10 Best Analog Gun Safes, Scored on Lock, Capacity, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: V-Line Slide-Away. A Simplex push-button drawer for two pistols, in 12-gauge steel.
4.7/5Check price →
02
Best multi-pistol: Viking VS-50SX. Three shelves for handguns and ammo behind a 5 mm steel door.
4.5/5Check price →
03
Best budget long-gun safe: Fortress 14CBF. A combination lock, 14 guns listed and 30 minutes of fire protection.
3.6/5Check price →
04
Best bedside box: Fort Knox PB1. A 3/16-inch wraparound door on a 10-gauge steel box.
4.7/5Check price →
05
Best fire rating: Tracker M12. A UL-listed Group 2 dial and an hour of fire protection.
4.4/5Check price →
06
Most room: Mesa MBF5922C. 14 long guns, a UL-listed Group 2 lock and an anchor kit.
4.4/5Check price →
07
Best security: Sturdy Safe 2424. A 4-gauge steel body and a dial, made in the USA.
4.4/5Check price →
08
Best value: First Alert 5100K. A steel key-lock box with a cable, at the lowest price here.
4.7/5Check price →
09
Best combination box: SnapSafe XL Lock Box. 16-gauge steel and a 3-digit code you set.
4.5/5Check price →
10
Lightest: StopBox Full-Size 2-Pack. Push buttons in polymer, 1.8 pounds a box.
4.4/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 10

Best overall

Lock: Genuine Simplex

Opens: Ball-bearing drawer

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.6
Genuine Simplex push-button, no batteries; owners mostly praise the lock
Capacity
4.6
2 pistols and magazines, pick-and-pluck foam; listed 0.5 cu ft is more than the outside
Security
4.9
12-gauge steel, 22 lb; mounts under a desk or shelf
Value
4.1
Premium price; owners call it worth the money

Here’s the deal: a heavy steel case with a drawer that slides out on ball-bearing rails. It’s 12-gauge steel, 22 pounds, made in the USA and California DOJ approved. A genuine Simplex lock opens it with a code you set, with no batteries and no key to lose. Inside is pick-and-pluck foam, and owners say it holds two semi-auto pistols, spare magazines and a speed loader. It mounts under a desk or a shelf or sits on top of one. Owners mostly praise the quality, the build and the lock, call it easy to use and say it’s worth the money. It’s also the top pick on our best drawer gun safes.

The catch: it’s one of the priciest pistol boxes here. The listing says 0.5 cubic feet, but the outside is 13 × 10 × 4 inches, about 0.3 cubic feet, so the inside is smaller than that; go by the owners’ two pistols. Most owners who mention the lock praise it, but some complain about it. You need 4 inches of height under a desk or shelf, and it has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ 12-gauge steel, 22 lb
✓ Slide-out drawer, 2 pistols
✓ Owners mostly praise the lock

Watch out for

✗ Premium price
✗ Listed size is more than the box
✗ No fire rating

Size

13 × 10 × 4 in

Weight

22 lb

Lock

Simplex push-button

Holds

2 pistols + magazines

Extras

Ball-bearing drawer, made in USA

Skip it if you keep rifles or shotguns: see pick 3.

Learn the lock before the night you need it.

An analog lock has no battery to die, but your hands still have to work it under stress. Owners of several picks here report boxes that wouldn’t open or latch at first. Set your code, then open and close it 20 times with the door or lid open, then try it with the lights off. Write the code down and keep it away from the safe, and keep any key where kids can’t find it. If you’d rather open it with a finger, see our best biometric gun safes.

Pick 2 of 10

Best multi-pistol

Lock: Dormakaba Simplex

Holds: 3 adjustable shelves

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
Dormakaba Simplex push-button, about 1,000 codes; owners split on the lock
Capacity
4.7
3 adjustable shelves: several handguns, ammo and papers
Security
4.6
5 mm door, 40 mm deadbolt, steel lock chamber, 50 lb
Value
4.3
Upper-mid price; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: a front-opening steel safe for a handgun collection. Viking fits an original Dormakaba Simplex push-button lock, with a solid steel chamber around it against forced entry, and lists about 1,000 possible codes. The door is 5 mm thick, the hinges are protected against a sledgehammer, and a 40 mm solid steel deadbolt slides into an anti-pry slot in the frame. It’s 19.7 × 13.8 × 12.2 inches and 50 pounds, with a carpeted inside, three adjustable shelves and an LED light. Owners mostly praise the steel, the weight and the value, and like how fast it opens.

