks itself

Extras

EMP-tested, battery, 2-year warranty

Skip it if you want a UL-listed lock: see pick 3.

Pick 3 of 7

Most secure keypad

Lock: UL-listed keypad

Lockout: 15 minutes

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.7
Replaces most mechanical dial locks; owners say it fits
Reliability
4.7
Owners mostly call it reliable
Security
4.9
UL listed, internal relocker, 15-minute lockout
Value
4.3
Highest-priced pick

Here’s the deal: the most security on this page. AMSEC’s ESL10XL is a UL-listed electronic lock made to replace most mechanical combination locks. It has a dead-latched lock design with an internal relocker, it locks itself when the boltwork is thrown so the safe can’t be left unlocked by mistake, and four wrong entries shut it down for 15 minutes. Owners mostly say it’s reliable, easy to install and a good fit; one says it took under 20 minutes, another that it saved them a locksmith bill, and one that they and their spouse each open it in 15 seconds.

The catch: it’s the highest-priced pick, and only a few were in stock when we checked. The listing doesn’t say how many codes it holds or what battery it takes. The brass and chrome listings are the same lock in another finish.

Why we like it

✓ UL listed, with a relocker
✓ 15-minute lockout
✓ Owners mostly call it reliable

Watch out for

✗ Highest-priced
✗ Number of codes not listed
✗ Battery not listed

Type

Electronic keypad, UL listed

Fits

Replaces most dial locks

Codes

Not listed

Bolt

Dead-latched, internal relocker

Extras

Locks itself, 15-minute lockout

Skip it if your safe came with a round keypad and a solenoid: see pick 4.

Pick 4 of 7

Best budget keypad kit

Lock: Solenoid keypad kit

Keys: 2 override keys

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.3
Only safes built on a 3.74″ round keypad; owners split
Reliability
4.4
Owners mostly say it works; some faulty boards
Security
4.1
Solenoid pin with 2 override keys
Value
4.4
Low price; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: the low-priced fix for the many safes that came with a round keypad and a solenoid pin instead of a lock body. You replace the whole set: the keypad, the circuit board, the solenoid, the reset button and two override keys are all in the box. The keypad is 3.74 inches across, the code is 3 to 8 digits, and you can set one manager code and two user codes, plus a silent mode and decoy digits to hide your code. It runs on a 9V alkaline battery, which isn’t included. Owners mostly say it works, especially on gun safes, and that it’s plug and play to install.

The catch: WAHLIN says to use all of its parts, not just the keypad, and owners are split on the fit: some say it isn’t an exact match for their safe. Several report faulty circuit boards or wiring. A solenoid with override keys is the easiest kind of safe lock to beat, so it scores low on security. The same kit is sold in black and in chrome, and La Macaza sells what looks like the same kit under its own name.

Why we like it

✓ Low-priced kit
✓ Whole kit in the box
✓ Plug-and-play install

Watch out for

✗ Not every round-keypad safe
✗ Some faulty boards
✗ Solenoid, low security

Type

Solenoid keypad kit

Fits

Safes with a 3.74″ round keypad

Codes

1 manager + 2 users, 3–8 digits

Bolt

Solenoid pin, 2 override keys

Extras

9V alkaline battery (not included), silent mode

Skip it if you’d rather open with a fingerprint: see pick 5.

Pick 5 of 7

Best fingerprint upgrade

Lock: Fingerprint + code

Prints: 20

SafesGeek score
4.0/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.3
Only round-keypad solenoid safes, 3.94″ panel
Reliability
4.3
Owners split on how well it works
Security
4.1
Solenoid pin; a print-plus-code mode helps
Value
4.3
Low price; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: a fingerprint upgrade for a round-keypad safe. It stores up to 20 fingerprints, still opens with a 3- to 8-digit code, and can be set to need both a fingerprint and the code. Three wrong codes or five failed prints start a lockout. The round panel is 3.94 inches across, a little bigger than pick 4’s, and it runs on four AAA alkaline batteries. Owners say it was easy to install and fits: one says it lined up with the old mounting tabs, another that it’s a perfect fit on a Winchester TS-20 gun safe.

The catch: owners are split on how well it works and on the value. The listing contradicts itself: the bullets say the keypad weighs 0.77 ounces, the specs say 7.04 ounces. It lists no override key, so keep spare batteries. Like pick 4, it’s a solenoid lock and scores low on security. For a safe built around a reader from the start, see our best handgun safes.

Why we like it

✓ 20 fingerprints
✓ The code still works
✓ Fingerprint-plus-code mode

Watch out for

✗ Mixed reviews on how it works
✗ No override key listed
✗ Solenoid, low security

Type

Fingerprint and code kit

Fits

Safes with a 3.94″ round keypad

Codes

20 prints, 3–8 digit code

Bolt

Solenoid pin

Extras

4 AAA batteries, lockout after wrong tries

Skip it if you want backup keys: see pick 4.

