7 Best Combination Safes, Scored on Lock, Protection, Security and Value

The short version

01
Best overall: SentrySafe SFW123DSB. A UL fire rating, a water rating and the most owners of any dial safe.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Best value: First Alert 2087F. A dial and a key, UL-rated for an hour, at a low price.
4.4/5Check price →
03
Widest inside: Hollon HS-360D. 121 lb of seamless steel, 15 inches wide inside.
4.5/5Check price →
04
Best dual lock: Phoenix Olympian 1223. A dial and a key, both needed, plus a 30-foot drop test.
4.4/5Check price →
05
Best lock: Stealth B1500D Floor Safe. A UL-listed S&G dial with a relocker, set in the floor.
4.4/5Check price →
06
Best wall safe: V-Line Quick Vault. A push-button lock between the studs, with no batteries.
4.5/5Check price →
07
Best under-desk: V-Line Desk Mate. Push-button access to a box under a desk or shelf.
4.5/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 7

Best overall

Lock: Dial, no batteries · Fire: UL 1 hr

1700°F

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.3
Dial combination, no batteries; owners mostly find the dial hard to open
Protection
4.9
UL 1 hr at 1700°F; ETL 15-ft fall and 24 hr in water
Security
4.6
Four live-locking bolts, 86 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.7
Low-priced for a UL-rated safe; owners mostly call it good value

Here’s the deal: the dial safe most people end up with, and the first result when you search for one. SentrySafe has it UL Classified for 1 hour at 1700°F and ETL Verified for 24 hours in 8 inches of water and for a 15-foot fall during a fire. Inside it’s 12.6 × 11.9 × 13.8 inches, 1.23 cubic feet, with a shelf, so letter papers lie flat. Four live-locking bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware hold the door, and it weighs 86 pounds. If fire or water ever damages it, SentrySafe replaces the safe. Owners mostly praise the value, the security and the size.

The catch: the dial is this safe’s sore spot. Owners complain about ease of use more than they praise it, and many say the door is hard to open. Owners are split on the build, mostly because the handle and the dial are plastic. The title says dial; the spec table says electronic combination lock. SentrySafe sets the combination at the factory (see the box below).

Why we like it

✓ UL 1 hr fire, ETL 24 hr water
✓ Letter papers lie flat
✓ Most owners of any dial safe

Watch out for

✗ Owners say the dial is hard to open
✗ Plastic handle and dial
✗ Combination set at the factory

Size

16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in

Weight

86 lb

Lock

Dial combination

Fire

UL 1 hr at 1700°F

Extras

Shelf, bolt-down kit, ETL water

Skip it if you want two hours of fire protection: see pick 3.

The combination is set at the factory.

SentrySafe’s dial safes come with a preset combination: the listings for this model and its bigger sibling say so, and you can’t pick your own numbers. Write it down and keep it, with any key, somewhere other than the safe. For a code you set yourself with no batteries, see the push-button picks 6 and 7; if batteries don’t bother you, see our best digital safes.

Pick 2 of 7

Best value

Fire: UL 1 hr · 1700°F

Water: Sealed

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.1
Combination dial plus a key; owners more negative than positive on the lock
Protection
4.6
UL 1 hr at 1700°F; waterproof, hours not stated
Security
4.4
78 lb, bolt-down kit, combination plus key; owners split on the lock
Value
4.7
Low price for a UL-rated safe; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: a combination safe with a UL fire rating on the listing: UL Classified for an hour at 1700°F with the inside kept under 350°F. Its Ready-Seal door keeps water out when it’s submerged, and First Alert says the seal still works when you bolt the safe down, which not every fire safe can claim. Letter papers lie flat on the floor of the safe, an adjustable shelf splits the space, and pry-resistant concealed hinges guard the door. Owners mostly say it works well, is solidly built and is good value.

The catch: it’s small, with no room for binders. Owners are more negative than positive on the lock, and some say it arrived damaged. It doesn’t say how long it stays dry. Only protecting a few documents? A fire chest costs less: see our best fireproof document safes.