The catch: owners are split on the lock: some say it opens easily, others that it stopped working. Those reviews are shared across Viking’s Simplex safes of every size, so not all of them are about this one. The listing says 3,133 cubic inches, nearly the outside size, so the space inside is less. It’s designed in San Francisco and made in China, the listing doesn’t say how to bolt it down, and it has no fire rating. A smaller Viking is a pick on our best mechanical gun safes.

Why we like it

✓ Room for several handguns
✓ 5 mm door, 40 mm deadbolt
✓ 3 shelves and an LED light

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on the lock
✗ Reviews shared across sizes
✗ Mounting not listed

Size

19.7 × 13.8 × 12.2 in

Weight

50 lb

Lock

Dormakaba Simplex

Holds

Several handguns, 3 shelves

Extras

LED light, carpeted inside

Skip it if you only keep one handgun by the bed: see pick 4.

Pick 3 of 10

Best budget long-gun safe

Lock: Combination, no keypad · Fire: 30 min

1200°F

SafesGeek score
3.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.3
Mechanical combination, the non-keypad version of the 14EBF; little owner feedback
Capacity
4.7
Listed for 14 guns, 55 in tall, convertible interior
Security
4.6
2 mm steel, three 1-in active bolts and 2 dead bolts, 270 lb
Value
4.3
Lowest-priced long-gun safe here; owners split on quality

Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced way here to lock up rifles and shotguns with no electronics. Fortress lists it for 14 guns in a 55 × 20.25 × 19-inch body with a gray convertible interior, and rates it for 30 minutes at 1200°F. Three 1-inch active bolts, two dead bolts and Fortress’s patented notch bolt hold the door, and external hinges let it swing open a full 180 degrees. It weighs 270 pounds. Fortress sells the same 14-gun safe with an electronic lock as the 14EBF; this listing is the combination version, so there’s no keypad battery to die.

The catch: the listing says “combination lock” but never says dial, so check the photos to see what you’re getting. The fire rating is Fortress’s own, with no lab named, and 1200°F is a cooler test than most gun safe ratings. The steel is 2 mm, about 14 gauge. Listed gun counts rarely allow for scopes, so plan on fewer. Only a few dozen owners have rated it, and they’re split on the quality. For more safes with a fire rating, see our best fireproof gun safes.

Why we like it

✓ 14 long guns listed
✓ 30 min at 1200°F
✓ 3 active bolts + 2 dead bolts

Watch out for

✗ Fire lab not named
✗ 2 mm steel
✗ Owners split on quality

Size

55 × 20.25 × 19 in

Weight

270 lb

Lock

Combination

Holds

14 guns (listed)

Extras

Convertible interior, 180° door

Skip it if you want a UL-listed dial: see pick 5.

Pick 4 of 10

Best bedside box

Lock: Simplex push-button

Door: 3/16-in steel, gas strut

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
Simplex push-button, no batteries; owners split on ease of use
Capacity
4.3
1 full-size + 1 small handgun, or spare magazines
Security
4.9
10-gauge steel, 3/16 in door, 22 lb; 4 holes to bolt down; CA DOJ
Value
4.1
Upper-mid price; owners split on value

Here’s the deal: a small pistol box built like a big safe. It’s welded 10-gauge steel with a 3/16-inch door that wraps around the box, a reinforced plate behind the lock and a gas strut that lifts the heavy door for you. The Simplex push-button lock needs no batteries, and a lock reset tool comes in the box. It’s 12.5 × 10.38 × 4.25 inches (5.25 with the buttons and knob) and 22 pounds, with four 3/8-inch holes to bolt it down. It’s made in the USA with a limited lifetime warranty, and the California Department of Justice certifies it. Owners mostly praise the quality, call it built like a tank and say it keeps kids out. It’s also pick 1 on our best small gun safes.