Pick 6 of 7

Best for a larger round keypad

Lock: Solenoid keypad kit

Keys: 2 override keys

SafesGeek score
3.9/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.4
Safes with a 3.94″ round keypad; owners mostly say it fits
Reliability
4.3
Owners mostly call it reliable; battery drains fast
Security
4.1
Solenoid pin with 2 override keys
Value
4.4
Low price; owners mostly rate the value

Here’s the deal: a solenoid kit for round-keypad safes with the larger 3.94-inch panel, the size pick 5 uses. The box has the chrome keypad, the circuit board, the solenoid with two override keys and a red reset cable. The code is 3 to 8 digits, you can type decoy digits around it to hide it, and wrong codes start a lockout. Owners mostly say it’s reliable, easy to install and a good fit, and one says it took 15 minutes. Several say it’s worth the money.

The catch: several owners say it drains batteries fast, so keep a spare and the override keys handy. The listing doesn’t say which battery it takes or how many codes it holds. Like pick 4, it’s a solenoid with override keys, the easiest kind of safe lock to beat, so it scores low on security.

Why we like it

✓ Fits the larger 3.94″ keypad
✓ Whole kit in the box
✓ Decoy digits hide your code

Watch out for

✗ Drains batteries fast
✗ Battery type not listed
✗ Solenoid, low security

Type

Solenoid keypad kit

Fits

Safes with a 3.94″ round keypad

Codes

3–8 digits, decoy digits

Bolt

Solenoid pin, 2 override keys

Extras

Reset cable, lockout after wrong codes

Skip it if your safe’s keypad is 3.74 inches across: see pick 4.

Pick 7 of 7

Lowest-priced keypad kit

Lock: Solenoid keypad kit

Keys: 2 override keys

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Fit
4.1
No keypad size listed; owners split on the fit
Reliability
4.4
Owners say it works; one 9V lasts a year, says the maker
Security
4.1
Solenoid pin with 2 override keys
Value
4.4
Lowest-priced pick; owners lean positive on value

Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced kit on this page, for a safe with a round keypad and a solenoid pin. It has the keypad, the solenoid and two override keys, takes a 3- to 8-digit code and shows its state with three colored lights. TeukRiGa says one 9V battery lasts a year; the battery isn’t included. Owners say it works and was easy to install, and one says it fit their Sentry safe.

The catch: the listing gives no keypad size, so you can’t check the fit before you order, and owners are split on it: some say it isn’t an exact match. Its spec table mentions app control, which the bullets don’t; treat it as a keypad lock. It has fewer owner reviews than the other kits here. Like picks 4 and 6, it’s a solenoid with override keys and scores low on security.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest-priced pick
✓ Owners say it works
✓ Easy to install

Watch out for

✗ No keypad size listed
✗ Not an exact fit on every safe
✗ Solenoid, low security

Type

Solenoid keypad kit

Fits

Round-keypad solenoid safes (size not listed)

Codes

3–8 digits

Bolt

Solenoid pin, 2 override keys

Extras

9V battery (not included), manual reset

Skip it if you want to check the size before you buy: see pick 4.

PickLockPowerTypeFitsCodesBoltExtras
S&G 6730 dial lock
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
Mechanical dialNo batteriesMechanical dial, Group 2Home, gun and commercial safes1 combination, 3 wheelsSolid brassRelock trigger, dial and ring, 2-year warranty
S&G Spartan PivotBolt
Best keypad lock
4.5/5
Check price
Keypad, 2 users–Electronic keypad, PivotBoltMagic Module footprint2 usersPivot bolt, relocks itselfEMP-tested, battery, 2-year warranty
AMSEC ESL10XL
Most secure keypad
4.8/5
Check price
UL-listed keypad–Electronic keypad, UL listedReplaces most dial locksNot listedDead-latched, internal relockerLocks itself, 15-minute lockout
WAHLIN PARTS solenoid kit
Best budget keypad kit
4.4/5
Check price
Solenoid keypad kit–Solenoid keypad kitSafes with a 3.74″ round keypad1 manager + 2 users, 3–8 digitsSolenoid pin, 2 override keys9V alkaline battery (not included), silent mode
YOSEC E-115F
Best fingerprint upgrade
4.0/5
Check price
Fingerprint + code–Fingerprint and code kitSafes with a 3.94″ round keypad20 prints, 3–8 digit codeSolenoid pin4 AAA batteries, lockout after wrong tries
WAH YUE HING kit
Best for a larger round keypad
3.9/5
Check price
Solenoid keypad kit–Solenoid keypad kitSafes with a 3.94″ round keypad3–8 digits, decoy digitsSolenoid pin, 2 override keysReset cable, lockout after wrong codes
TeukRiGa kit
Lowest-priced keypad kit
4.2/5
Check price
Solenoid keypad kit–Solenoid keypad kitRound-keypad solenoid safes (size not listed)3–8 digitsSolenoid pin, 2 override keys9V battery (not included), manual reset

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

A replacement lock has one job: open your safe for you, and only you, for years. Five questions decide which one.

