Buying guide · Updated for 2026
7 Best Centurion Gun Safe Alternatives You Can Order Online
Searching for a Centurion gun safe? The Centurion is Liberty Safe’s entry-level line, made in the USA in 12, 18 and 24-gun sizes and sold through dealers and stores. Its one Amazon listing has no price and no seller, and we aren’t connected to Liberty. So we looked at the 161 listings Amazon shows for “centurion gun safe” and kept 7 full-size, fire-rated long-gun safes of the same kind that you can order online, scored on protection, capacity, security and value.
By the SafesGeek review team. If you buy through our links, we earn a commission at no cost to you. But it never changes our picks.
The short version
Pick 1 of 7
Kodiak KBX5629 Gun Safe (42-gun)
Best overall
Fire: 30 min · 1400°F
Holds: 9+ scoped rifles, owners say
Here’s the deal: the safe here with by far the most owner feedback, and the most room for the money. Rhino Metals makes it. It’s 56 × 29 × 22 inches of 14-gauge steel and weighs 333 to 390 pounds (sources differ). It’s rated for 30 minutes at 1400°F, a hotter test than the Centurion’s 1200°F, with fireboard in the walls, floor, ceiling and door and a seal that swells up to 8 times in heat to keep smoke out. A UL-listed electronic lock sits behind a hardened armor plate, and a spring-loaded relocker jams the door if someone attacks the lock. The door opens 180 degrees and carries an organizer with handgun holders, and the shelf adjusts. Owners rate the quality, security and value highly, and say the lock is easy to set up. It’s also a pick on our best gun safes page.
The catch: it won’t hold 42 guns with scopes. Most owners say it has room for what they store, but some say it won’t hold all their long guns: one fit 9 rifles on one side with space for a couple more by the door, and another says the count is true only without scopes. At 29 inches wide it’s wider than a Centurion 24, so measure the spot. The fire figure is the maker’s; the listing doesn’t name the lab. It comes by freight, and at over 300 pounds it needs a plan for getting it inside and bolting it down.
Why we like it
✓ Most owner feedback of the safes
✓ UL-listed lock behind an armor plate
✓ 30 min at 1400°F, heat-sealing door
Watch out for
✗ About half of 42 fit with scopes
✗ 29 in wide: measure the spot
✗ Fire test lab not named
Size
56 × 29 × 22 in
Lock
UL-listed electronic, relocker
Inside
Not listed
Holds
Listed 42; 9+ scoped rifles, owners say
Build
14-gauge steel, 333–390 lb, 30 min fire
Skip it if you want a longer fire rating: see pick 2.
A fire rating is minutes at a set heat.
“30 minutes at 1400°F” means the maker heated the safe to 1400°F for 30 minutes and the inside stayed cool enough for paper. Liberty rates the Centurion the same way, at 30 minutes and 1200°F, a gentler heat. None of the listings here names an independent lab, so compare the minutes and the heat together, and don’t read “fireproof” as more than that.
Pick 2 of 7
Wasatch 24-Gun Fire and Water Safe (24EDBW)
Best fire and water
Fire: 45 min · 1400°F
Water: 72 hr in 2 ft, listed
Here’s the deal: the only pick with figures for both fire and water. Wasatch rates it for 45 minutes at 1400°F, longer and hotter than the Centurion’s 30 minutes at 1200°F, and for 72 hours in 2 feet of standing water. It’s listed for 24 guns, like a Centurion 24, with 10.4 cubic feet inside a 55 × 24 × 15-inch body. A backlit electronic lock with an alarm opens it, and a backup key comes with it. Three 1.5-inch live bolts and two dead bolts hold the door, which swings a full 180 degrees on outside hinges and has storage built into it. The body is 2 mm steel, about 14 gauge, with a plush tan interior and a dark bronze finish.
The catch: the listing is short. It doesn’t give the weight, the number of shelves or whether it’s pre-drilled to bolt down, so ask the seller before it ships. The 15-inch depth listed is shallow for a 24-gun safe, so check it against your longest scoped rifle. Owners rate it, but haven’t raised clear topics yet. Fortress (pick 6) appears to be a sister brand: their listings share model codes and lock names. The fire and water figures are Wasatch’s own; no lab is named. It comes by freight.