The catch: owners are split on ease of use: some find it simple, others say it wouldn’t open. They’re also split on the value. Bolts aren’t included, so buy 3/8-inch anchors that suit your floor or furniture. It holds a full-size handgun plus a small one or spare magazines, and it has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ 10-gauge steel, 3/16 in door
✓ Gas strut lifts the door
✓ Made in USA, lifetime warranty

Watch out for

✗ Owners split on opening it
✗ Bolts not included
✗ No fire rating

Size

12.5 × 10.38 × 4.25 in

Weight

22 lb

Lock

Simplex push-button

Holds

1 full-size + 1 small handgun

Extras

Gas strut, lock reset tool

Skip it if you need room for several pistols and ammo: see pick 2.

Pick 5 of 10

Best fire rating

Lock: UL Group 2 dial

Fire: 60 min

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
UL-listed Group 2 dial, no batteries; slow to open, no owner reviews yet
Capacity
4.6
Listed for 12 long guns; a narrow 23-inch body
Security
4.6
11-gauge steel, 12 bolts, Group 2 dial; 4 holes, anchors included
Value
4.1
Premium price; no owner reviews yet

Here’s the deal: the old-school long-gun safe. The title says mechanical dial lock, and Tracker’s spec sheet names a UL-listed Group 2 dial, so there are no batteries and no electronics to fail. Tracker lists 60 minutes of fire protection, the longest here. The spec sheet adds 11-gauge (3 mm) steel and twelve 1.25-inch locking bolts, and four pre-drilled holes and concrete anchors come with it. The listing says it holds 12 guns and weighs 550 pounds. It’s also on our best gun safes.

The catch: no owners have reviewed it on Amazon yet, and the listing says very little; most specs here come from Tracker’s spec sheet. The fire figure is Tracker’s own. A dial takes several slow, exact turns, so it’s the slowest lock here to open in a hurry. It’s a narrow safe, so expect fewer than 12 long guns once scopes are on.

Why we like it

✓ UL-listed Group 2 dial
✓ 60 min fire rating
✓ Anchors included

Watch out for

✗ No owner reviews yet
✗ Thin Amazon listing
✗ Slow to open

Size

59 × 23 × 20 in (spec sheet)

Weight

550 lb (listed)

Lock

Group 2 dial

Holds

12 long guns (listed)

Extras

60 min fire, 4 anchors

Skip it if you need the gun in seconds: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 10

Most room

Lock: UL Group 2 combination

Holds: 14 guns, 7.9 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
UL-listed Group 2 combination lock, no batteries; only a few owner ratings
Capacity
4.7
Listed for 14 guns, 7.9 cu ft, 59 in tall
Security
4.6
505 lb, factory drop-tested from 2 stories; anchor kit included; steel gauge not listed
Value
4.0
Premium price; only a few owner ratings

Here’s the deal: an all-steel long-gun safe with a UL-listed Group 2 combination lock, UL’s grade for mechanical combination locks, so there’s nothing to charge. Mesa lists it for 14 guns in 7.9 cubic feet, in a 59 × 22 × 20-inch body that weighs 505 pounds. Mesa says it’s factory tested to survive a two-story drop. Four pre-drilled anchor holes and an anchor kit come with it, so you can bolt it to the floor the day it arrives.

The catch: only a handful of owners have rated it, the listing says little about the steel, and it lists no fire rating. A combination lock is slower to open than push-buttons. It’s one of the priciest picks, and listed gun counts rarely allow for scopes.

Why we like it

✓ 14 guns, 7.9 cu ft
✓ UL-listed Group 2 lock
✓ Anchor kit included

Watch out for

✗ Few owner ratings
✗ No fire rating listed
✗ Steel gauge not listed

Size

59 × 22 × 20 in

Weight

505 lb

Lock

Group 2 combination

Holds

14 guns (listed)

Extras

Anchor kit, 4 holes

Skip it if you want a fire rating: see pick 5.

