7 Best Drop Boxes with Lock, Scored on Drop, Capacity, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: Mail Boss 7412. A tilting bin door and an anti-pry 10-disc wafer lock.
4.8/5Check price →
02
Best heavy-duty: PHYXOLOGY Cash Drop Box. 2 mm steel walls that mount on any side.
4.8/5Check price →
03
Best through-the-wall drop box: VEVOR Through-the-Wall Box. People drop outside, you collect inside.
4.5/5Check price →
04
Best through-the-door drop box: Plugsharge D2A-B. A combination lock and a rain hood on a wood door.
4.6/5Check price →
05
Best slim wall box: Adir 631. Only 3″ deep, with a 10″ slot for forms and checks.
4.7/5Check price →
06
Best value: xydled Suggestion Box. A small steel box with a key lock at the lowest price.
4.8/5Check price →
07
Best suggestion box kit: Mail Boss 8100. Cards, labels and hardware for a counter or a wall.
4.6/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 7

Best overall

Lock: Key, 3 keys

Mount: Wall

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Anti-fishing bin door; takes keys, letters and payments
Capacity
4.0*
No inside size listed; about 0.49 cu ft by its outside size
Security
4.3
16-gauge galvanized steel, anti-pry latch, 10-disc wafer lock
Value
4.6
Mid-priced; owners rate the durability highly

Here’s the deal: the drop box with the most owner feedback we found, and the one most built for the job. Mail Boss sells it for night drops, key drops, payment drops and interoffice mail. Instead of an open slot it has a bin door: a tilting hopper takes the envelope or the keys and drops them inside, so there’s never an open path from outside to the contents. The body is 16-gauge galvanized steel with a powder coat and stainless steel hinges. The lock is a commercial-grade 10-disc wafer lock behind a patented anti-pry latch with a tempered steel hook cam, with 3 laser-cut keys. It comes with the mounting hardware and a limited lifetime warranty against defects. Owners mostly praise how durable and secure it is and say it’s easy to mount yourself; one uses it as a real estate office drop box.

The catch: it’s made for indoor use or a covered spot outside, and owners are split on rain: about as many report water getting in as call it rainproof. They’re split on the size too. The listing gives no inside size; the outside is 11.2 × 4.7 × 16.2 inches, under half a cubic foot. A thick parcel won’t go through the bin door.

Why we like it

✓ Bin door: nothing to fish through
✓ Anti-pry latch, 10-disc wafer lock
✓ Most owner feedback we found

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on rain getting in
✗ No inside size listed
✗ Indoor or covered spots only

Size

11.2 × 4.7 × 16.2 in

Lock

10-disc wafer, 3 keys

Slot

Tilting bin door

Mount

Wall, hardware included

Build

16-gauge galvanized steel

Skip it if people should drop from outside while you collect inside: see pick 3.

Keys or cash inside? Empty it the same day.

Every drop box here keeps honest people honest. It’s sheet steel screwed to a wall, a door or a counter, so someone with a pry bar and a few minutes can get in, and a box full of car keys or envelopes is a reason to try. Empty it every day, ask for checks instead of cash, and lock what you collect in a safe; see our best money safes. If staff drop cash all day inside a shop, see our best drop safes.

Pick 2 of 7

Best heavy-duty

Steel: 2 mm

Mount: Any side

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.3
Tamper-proof blade under the slot; slot size not listed
Capacity
3.8*
0.25 cu ft listed, which is its outside size
Security
4.4
2 mm steel walls, pry-resistant hinge, mounts on any side
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners rate the quality highly

Here’s the deal: the thickest steel on this page, in a small box sold as a key depository and deposit box for hotels, apartments and stores. The walls are 2 mm steel, the hinge is pry-resistant, and a tamper-proof blade under the slot stops anyone reaching back in. It’s 12 × 6 × 6 inches with pre-drilled holes on every side, so it can go on a wall, between the studs, on the floor or under a counter, with the hardware in the box. The key lock needs no batteries, and 3 keys come with it. Owners rate the build highly, say it works well, and one uses it for a store’s nightly drops.