Why we like it
✓ 45 min at 1400°F
✓ 72 hours in 2 ft of water, listed
✓ Alarm lock with a backup key
Watch out for
✗ Weight not listed
✗ 15 in deep, listed
✗ Few owner topics yet
Size
55 × 24 × 15 in
Lock
Backlit electronic, alarm, backup key
Inside
10.4 cu ft, listed
Holds
Listed 24 guns
Build
2 mm steel, 5 bolts, 45 min fire
Skip it if you want thicker steel and more bolts: see pick 3.
Pick 3 of 7
Tracker Safe M32 Gun Safe (32-gun, dial lock)
Toughest build
Fire: 60 min · 1250°F
Lock: Dial, no batteries
Here’s the deal: the heaviest, thickest safe here. Its body is 11-gauge (3 mm) steel and its composite door is 5 inches thick. Twelve 1.25-inch steel bolts lock the full door, a drill-resistant hard plate guards the lock, and the safe weighs 700 pounds. Tracker rates it for 60 minutes at 1250°F, twice the Centurion’s 30 minutes. It opens with a mechanical dial, so there are no batteries or electronics to fail. A door organizer and a power outlet come standard, and it’s listed for 32 guns. For more dial safes, see our best mechanical gun safes.
The catch: it’s the most expensive pick, and no owner has rated it yet. The listing doesn’t give the size, so ask for the spec sheet and measure doorways first. It doesn’t mention anchor holes either. The fire figure is Tracker’s own, with no lab named. At 700 pounds it comes by freight and needs movers or a heavy-duty dolly, and a dial is slower to open than a keypad. Thirty-two guns is the label: with scopes, plan on about half.
Why we like it
✓ 11-gauge steel, 5-inch door
✓ Twelve 1.25-inch bolts, hard plate
✓ 60 min fire, dial lock
Watch out for
✗ Most expensive pick
✗ Size not listed
✗ No owner ratings yet
Size
Not listed
Lock
Mechanical dial, hard plate
Inside
Not listed
Holds
Listed 32 guns
Build
11-gauge steel, 700 lb, 60 min fire
Skip it if you want owner feedback before you spend this much: see pick 1.
Pick 4 of 7
Stealth EGS14 Essential Gun Safe (14-gun)
Best 14-gun safe
Fire: 30 min
Lock: UL-listed electronic
Here’s the deal: the nearest match here to a Centurion 12, in size and fire rating. It’s 55 × 20 × 17 inches (add 3 inches for the handle), 14-gauge steel, listed for 14 long guns and rated for 30 minutes, with a door seal that swells 7 times in heat. A UL-listed electronic lock, assembled in the USA, sits behind a drill-resistant hard plate with a relocker, and six 1-inch bolts lock the door. It comes ready to use: an outlet kit with 3 outlets and 2 USB ports, adjustable shelves and a MOLLE organizer on the door. Four holes let you bolt it down, it’s California DOJ approved, and Stealth covers break-ins and house fires for life. Owners like the quality, the easy lock and the value. Stealth’s bigger EGS28 is on our best 30 gun safes page.
The catch: the listing gives the fire time but not the temperature, so it can’t be set side by side with the 1400°F figures above. Owners are split on room: several say it holds all their guns, one doubts it takes 14 rifles. At 20 inches wide, plan on fewer with scopes. The weight is given as 230 and 260 pounds in two places. It comes by freight, and you must give a phone number and be home to sign.
Why we like it
✓ UL-listed lock, hard plate, relocker
✓ Outlets and USB inside
✓ Lifetime fire and break-in warranty
Watch out for
✗ No fire temperature listed
✗ Owners split on room
✗ Weight listed two ways
Size
55 × 20 × 17 in
Lock
UL-listed electronic, relocker
Inside
Not listed
Holds
Listed 14 long guns
Build
14-gauge steel, 230–260 lb, 6 bolts
Skip it if you need room for 24 guns: see pick 2.