Pick 7 of 10

Best security

Lock: S&G Group II dial

Steel: 4-gauge body, 3/8-in door

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
S&G Group II mechanical dial, no batteries; no owner reviews yet
Capacity
4.4
19 × 13 × 19 in inside: up to 10 pistols, adjustable shelves
Security
5.0
4-gauge steel body, 3/8-in steel door; pre-drilled anchor holes
Value
3.8
Most expensive pick; no owner reviews yet

Here’s the deal: the heaviest steel on this page. Sturdy builds it in the USA with a 4-gauge steel body and a 3/8-inch steel door, and an S&G Group II mechanical dial opens it with no batteries. It’s 24 × 19 × 24 inches outside and 19 × 13 × 19 inches inside, with adjustable shelves for up to 10 pistols, ammo and papers. It’s lined with ceramic fire protection and glass blanket insulation, and it has pre-drilled anchor holes and a hole for running power to accessories inside. For more safes built in the USA, see our best American made gun safes.

The catch: it’s the most expensive pick by far, and no owners have reviewed it on Amazon yet. The listing doesn’t give a weight or a fire rating, only the lining. A dial is slow to open in a hurry. It comes curbside, so plan how you’ll move it inside.

Why we like it

✓ 4-gauge body, 3/8 in door
✓ Up to 10 pistols
✓ Made in USA

Watch out for

✗ Most expensive pick
✗ No owner reviews yet
✗ Weight not listed

Size

24 × 19 × 24 in

Weight

Not listed

Lock

S&G Group II dial

Holds

Up to 10 pistols

Extras

Adjustable shelves, fire lining

Skip it if you want owner feedback before you spend this much: see pick 1.

Pick 8 of 10

Best value

Lock: Key

Steel: 18 gauge, 3 lb

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.3
Key lock, no batteries; owners split on ease of use
Capacity
4.0
One handgun and spare magazines; 9.5 × 7 × 2.25 in outside
Security
4.3
18-gauge steel, 3 lb; steel cable included, no mounting
Value
4.7
Lowest-priced pick; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: the simplest analog lock there is, at the lowest price here. It’s an 18-gauge steel box, 9.5 × 7 × 2.25 inches and 3 pounds, opened with a key, and a steel cable comes with it to lock it to a car seat or a fixture. First Alert says it meets TSA airline rules for a handgun in checked bags. Owners mostly call it secure and well padded, one fits a S&W Shield and three magazines, and owners rate the value. For more boxes made for the road, see our best gun lock boxes.

The catch: a key is only as safe as where you hide it, and it’s slow to find in the dark. Owners are split on ease of use and on the size: some say it’s small. At 3 pounds on a cable, it keeps kids and quick hands out, not a thief with tools. It doesn’t mount, and it has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ Lowest price here
✓ Steel cable included
✓ Meets TSA rules for checked bags

Watch out for

✗ A key can be found
✗ One handgun
✗ Doesn’t mount

Size

9.5 × 7 × 2.25 in

Weight

3 lb

Lock

Key

Holds

1 handgun + magazines

Extras

Steel cable, foam lined

Skip it if the gun stays by the bed: see pick 4.

Pick 9 of 10

Best combination box

Lock: 3-digit combination

Steel: 16 gauge, 1,500-lb cable

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
3.8
3-digit combination you set; owners mostly complain about the lock
Capacity
4.1
A 1911-size pistol or a 4-in revolver, plus magazines
Security
4.4
16-gauge steel, 1,500-lb cable; CA DOJ, TSA
Value
4.6
Low price; owners mostly rate the value

Here’s the deal: a budget steel lock box with no key and no batteries. You set your own 3-digit code. The housing is 16-gauge steel, 10 × 7 × 2 inches, and a 1,500-pound cable locks it to a car seat or a bed frame. The California Department of Justice approves it as a firearm safety device, and SnapSafe says it meets TSA rules. Owners mostly praise the value, the size and the steel, and fit a full-size 1911 with two magazines. For more boxes for the car, see our best car gun safes.

The catch: owners mostly complain about the combination lock: it’s fiddly to set and can be hard to open. Work it many times before you trust it. A 3-digit code has far fewer combinations than a Simplex lock, and a cable can be cut. It has no fire rating.