The catch: it’s small. The 0.25 cubic feet listed is the outside size, so the inside holds less: fine for envelopes and keys, not for thick packets or a stack of forms. The listing doesn’t give the slot size, and it isn’t water resistant, so keep it indoors or under cover.

Why we like it

✓ 2 mm steel, the thickest here
✓ Mounts on a wall, floor or counter
✓ Low price

Watch out for

✗ Small: 0.25 cu ft is the outside
✗ Slot size not listed
✗ Not water resistant

Size

12 × 6 × 6 in

Lock

Key, 3 keys

Slot

Size not listed, blade underneath

Mount

Wall, floor or under a counter

Build

2 mm steel

Skip it if you collect letter-size forms or mail: see pick 5.

Pick 3 of 7

Best through-the-wall drop box

Lock: Combination

Walls: 2.8–7.9 in

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.7
Rain shield over a 1.6 in slot, drain holes, metal baffles
Capacity
4.0*
0.74 cu ft listed; the outside is only 0.77
Security
4.1
Steel, gauge not listed; combination lock
Value
4.6
Low-priced; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: for an office or a shop where people should drop from the street while you collect inside, this box goes through the wall. Only the slot faces outside, under a large rain shield, and the box hangs on the inside wall with drain holes and rubber pads in the bottom. The slot is 9.8 × 1.6 inches, tall enough for keys on a ring, a phone or a thick envelope, with metal baffles inside against fishing. The adjustable chute fits walls from 2.8 to 7.9 inches thick. It opens with a combination you can change at any time, so there are no keys to hand out or lose, and a 2 × 4 inch window in the door shows whether anything has come in. It’s 13.5 lb of steel.

The catch: owners have said little about it so far, and they’re split on how easy it is to install: you have to cut a hole through the wall. The rain features are the listing’s claims; owners haven’t confirmed them yet. The listing says 0.74 cubic feet, but the outside is 12.6 × 6.22 × 16.93 inches, only 0.77, so the inside is smaller. VEVOR doesn’t give the steel gauge or how many digits the code has.

Why we like it

✓ Drop from outside, collect inside
✓ Rain shield and drain holes
✓ 1.6 in slot takes keys on a ring

Watch out for

✗ Needs a hole cut through the wall
✗ Steel gauge not listed
✗ Little owner feedback yet

Size

12.6 × 6.2 × 16.9 in

Lock

Combination, code you can change

Slot

9.8 × 1.6 in

Mount

Through walls 2.8–7.9 in

Build

Steel, 13.5 lb

Skip it if you can’t cut a hole in the wall: see pick 4.

Pick 4 of 7

Best through-the-door drop box

Lock: Combination

Doors: Wood, up to 1.75 in

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.6
Deposits through the door; anti-fishing design and rain hood
Capacity
4.0*
765 cu in listed, the same as its outside size
Security
4.1
1.5 mm galvanized steel, combination lock; screwed to a wood door
Value
4.4
Pricier; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the same idea as a through-the-wall box, but through a door, so there’s no wall to cut. People drop keys, checks, forms or letters through the slot on the outside of the door, and you open the box on the inside. An internal anti-fishing design stops hooks reaching the contents, an extended rain hood sits over the slot, and the inside has a rubber mat. The body is 1.5 mm galvanized steel with a powder coat, and it opens with a combination, so staff don’t need keys. It fits wood doors up to 1.75 inches thick and comes with the mounting hardware. The few owners so far say the quality is better than they expected and it works well.

The catch: little owner feedback yet, and it’s one of the pricier boxes here. It only fits wood doors up to 1.75 inches thick, so a metal door or a thicker door is out. The listing says the inside is 12 × 4.25 × 15 inches (765 cubic inches), which is the outside size too, so the inside is smaller. It gives no slot size or code length, and when we checked it said it usually ships in 4 to 5 weeks.