Pick 5 of 7
XPEDITION 24-Gun Fireproof Safe (GSF-E175)
Best budget pick
Fire: 45 min · 1400°F
Holds: 12–16 guns, owners say
Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced pick, and a full-size fire-rated safe that arrives assembled. It’s 55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 inches and 326 pounds of reinforced steel. XPEDITION says it protects contents for 45 minutes at 1400°F and is water-resistant. It opens with a keypad or backup keys. The keypad sounds an alarm after 3 wrong tries, and the safe has a vibration alarm and a silent mode. A power outlet inside lets you charge devices or run a dehumidifier: see our best gun safe dehumidifiers. Adjustable racks, pouches and dividers organize rifles, pistols and ammo. It’s also on our best fireproof gun safes page.
The catch: the fire rating is XPEDITION’s own. The listing doesn’t say who tested it, and gives no figures for the water claim. It’s sold as a 24-gun safe, but owners say 12–16 is realistic once scopes are on. The listed 15.7 cubic feet is the outside size (55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 ÷ 1,728), so the inside is less. The same safe is sold as the VALINIRT 24-gun, and the owner feedback is shared across XPEDITION’s safes, so there’s little on this one. At 326 pounds, it arrives by freight.
Why we like it
✓ Lowest-priced pick
✓ 45 min at 1400°F, arrives assembled
✓ Power outlet inside
Watch out for
✗ Fire test lab not named
✗ 12–16 guns, not 24, owners say
✗ Listed 15.7 cu ft is the outside
Size
55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 in
Lock
Keypad, backup keys
Inside
Under 15.7 cu ft
Holds
12–16 guns, owners say
Build
Steel, 326 lb, outlet inside
Skip it if you want a UL-listed lock: see pick 4.
Pick 6 of 7
Fortress 14-Gun Fireproof Safe (14CBF)
Best budget mechanical lock
Fire: 30 min · 1200°F
Lock: Combination, no batteries
Here’s the deal: a mid-size fire safe with no batteries to fail, at a low price. It’s 55 × 20.25 × 19 inches and 270 pounds, built from 2 mm steel (about 14 gauge). Fortress rates it for 30 minutes at 1200°F, the same figure Liberty gives a Centurion 12. Three 1-inch active bolts, two dead bolts and Fortress’s patented notch bolt hold the door, and external hinges let it swing open a full 180 degrees, so the whole inside is easy to reach. The gray interior converts between rifle racks and shelves, and a lever handle opens it. Owners like its safety features.
The catch: owners are split on the quality, the weakest owner feedback of the picks with ratings. The listing says “combination lock” but never says dial, so check the photos. The fire rating is Fortress’s own, with no lab named, and 1200°F is a cooler test than the 1400°F figures above. Listed gun counts rarely allow for scopes, so plan on fewer than 14. It ships by freight, and someone has to be home.
Why we like it
✓ Combination lock: no batteries
✓ Five bolts, 180° door
✓ Convertible interior
Watch out for
✗ Owners split on quality
✗ 1200°F, a cooler fire test
✗ Lock type not shown as dial
Size
55 × 20.25 × 19 in
Lock
Combination, mechanical
Inside
Not listed
Holds
Listed 14 guns
Build
2 mm steel, 270 lb, 5 bolts
Skip it if you want a dial on a tougher safe: see pick 3.
Pick 7 of 7
Crescent Shield CS-24E Gun Safe
Best American-assembled
Fire: 75 min
Origin: Assembled in America
Here’s the deal: the pick for a Centurion shopper who wants a safe put together in the USA. The listing says it’s assembled in America, and names Hollon Safe Company as the manufacturer. It opens with a Sargent & Greenleaf UL Type 1 electronic lock that takes 2 user codes, set behind a drill-resistant hard plate in 12-gauge steel. It’s listed for 24 long guns, like a Centurion 24, weighs 500 pounds and carries a 75-minute fire figure, the longest here. For safes whose listings say made in the USA, see our best American made gun safes.