Why we like it

✓ UL Classified: 1 hr at 1700°F
✓ Seal holds when bolted down
✓ Low price for a UL rating

Watch out for

✗ Lock complaints from some owners
✗ Water hours not stated
✗ No room for binders

Size

16.5 × 14.5 × 19 in

Weight

78 lb

Lock

Combination dial + key

Fire

UL 1 hr at 1700°F

Extras

Shelf, bolt-down kit, water seal

Skip it if you want room for binders: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 7

Widest inside

Lock: Dial, no batteries

Inside: 15 × 12 × 9.3 in

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.4
Dial lock, no batteries; nothing else listed, few owner reviews
Protection
4.7
2 hr at 1850°F, Hollon’s own rating, no lab named
Security
4.6
121 lb seamless steel, dial lock; one anchor hole, bolts included
Value
4.1
Upper-priced; few owner reviews

Here’s the deal: a low, wide steel safe with the widest inside on this page. It’s 121 pounds with a seamless body and door, and Hollon rates it for 2 hours at 1850°F. Inside it’s 15 inches wide, 12 deep and 9.3 tall, about 1 cubic foot, so files and a laptop lie flat. The dial never needs batteries, and bolts come in the box for its anchor hole. The owners who have rated it call it beefy and well built.

The catch: the fire rating is Hollon’s own, and the listing doesn’t name a testing lab. It has no water rating and only one anchoring hole, and only a handful of owners have rated it so far. At 121 pounds, plan the delivery.

Why we like it

✓ 2 hr at 1850°F (maker’s rating)
✓ Widest inside, 15 in
✓ 121 lb seamless steel

Watch out for

✗ No testing lab named
✗ No water rating
✗ Few owner reviews so far

Size

19.25 × 16.75 × 13.75 in

Weight

121 lb

Lock

Dial

Fire

2 hr at 1850°F (maker)

Extras

Inside 15 × 12 × 9.3 in, bolts

Skip it if you want a UL label on the fire rating: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 7

Best dual lock

Lock: Dial + key, both needed · Fire: 1 hr

30-ft drop test

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.6
Dual control: dial and key together, or key only; no batteries
Protection
4.6
1 hr for papers, 30-ft drop test; lab not named, water resistant only
Security
4.6
117 lb, steel bolt work into steel, bolt-down kit
Value
4.0
Priciest fire pick; almost no owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the one safe here that can ask for two things to open. In dual control, you dial the combination and turn the key; for everyday use, you can leave the dial set and use just the key. Phoenix rates it for 1 hour at 1700°F for papers and 30 minutes for USB drives and discs, explosion-tests it at 2000°F, and drops it 30 feet onto rubble before reheating it. Inside it’s 16.25 × 11.75 × 11.75 inches, 1.3 cubic feet, with a shelf and a drawer. All the bolt work is steel locking into steel, so the door holds even if the hinges come off, and a bolt-down kit is included. Phoenix replaces it free if it’s ever in a fire, and the safe and lock have a 3-year warranty.

The catch: the listing doesn’t name the lab behind its fire rating. It’s water resistant against hoses and sprinklers, not rated for a flood. It’s the priciest fire-rated pick, and almost no owners have rated it yet.

Why we like it

✓ Dial and key: two-step entry
✓ 30-ft drop test after fire
✓ Shelf and drawer, 1.3 cu ft

Watch out for

✗ Lab not named
✗ Water resistant, not waterproof
✗ Almost no owner feedback

Size

15.88 × 17.38 × 20.5 in

Weight

117 lb

Lock

Dial + key (dual control)

Fire

1 hr at 1700°F (maker)

Extras

Shelf, drawer, bolt-down kit

Skip it if you want a UL rating and a flood rating: see pick 1.

Pick 5 of 7

Best lock

Lock: UL-listed S&G dial

Door: ½-inch steel plate

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.9
UL-listed S&G mechanical dial, hardplate and relocker
Protection
3.7
No fire rating
Security
4.9
½-in steel door, three 1-in bolts, set in a concrete floor
Value
4.0
One of the two priciest picks; almost no owner feedback

Here’s the deal: the strongest lock and the most steel on this page, built to sit in a concrete floor with only the door showing. The lock is a UL-listed Sargent & Greenleaf mechanical dial, protected by a hardplate and a relocker that locks the bolts in place if the lock is attacked. The door is a ½-inch solid steel plate with three 1-inch bolts and an internal steel dead bar, on a 12-gauge body, and a piston helps the door open. It’s 14.5 × 12.5 × 12.4 inches and 73 pounds, made in the USA. For more safes set in the floor, see our best floor safes.

The catch: it has no fire rating, and it has to be set into concrete or built in to do its job. The listing doesn’t give the inside size, only a handful of owners have rated it, and it’s one of the two priciest picks.