Why we like it

✓ No hole in a wall needed
✓ Combination lock: no keys to hand out
✓ Rain hood over the slot

Watch out for

✗ Wood doors up to 1.75 in only
✗ Little owner feedback yet
✗ Ships in weeks, not days

Size

12 × 4.25 × 15 in

Lock

Combination

Slot

Size not listed, rain hood

Mount

Through wood doors up to 1.75 in

Build

1.5 mm galvanized steel

Skip it if you want a box with lots of owner feedback: see pick 1.

Pick 5 of 7

Best slim wall box

Depth: 3 in

Slot: 10 in wide

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.1
10 × 5/16 in top slot; no baffle listed
Capacity
3.8*
About 0.21 cu ft by its outside size
Security
4.1
Heavy-gauge steel, piano hinge, key lock; gauge not listed
Value
4.7
Low-priced; owners rate the quality highly

Here’s the deal: a flat steel box only 3 inches deep that hangs flat on a wall or a door, with a 10-inch slot in the top. That wide, thin slot takes letter-size forms, checks, envelopes and comment cards without folding them twice. The steel is powder coated, the door has a full piano hinge and a key lock, and it comes with 2 keys, screws and pre-drilled holes, in a choice of colors. It has the most owner feedback after pick 1, and owners mostly praise the quality, how sturdy it is and how easy it is to hang; they use it for rent checks, employee surveys, quizzes and after-hours sales.

The catch: the slot is only 5/16 inch tall, so a key on a ring or a thick envelope won’t go in, whatever the listing says about keys. There’s no baffle listed behind the slot, so it’s for paper, not cash left overnight. The listing gives two sizes: 12 × 3 × 10 inches in the text and 3 × 3 × 12 inches in the specs; going by the first, it holds about 0.21 cubic feet. It isn’t sold as weatherproof, so keep it inside.

Why we like it

✓ Only 3 in deep on the wall
✓ 10 in slot for forms and checks
✓ Owners rate the quality highly

Watch out for

✗ 5/16 in slot: too thin for keys
✗ No anti-fishing baffle listed
✗ Listing gives two sizes

Size

12 × 3 × 10 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Slot

10 × 5/16 in, top

Mount

Wall or door, screws included

Build

Powder-coated steel, piano hinge

Skip it if people drop keys: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 7

Best value

Lock: Key, 2 keys

Mount: Wall or desk

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.0
Slot size not listed; no baffle listed
Capacity
3.8*
Listed as 357 “cubic feet”; about 0.21 cu ft by its outside size
Security
4.0
Steel, gauge not listed; key lock
Value
4.9
Lowest-priced; owners mostly praise the sturdiness and the lock

Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced pick, a small steel box with a slot on top and a key lock, sold as a suggestion, ballot, donation and drop box. It stands on a desk or a counter, or screws to a wall with the screws and pre-drilled holes in the box. Owners have nothing but praise for how sturdy it is, and they like the lock: one uses it for workplace cash collections during shifts, another for collecting payments.

The catch: it’s small, 7.3 × 5.9 × 8.3 inches outside. The listing calls that 357 cubic feet; it means cubic inches, about 0.21 cubic feet. The listing doesn’t give the slot size, the steel gauge or any anti-fishing design, so it’s for cards, notes and envelopes in a room you watch, not for an unattended box full of cash.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest price here
✓ Owners praise how sturdy it is
✓ Stands on a desk or hangs on a wall

Watch out for

✗ Small: about 0.21 cu ft
✗ No anti-fishing design listed
✗ Slot size not listed

Size

7.3 × 5.9 × 8.3 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Slot

Top, size not listed

Mount

Wall or desk, screws included

Build

Steel, coated

Skip it if the box will hang somewhere nobody watches: see pick 1.