Open the door and look behind the keypad. Most full-size gun safes have a lock body: a metal case with a bolt, wired to the keypad or turned by a dial. Many lower-priced safes have a round keypad wired to a small solenoid pin instead. Picks 1 to 3 replace a lock body; picks 4 to 7 replace a solenoid kit. They don’t swap with each other.

Lock bodies mostly share one footprint, which S&G calls the “Magic Module”, so an S&G or AMSEC lock usually bolts into the same holes. Check which way the bolt moves and that the mounting holes line up. Round keypad kits differ in size and in the plug, and owners are split on whether a kit fits their safe. That’s what our Fit score measures.

A dial needs no battery and has the fewest parts that can fail, but it’s slow. A keypad opens in seconds but needs fresh batteries; across the low-priced kits we checked, almost every comment about battery life is a complaint. A fingerprint reader is fastest when it reads, and owners are split on how well it does. That’s our Reliability score.

Look for a rating the listing states: UL listed (pick 3) or Group 2 (pick 1). A relocker, a penalty lockout after wrong codes and a solid bolt all help. A solenoid pin with override keys is the weakest kind of safe lock. That’s our Security score.

Most owners do, and many say it took under half an hour, but more owners complain about the instructions than praise them. Work with the door open, test the lock again and again before you close it, and call a safe technician if the old lock won’t come off.

Make the safe stronger. A rated lock on a thin door is still a thin door, and no lock adds fire time. For that, see our best gun safes and best fireproof gun safes.

One last tip: while the door is open, look inside. A new lock is a good time to deal with damp, see our best gun safe dehumidifiers, and with clutter, see our best gun safe organizers.

Still not sure? Get the S&G 6730 dial lock.
A Group 2 dial with a relock trigger that never needs a battery, and owners mostly say it fits.
Check price on Amazon →
Can I replace a gun safe keypad myself?

Usually, yes. Most owners of these locks put them in themselves, and several say it took under half an hour. Do it with the door open, follow the maker’s video, and test the new lock several times before you close the door. If the safe is locked shut with a dead keypad, that’s a job for a safe technician.

Why did my gun safe keypad stop working?

Start with the battery: a weak battery is the first suspect, and several kit makers say to use alkaline batteries only. If a fresh battery doesn’t help, the keypad, the board or the solenoid may have failed, and a replacement kit or lock fixes it. On a low-priced safe that keeps failing, a new safe may make more sense; see our best budget gun safes.

Keypad or dial: which is better?

A dial never needs a battery and has the fewest parts to fail, but it takes longer to open. A keypad opens in seconds and can hold several codes. Pick 1 is a dial; picks 2 and 3 are keypads that fit the same kind of safe.

Will a new keypad fit my Winchester or Cannon safe?

It depends on which lock your safe has, not on the brand. Pull the keypad with the door open: a round keypad on a solenoid takes a kit like picks 4 to 7 (one owner fit pick 5 to a Winchester TS-20), and a lock body takes a lock like picks 1 to 3. Match the keypad size and the plug before you order.

What does “UL listed” mean on a safe lock?

UL tests safe locks against attack and tampering, and a listed lock passed. Pick 3 says it’s UL listed. For dial locks, Group 2 is UL’s rating for a combination lock with moderate resistance to expert manipulation; S&G says pick 1 held up for over 20 hours. A listing that names no rating has none you can count on.

Will a new lock make my safe harder to break into?

Only a little. A better lock stops code guessing and manipulation, but a thief usually attacks the door and the body, not the lock. For more steel and room, see our best large gun safes.

Is a gun safe lock the same as a gun lock?

No. A gun safe lock is the lock on the safe’s door. A gun lock goes on the gun itself, through the action or over the trigger; see our best gun locks.

Find your fit

A new keypad gives the gun safe you already own a fresh, reliable lock. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A fresh lock for your safe
→ Gun safe keypads (you're here)
Replacement electronic and dial locks that fit the safe you already own.
If you want
A whole new safe
→ Gun safes
More steel and more fire time, in a safe built around a new lock.
If you want
A handgun by the bed
→ Biometric gun safes
A small safe built around a fingerprint reader.
If you want
A new safe for less
→ Budget gun safes
A new budget safe replaces the whole thing, keypad and all.

How to choose a replacement safe lock →

We looked at 274 products that came up on Amazon across 3 searches for “gun safe keypad replacement”, “gun safe lock” and “electronic safe lock”. Most were door locks, luggage locks, gun locks and whole safes; 56 were replacement safe locks. Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews of those 56: whether the lock works, the installation, the quality, the fit and the value. Those became our four scores: fit, reliability, security and value.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 274 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. We only picked locks we could score on all four, and we skipped listings you can’t buy right now.

Replacement locks get far fewer owner reviews than safes, so one owner’s comment can stand out. Where a point comes from one owner, we say so.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.