Why we like it

✓ UL-listed S&G dial with relocker
✓ ½-in steel door, 3 bolts
✓ Hidden in the floor

Watch out for

✗ No fire rating
✗ Needs a concrete install
✗ Inside size not listed

Size

14.5 × 12.5 × 12.4 in

Weight

73 lb

Lock

UL-listed S&G dial

Fire

None

Extras

Relocker, piston door, dead bar

Skip it if fire is your worry: see pick 1.

Pick 6 of 7

Best wall safe

Lock: Simplex 5-button

Fits: Between wall studs

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.7
Simplex 5-button lock, a code you set, no batteries; owners mostly find it easy
Protection
3.7
No fire rating
Security
4.3
Steel clamshell, 3/8-in lock block, welded hinge; mounts between studs
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners rate the value

Here’s the deal: a push-button safe that hides in the wall. It mounts flush between the studs with a bezel, so a picture can hang over it, and it’s 3.5 inches deep. The Simplex lock has five mechanical buttons and 1,081 possible codes; you set your own, and there are no batteries and no keys. The body is fabricated steel in a pry-resistant clamshell, with a 3/8-inch steel lock block and a hinge welded on one end, and a felt-lined adjustable shelf inside. It’s made in the USA. Owners mostly praise how easy it is to install and use, the build and having no batteries to worry about. For more safes that hide in a wall, see our best wall safes.

The catch: it has no fire rating, and at 23 pounds it’s only as strong as the wall around it; one owner says it stops small children and casual burglars. It holds about 0.35 cubic feet, a shallow space for cash, papers and small valuables.

Why we like it

✓ A code you set, no batteries
✓ Hides behind a picture
✓ Owners call it easy to install

Watch out for

✗ No fire rating
✗ Only as strong as the wall
✗ Shallow, 0.35 cu ft

Size

17 × 15 × 3.5 in

Weight

23 lb

Lock

Simplex 5-button

Fire

None

Extras

Felt-lined shelf, bezel

Skip it if you can’t cut into a wall: see pick 7.

Pick 7 of 7

Best under-desk

Lock: Simplex 5-button

Mount: Under a desk or shelf

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Lock
4.6
Simplex 5-button, no batteries; owners mostly like it, some say it doesn’t always latch
Protection
3.7
No fire rating
Security
4.1
Steel box on anti-pry brackets; quick-release bracket, steel thickness not listed
Value
4.4
Mid-priced; owners praise the quality

Here’s the deal: push-button access to a small box mounted under a desk, a shelf or a nightstand. The same five-button Simplex lock as pick 6 opens it with no batteries; one owner says it takes a couple of quick presses. It mounts on anti-pry brackets with a quick-release bracket, and the inside is felt-lined, with a felt tray for small items. It’s 11.75 × 7.5 × 4 inches and made in the USA. Owners mostly praise the quality, the solid feel, how easy it is to use and that it never needs batteries.

The catch: it’s a small box, not a safe you’d bolt into a floor. It has no fire rating, and the listing gives no steel thickness. Its listed capacity, 352.5 cubic inches, is the same as its outside size, so the real space inside is smaller, and the 2.3 lb in the specs looks low for a steel box. Some owners report it not locking properly, so test it before you load it. Amazon lists it as a pistol safe; for a handgun, see our best handgun safes.

Why we like it

✓ No batteries, quick to open
✓ Hidden under a desk
✓ Owners praise the build

Watch out for

✗ No fire rating
✗ Small inside
✗ Doesn’t always latch, some say

Size

11.75 × 7.5 × 4 in

Weight

Not clear (listed 2.3 lb)

Lock

Simplex 5-button

Fire

None

Extras

Felt tray, anti-pry brackets

Skip it if you need room for papers: see pick 1.