Pick 7 of 7

Best suggestion box kit

Comes with: Cards, labels

Mount: Counter or wall

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Drop
4.0
Slot size not listed; no baffle listed
Capacity
3.8*
About 0.23 cu ft by its outside size
Security
4.0
Steel, 4 lb, key lock
Value
4.6
Low-priced; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: a small steel comment box from Mail Boss, ready to use out of the box. It comes with comment and suggestion cards, sticker labels, 2 keys and mounting hardware, and it sits on a counter or a desk or screws to a wall or any flat surface. Mail Boss sells it for comments, ballots, tips, keys, room cards and donations, with a scratch- and rust-resistant powder coat and a limited lifetime warranty. Owners like the size and say it’s versatile, with several using it at farm and vegetable stands.

The catch: it’s 9.5 × 7 × 6 inches and 4 lb, about 0.23 cubic feet, so it’s light enough to carry off unless you screw it down. The listing gives no slot size, steel gauge or anti-fishing design, and there’s little owner feedback so far, though all of it is positive. When we checked, stock was low.

Why we like it

✓ Cards, labels and hardware included
✓ Counter, desk or wall
✓ Limited lifetime warranty

Watch out for

✗ Light: screw it down
✗ No anti-fishing design listed
✗ Little owner feedback yet

Size

9.5 × 7 × 6 in

Lock

Key, 2 keys

Slot

Top, size not listed

Mount

Counter, desk or wall

Build

Powder-coated steel, 4 lb

Skip it if you want the lowest price: see pick 6.

PickLockMountSizeSlotBuildSteelWalls
Mail Boss 7412
Best overall
4.8/5
Check price
Key, 3 keysWall11.2 × 4.7 × 16.2 inTilting bin door16-gauge galvanized steel––
PHYXOLOGY Cash Drop Box
Best heavy-duty
4.8/5
Check price
Key, 3 keysAny side12 × 6 × 6 inSize not listed, blade underneath2 mm steel2 mm–
VEVOR Through-the-Wall Box
Best through-the-wall drop box
4.5/5
Check price
CombinationThrough walls 2.8–7.9 in12.6 × 6.2 × 16.9 in9.8 × 1.6 inSteel, 13.5 lb–2.8–7.9 in
Plugsharge D2A-B
Best through-the-door drop box
4.6/5
Check price
CombinationThrough wood doors up to 1.75 in12 × 4.25 × 15 inSize not listed, rain hood1.5 mm galvanized steel––
Adir 631
Best slim wall box
4.7/5
Check price
Key, 2 keysWall or door, screws included12 × 3 × 10 in10 in widePowder-coated steel, piano hinge––
xydled Suggestion Box
Best value
4.8/5
Check price
Key, 2 keysWall or desk7.3 × 5.9 × 8.3 inTop, size not listedSteel, coated––
Mail Boss 8100
Best suggestion box kit
4.6/5
Check price
Key, 2 keysCounter or wall9.5 × 7 × 6 inTop, size not listedPowder-coated steel, 4 lb––

A drop box with lock has one job: let people leave something at any time while only you can take it out. Six questions decide which one.

A wall box (picks 1, 2 and 5) is the easiest: a few screws and it’s up, in a lobby, a hallway or a covered spot outside. A through-the-wall box (pick 3) lets people drop from outside while you collect inside, but you have to cut a hole in a wall whose thickness falls in the box’s range. A through-the-door box (pick 4) does the same through a wood door, with no wall to cut. A small box for a counter or a desk (picks 6 and 7) suits comments, ballots and tips in a room where someone is around.

This is what makes a drop box more than a box with a slot. A tilting bin door (pick 1) never leaves an open path to the inside. A blade under the slot (pick 2), metal baffles (pick 3) or an anti-fishing chute (pick 4) make it hard to hook anything back out. Picks 5, 6 and 7 list no baffle, so they’re fine for forms and comment cards but shouldn’t hold cash or car keys overnight.

Check the slot before you buy. A key on a ring needs about an inch: the bin door on pick 1 and the 1.6 inch slot on pick 3 take one, while the 5/16 inch slot on pick 5 takes paper only. For keys that you hand out rather than take in, see our best key lock boxes, and for a hook for every key in the office, our best key cabinets.