The catch: this is the shortest listing of the seven. The 75 minutes comes with no temperature and no lab, so we can’t compare it with the 1400°F figures above. The listing gives no size inside or out, doesn’t say how many bolts lock the door, and doesn’t mention anchor holes, so ask the seller for the spec sheet first. The specs call a 500-pound safe portable, which it isn’t. No owners have rated it on Amazon yet, and it’s one of the two priciest picks.
Why we like it
✓ Assembled in America, per the listing
✓ S&G UL Type 1 electronic lock
✓ 12-gauge steel, hard plate
Watch out for
✗ Fire figure has no temperature
✗ Size not listed
✗ No owner ratings yet
Size
Not listed
Lock
S&G UL Type 1 keypad, 2 users
Inside
Not listed
Holds
Listed for 24 long guns
Build
12-gauge steel, 500 lb, 75 min fire
Skip it if you want a fire figure with a temperature: see pick 2.
Compare the specs
| Pick | Fire | Holds | Size | Lock | Inside | Build | Water |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kodiak KBX5629 Best overall 4.6/5 Check price | 30 min · 1400°F | 9+ scoped rifles, owners say | 56 × 29 × 22 in | UL-listed electronic, relocker | Not listed | 14-gauge steel, 333–390 lb, 30 min fire | – |
| Wasatch 24 Best fire and water 4.3/5 Check price | 45 min · 1400°F | Listed 24 guns | 55 × 24 × 15 in | Backlit electronic, alarm, backup key | 10.4 cu ft, listed | 2 mm steel, 5 bolts, 45 min fire | 72 hr in 2 ft, listed |
| Tracker M32 Toughest build 4.4/5 Check price | 60 min · 1250°F | Listed 32 guns | Not listed | Dial, no batteries | Not listed | 11-gauge steel, 700 lb, 60 min fire | – |
| Stealth EGS14 Best 14-gun safe 4.3/5 Check price | 30 min | Listed 14 long guns | 55 × 20 × 17 in | UL-listed electronic | Not listed | 14-gauge steel, 230–260 lb, 6 bolts | – |
| XPEDITION 24 Best budget pick 4.5/5 Check price | 45 min · 1400°F | 12–16 guns, owners say | 55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 in | Keypad, backup keys | Under 15.7 cu ft | Steel, 326 lb, outlet inside | – |
| Fortress 14CBF Best budget mechanical lock 3.4/5 Check price | 30 min · 1200°F | Listed 14 guns | 55 × 20.25 × 19 in | Combination, no batteries | Not listed | 2 mm steel, 270 lb, 5 bolts | – |
| Crescent Shield CS-24E Best American-assembled 4.4/5 Check price | 75 min | Listed for 24 long guns | Not listed | S&G UL Type 1 keypad, 2 users | Not listed | 12-gauge steel, 500 lb, 75 min fire | – |
Specs as each maker or listing states them, Nov 2026. Tap a name to jump to its review.
Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds
What do you want to lock up?
How to choose a Centurion gun safe alternative
A Centurion gun safe is a first real gun safe for many buyers: fire-lined, full height and made to bolt down. Six questions decide which alternative fits you.
What is a Centurion gun safe?
It’s Liberty Safe’s entry-level line, made in the USA in 12, 18 and 24-gun sizes, with an electronic or dial lock. Liberty rates it for 30 minutes at 1200°F, and 40 minutes on the 24-gun size. Liberty sells it through dealers and stores, not on Amazon: the one Amazon listing we found has no price and no seller. The safes here are the same kind of safe from other brands, and two of them, picks 4 and 7, have US-assembled parts. For safes whose listings say made in the USA, see our best American made gun safes.
How long a fire rating do you need?
Compare minutes and heat together: 45 minutes at 1400°F beats 30 minutes at 1200°F. The picks here run from 30 to 75 minutes, all by their makers’ own figures with no lab named, the same as the Centurion’s. If papers matter as much as guns, a longer rating is worth more than a bigger gun count. For more fire-rated gun safes, see our best fireproof gun safes.