PickLockSizeWeightFireExtrasWaterInside
SentrySafe SFW123DSB
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
Dial, no batteries · Fire: UL 1 hr16.3 × 19.3 × 17.8 in86 lbUL 1 hr at 1700°FShelf, bolt-down kit, ETL water––
First Alert 2087F
Best value
4.4/5
Check price
Combination dial + key16.5 × 14.5 × 19 in78 lbUL 1 hr · 1700°FShelf, bolt-down kit, water sealSealed–
Hollon HS-360D
Widest inside
4.5/5
Check price
Dial, no batteries19.25 × 16.75 × 13.75 in121 lb2 hr at 1850°F (maker)Inside 15 × 12 × 9.3 in, bolts–15 × 12 × 9.3 in
Phoenix Olympian 1223
Best dual lock
4.4/5
Check price
Dial + key, both needed · Fire: 1 hr15.88 × 17.38 × 20.5 in117 lb1 hr at 1700°F (maker)Shelf, drawer, bolt-down kit––
Stealth B1500D Floor Safe
Best lock
4.4/5
Check price
UL-listed S&G dial14.5 × 12.5 × 12.4 in73 lbNoneRelocker, piston door, dead bar––
V-Line Quick Vault
Best wall safe
4.5/5
Check price
Simplex 5-button17 × 15 × 3.5 in23 lbNoneFelt-lined shelf, bezel––
V-Line Desk Mate
Best under-desk
4.5/5
Check price
Simplex 5-button11.75 × 7.5 × 4 inNot clear (listed 2.3 lb)NoneFelt tray, anti-pry brackets––

A combination safe has one job: open for you years from now, with no batteries and no power, and stay shut for everyone else. Four questions decide which one.

A dial is the classic: no batteries, but it takes several careful turns each way, and owners of dial safes complain about ease of use more than anything else. A Simplex push-button lock, like picks 6 and 7, opens in a few presses, takes a code you set and still needs no batteries. If you’ll open the safe every day, push-button is easier; for papers you open a few times a year, a dial is fine.

Not on every safe. SentrySafe’s dial safes come with a combination set at the factory, while push-button locks take a code you set. Wherever you keep the combination and any backup key, keep them outside the safe.

No pick does it all. Picks 1 to 4 carry a fire rating, but most of their weight is fire insulation, not armor steel. Pick 5 has the strongest lock and a ½-inch steel door, but no fire rating, and it has to be set in concrete. Picks 6 and 7 hide in a wall or under a desk. For papers, a fire rating matters most; see our best fireproof safes. For cash and jewelry, theft matters more; see our best money safes or our best jewelry safes.

Bolt it down. Most fire-rated picks come with bolt-down hardware, pick 5 sits in a concrete floor, and picks 6 and 7 mount into a wall or under a desk. A fire safe that isn’t bolted down can be carried out. For smaller boxes you can hide, see our best drawer safes.

One last tip: practice the dial a few times with the door open before you lock anything inside.

Still not sure? Get the SentrySafe SFW123DSB.
A UL fire rating, a water rating and a dial that never needs batteries.
Check price on Amazon →
What is a combination safe?

A safe that opens with a combination instead of a key or a fingerprint. On this page that means a mechanical lock, a dial or push-buttons, with no batteries. Many keypad safes are also sold as combination safes; those are on our best digital safes.

Are dial safes more reliable than digital safes?

There’s no battery or circuit board to fail, so a dial keeps working with no upkeep. The trade-off is speed: a dial is slower, and owners find it harder to open. A keypad opens in a second but needs batteries and backup keys.

Can I change the combination on a dial safe?

On SentrySafe’s dial safes, no: the combination is set at the factory. The push-button Simplex locks on picks 6 and 7 take a code you set.

Are combination safes fireproof?

Picks 1 to 4 carry a fire rating; picks 5 to 7 don’t. For safes rated for fire and flood, see our best fireproof waterproof safes.

What if I forget the combination?

Picks 2 and 4 come with a key. Otherwise, it’s a locksmith or the maker, so write the combination down and keep it outside the safe.

Can I keep a handgun in a combination safe?

You can, but quick access matters for a gun; see our best handgun safes. Owners use the push-button picks 6 and 7 for handguns too.

Find your fit

A combination safe opens with a dial or code you know, with no batteries to fail. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
A lock you open with a combination
→ Combination safes (you're here)
Dial and code safes for cash, papers and valuables.
If you want
A keypad for speed
→ Digital safes
A keypad with backup keys for when the batteries run out.
If you want
Just a key
→ Fire chests
A key opens it in a second, and our picks carry a fire rating.

How to choose a combination safe →

We looked at 336 products that came up on Amazon in searches for “combination safe”, “dial safe” and “mechanical safe”, and kept the safes that open with a mechanical lock, a dial or push-buttons, with no electronics. Then we counted what owners talk about most in their reviews: the lock and how easy it is to open, fire protection, how secure it feels and value. Those became our four scores.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 336 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. We only picked safes we could score on all four, we left out near-copies of the same safe, and we skipped listings you can’t buy right now.

We didn’t test these products ourselves. Sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so, and where few owners have rated a safe, we say that too.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.