None of the picks is waterproof, and several listings say outright that they aren’t water resistant. Owners of pick 1 are split on rain coming in through the slot. Mount a wall box under a roof or an awning, or choose a through-the-wall or through-the-door box (picks 3 and 4) so only the slot and its rain cover face the weather.

Smaller than you’d think. A day of keys, checks and forms fits in any pick here. Go by the outside inches: several listings claim the outside size, or more, as the room inside. For the mail carrier and small parcels, see our best locking mailboxes or our best wall mount mailboxes; for parcels, our best package delivery boxes.

Not back in the drop box. Lock payments in a safe as soon as you collect them; see our best money safes. For a landlord’s office, our best rent drop boxes go deeper on rent day. A shop where staff drop cash all day needs a drop safe instead; see our best drop safes. For cash you hand out and count at a table, see our best cash boxes.

One last tip: many drop boxes on Amazon are the same steel box under several brand names, so don’t pay more for a name alone. Compare the steel, the anti-fishing design, the slot size and the lock.

Still not sure? Get the Mail Boss 7412.
A tilting bin door, 16-gauge steel and an anti-pry 10-disc wafer lock.
Check price on Amazon →
What is a drop box with lock?

A steel box with a slot and a locked door. Anyone can drop keys, checks, forms, mail or comment cards through the slot at any time, and only the person with the key or the code can open the door and take them out. Better ones add a bin door, a baffle or a blade behind the slot so nobody can fish anything back out.

Is a locking drop box safe for cash?

For a few hours, yes; overnight, not on its own. These are light steel boxes with no burglary rating, held on by screws, so a thief with a pry bar can get in. Ask for checks instead of cash, empty the box every day, and keep what you collect in one of our best money safes.

Can I mount a drop box outside?

Only under cover. None of the picks is waterproof, owners of the best-selling box are split on rain coming in through the slot, and several listings say they aren’t water resistant. Put it under a roof or an awning, or use a through-the-wall or through-the-door box (picks 3 and 4) so only the slot is outside.

Can I use a suggestion box as a payment drop box?

For checks and forms in a room someone watches, yes. Picks 5, 6 and 7 list no anti-fishing baffle, so a thin tool can reach through the slot. For payments left after hours, pick a box with a bin door or a baffle (picks 1 to 4).

Can I use one as a key drop box for a car shop or a rental office?

Yes, if the slot fits a key on a ring, about an inch tall. The bin door on pick 1 and the 1.6 inch slot on pick 3 take keys; the 5/16 inch slot on pick 5 doesn’t. Empty it every morning: a box of car keys is worth more than it looks.

What about a lockable drop box on a post at the curb?

That’s a locking mailbox with a drop slot, made for the mail carrier, and many go on a post. See our best locking mailboxes.

Find your fit

A drop box with lock lets anyone leave keys, payments or notes while only you take them out. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Keys, payments and notes dropped any time
→ Drop boxes with lock (you're here)
Wall, door and counter boxes with a slot and a locked door.
If you want
Cash dropped in on site
→ Drop safes
Drop safes of 30 to 61 lb that bolt down, for a shop's cash.
If you want
Your home mail locked away
→ Locking mailboxes
Post and wall mailboxes with an anti-pry lock and a baffle door for the mail carrier.
If you want
Parcels left safely at the door
→ Package delivery boxes
Big porch boxes with a one-way drop for deliveries.

How to choose a drop box with lock →

We looked at 98 products that came up on Amazon when we searched for “drop box with lock”, on its own and with eight of Amazon’s filters (anti-fishing baffle, rear access, drop chute, post and flush mounts, and two brands). Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews of all those boxes: how sturdy and secure they are, the size and the slot, the lock, rain getting in and the value. Those became our four scores.

Many listings are the same steel box under several brand names, so we kept one per body, the listing with the most owner feedback. We left out wall and post mailboxes, farm-stand cash boxes, acrylic donation boxes and drop safes, which are made for other jobs, and boxes whose owners mostly complain about the lock or the security.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 98 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. One exception: when every pick is weak on the same stat, we still show that score, marked with *, but leave it out of the overall, because it can’t tell the picks apart.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.