Why we like it

✓ 16-gauge steel
✓ 1,500-lb cable included
✓ CA DOJ approved

Watch out for

✗ Owners mostly fault the lock
✗ Only a 3-digit code
✗ Cable can be cut

Size

10 × 7 × 2 in

Weight

3.5 lb

Lock

3-digit combination

Holds

1911-size pistol or 4 in revolver

Extras

1,500-lb cable, foam lined

Skip it if you want a lock owners trust: see pick 1.

Pick 10 of 10

Lightest

Lock: 81-code push-button

Body: Polymer, 2-pack

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.3
Mechanical push buttons, 81 codes you set; owners split on opening it
Capacity
4.0
One full-size handgun per box, 9.25 × 7.15 × 1.75 in inside
Security
4.0
Reinforced polymer; cable or padlock not included
Value
4.3
Two boxes in one listing; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: the mechanical lock box many gun owners search for by name, and the lightest pick at 1.8 pounds. You press mechanical buttons in your own combination, chosen from 81, so there are no batteries, electronics or keys to fail. It’s 11.5 × 8.5 × 2.25 inches in glass-reinforced polymer, with 9.25 × 7.15 × 1.75 inches inside plus a small compartment. StopBox says it’s TSA compliant and takes a padlock or cable (not included). This listing is a 2-pack of full-size boxes. Owners like it most for keeping guns away from kids while still getting in fast.

The catch: it’s polymer, not steel, so it’s a child lock rather than a safe. Owners are split on ease of use: some say it’s hard to open or won’t close until you practice. 81 combinations is far fewer than a Simplex lock’s thousand or so, and StopBox says it isn’t made for wall mounting.

Why we like it

✓ No batteries or keys
✓ TSA compliant, 1.8 lb
✓ Two boxes in one listing

Watch out for

✗ Polymer, not steel
✗ Owners split on opening it
✗ Only 81 codes

Size

11.5 × 8.5 × 2.25 in

Weight

1.8 lb

Lock

81-code push-button

Holds

1 full-size handgun

Extras

2-pack, TSA compliant

Skip it if you want steel at home: see pick 4.

PickLockOpensSizeWeightHoldsExtrasDoor
V-Line Slide-Away
Best overall
4.7/5
Check price
Genuine SimplexBall-bearing drawer13 × 10 × 4 in22 lb2 pistols + magazinesBall-bearing drawer, made in USA–
Viking VS-50SX
Best multi-pistol
4.5/5
Check price
Dormakaba Simplex–19.7 × 13.8 × 12.2 in50 lb3 adjustable shelvesLED light, carpeted inside–
Fortress 14CBF
Best budget long-gun safe
3.6/5
Check price
Combination, no keypad · Fire: 30 min–55 × 20.25 × 19 in270 lb14 guns (listed)Convertible interior, 180° door–
Fort Knox PB1
Best bedside box
4.7/5
Check price
Simplex push-button–12.5 × 10.38 × 4.25 in22 lb1 full-size + 1 small handgunGas strut, lock reset tool3/16-in steel, gas strut
Tracker M12
Best fire rating
4.4/5
Check price
UL Group 2 dial–59 × 23 × 20 in (spec sheet)550 lb (listed)12 long guns (listed)60 min fire, 4 anchors–
Mesa MBF5922C
Most room
4.4/5
Check price
UL Group 2 combination–59 × 22 × 20 in505 lb14 guns, 7.9 cu ftAnchor kit, 4 holes–
Sturdy Safe 2424
Best security
4.4/5
Check price
S&G Group II dial–24 × 19 × 24 inNot listedUp to 10 pistolsAdjustable shelves, fire lining–
First Alert 5100K
Best value
4.7/5
Check price
Key–9.5 × 7 × 2.25 in3 lb1 handgun + magazinesSteel cable, foam lined–
SnapSafe XL Lock Box
Best combination box
4.5/5
Check price
3-digit combination–10 × 7 × 2 in3.5 lb1911-size pistol or 4 in revolver1,500-lb cable, foam lined–
StopBox Full-Size 2-Pack
Lightest
4.4/5
Check price
81-code push-button–11.5 × 8.5 × 2.25 in1.8 lb1 full-size handgun2-pack, TSA compliant–

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

An analog gun safe has one job: open for you every time, with no batteries, and stay shut for kids and thieves. Four questions decide which one.