How many guns will really fit?
Plan on about half the label. Gun counts assume bare rifles packed tight; scopes, slings and bipods take the room, and door organizers and shelves take more. If you’re choosing between a Centurion 12 and 24, see our best 12 gun safes and our best 24 gun safes, and for bigger collections our best large gun safes.
Keypad or dial?
A keypad opens in seconds and most here have a backup key. A dial or combination lock needs no batteries and has no circuit board to fail, but it’s slower. Pick 3 has a dial, pick 6 a combination lock; the rest open with a keypad.
Can you get it inside?
The safes here weigh from about 230 pounds to 700 and come by freight, usually to the curb or the garage. Plan on a heavy-duty dolly from our best gun safe dolly guide and 2 or 3 strong people, or movers, and measure doorways and stairs first: the picks with a listed size are 20 to 29 inches wide.
Keep it dry
A closed steel safe traps moisture. Put a dehumidifier inside: picks 3, 4 and 5 have an outlet built in, which makes a plug-in rod easy.
One last tip: bolt it down. A tall safe can tip forward when the heavy door swings open, and bolts keep a thief from walking off with it. Picks 1 and 4 are pre-drilled to bolt down; ask the seller about the rest.
Quick answers
Can you buy a Centurion gun safe on Amazon?
Not from a seller we could find. Liberty’s one Centurion listing on Amazon has no price and no seller. Liberty sells the Centurion through its dealers and stores; the safes on this page are the same kind of safe that you can order online.
Is a Centurion gun safe fireproof?
No safe is fireproof. Liberty rates the Centurion for 30 minutes at 1200°F, and 40 minutes on the 24-gun size. The picks here are rated for 30 to 75 minutes by their makers.
What’s the closest alternative to a Centurion 12?
Pick 4, the Stealth EGS14: listed for 14 long guns and rated for 30 minutes, with a UL-listed lock. Pick 6, the Fortress 14CBF, has the same 30 minutes at 1200°F that Liberty gives the Centurion 12.
What’s the closest alternative to a Centurion 24?
Picks 2, 5 and 7 are listed for 24 guns. The Wasatch (pick 2) adds a water rating, the XPEDITION (pick 5) is the lowest-priced pick, and the Crescent Shield (pick 7) is assembled in America.
Which of these safes has a dial lock?
Pick 3, the Tracker M32, opens with a mechanical dial. Pick 6, the Fortress, has a combination lock; check the photos to see whether it’s a dial. The others open with a keypad.
How much does a Centurion-style gun safe weigh?
The picks here weigh from about 230 pounds to 700, and one listing gives no weight. All come by freight; plan on help or movers to get one inside.
Find your fit
A Centurion gun safe is a fire-lined first gun safe, and every pick here is that kind of safe you can order online. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.
How we picked
We looked at 161 products that came up on Amazon in our searches for “centurion gun safe”. Liberty’s own Centurion 12 listing was among them, but with no price and no seller, so it can’t be bought there. Most of the rest were handgun boxes, home safes and thin rifle cabinets that the search pulls in. We kept what a Centurion shopper is after: full-size long-gun safes with a fire figure in the listing. We kept one pick per brand name, and picked them for different needs: the most owner feedback, fire and water figures, the toughest build, the nearest match to a Centurion 12, the lowest price, a lock with no batteries and a safe assembled in America. We skipped other sizes of the same safes, the same safe sold under a second brand, safes we couldn’t confirm were for sale, cabinets with no fire rating, and two safes whose listings give two different fire figures.
How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 161 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.
We didn’t test these safes ourselves, and we have no tie to Liberty or any maker here. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them; the Centurion facts are Liberty’s and its dealers’. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so. Two of the seven picks have no owner ratings yet, and we say so for each.
SafesGeek Review Team
We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.
Sources: Amazon listings (Nov 2026); Liberty Safe dealer listings for the Centurion (Nov 2026); our guides Best gun safes, Best fireproof gun safes, Best large gun safes and Best American made gun safes.