A push-button lock like the Simplex on picks 1, 2 and 4 opens with a code you set, pressed by feel in a few seconds. A dial like the UL-listed Group 2 locks on picks 5 to 7 takes several slow turns, but it’s the lock on most full-size safes. A key, like pick 8’s, is quickest of all if it’s on you, and useless if it’s lost. Cheaper boxes use simpler codes: pick 9 has 3 digits and pick 10 has 81 combinations. For more pistol safes with a genuine Simplex lock, see our best handgun safes with simplex lock.

For a gun by the bed, speed beats everything. Push-buttons win here, and owners of pick 1 mostly praise its lock. A dial is fine for long guns you take out for the range, not for a bump in the night. If you want a lock that opens with a touch, see our best biometric gun safes.

Picks 4 and 8 to 10 hold one handgun, or one plus a small one; pick 1 holds two; picks 2 and 7 hold several on shelves; picks 3, 5 and 6 are long-gun safes listed for 12 to 14 guns. Listed counts rarely allow for scopes, lights or holsters, so plan on fewer. For a safe that holds a whole collection, see our best gun safes.

Bolt it down. Picks 5 and 6 come with anchors, pick 4 has four 3/8-inch holes, pick 7 has pre-drilled anchor holes and pick 1 mounts under a desk or shelf. Picks 8 and 9 come with a steel cable; pick 10 takes a cable or padlock, sold separately.

One last tip: write your code down and keep it somewhere other than the safe, and keep the key off your key ring.

Still not sure? Get the V-Line Slide-Away.
12-gauge steel, a drawer for two pistols and a lock that never needs a battery.
Check price on Amazon →
What is an analog gun safe?

A gun safe whose lock works with no power at all: push-buttons like the Simplex, a dial or a key. Some people call it a mechanical or non-electronic gun safe; we also cover those on our best mechanical gun safes.

Is an analog gun safe more reliable than a digital one?

There’s no battery, circuit board or fingerprint reader to fail, so an analog lock keeps working with no upkeep. It can still stick: owners of some picks report boxes that wouldn’t open at first, so test yours before you load it.

Are dial gun safes slow to open?

Yes. A dial takes several exact turns each way, which is hard under stress or in the dark. That’s why most people keep a long-gun safe with a dial and a push-button box for the bedside handgun.

What if I forget the code or lose the key?

Write the code down and keep it away from the safe, and keep a spare key somewhere only you know. If you’re locked out, contact the maker with your proof of purchase.

Are analog gun safes fireproof?

Only picks 3 and 5 list a fire rating: 30 minutes at 1200°F and 60 minutes, both the makers’ own figures. Pick 7 has a fire lining but no rating. For gun safes picked for fire, see our best fireproof gun safes.

Do analog gun safes need any upkeep?

No batteries to change. Work the lock now and then so the code stays in your fingers, and keep the key where you can reach it in the dark.

Find your fit

An analog gun safe opens with push-buttons, a dial or a key, with no batteries to fail. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A lock with no batteries
→ Analog gun safes (you're here)
Push-button, dial and key safes that open the same way every time.
If you want
A genuine Simplex lock
→ Handgun safes with Simplex lock
Pistol safes with a five-button Simplex lock you open by feel, most in thick steel.
If you want
Speed in the dark
→ Biometric gun safes
A fingerprint opens it with no code to remember.
If you want
Room for more guns
→ Gun safes
Our picks hold 13 to 63 guns with 30 to 60 minutes of fire protection.

How to choose an analog gun safe →

We looked at 127 products that came up on Amazon in searches for “analog gun safe”: the plain search, which is mostly fingerprint and keypad safes, and five filtered searches for push-button, knob, key and combination locks and a higher price band. We added 186 more push-button, dial, combination and key gun safes from our earlier research, for 313 listings, and kept the gun safes that open with no electronics. Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews: the lock and how reliably it opens, how many guns fit, how secure it feels and value. Those became our four scores.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 313 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. When a safe is also on another of our pages, it keeps the same security and value scores there and here. We kept one pick per brand, left out near-copies of the same safe (another size, or the same box under another name), and skipped listings you can’t buy right now.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so, and where few owners have rated a safe, we say that too.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.