9 Best Fireproof Gun Safes (and Who Tested the Fire Rating)

The short version

01
Best overall: Kodiak KBX5940. 40 minutes at 1400°F, room for 25–40 rifles.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Best value for long guns: XPEDITION 24-gun. 45 minutes at 1400°F, outlet inside.
4.6/5Check price →
03
Best with a burglary rating: Stealth UL23. UL burglary rating plus 1 hour of fire.
4.3/5Check price →
04
Best 14-gun fireproof safe: Fortress 14CBF. 30 minutes at 1200°F, five bolts.
3.5/5Check price →
05
Best fireproof pistol safe: XPEDITION 2.5 cu ft. Fire and water claims in one.
4.7/5Check price →
06
Best for long fires: Hollon RG-39. 2 hours at 1400°F, 10-gauge steel.
4.5/5Check price →
07
Best mid-size safe: TIGERKING GS5926. 12-gauge steel, real inside size listed.
4.4/5Check price →
08
Best waterproof: Sports Afield Haven 5925HX. 75 minutes at 1400°F, 7 days in water.
4.4/5Check price →
09
Lowest-priced long-gun pick: SureLock 24-gun. 30 minutes at 1400°F, 26 inches wide.
4.4/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 9

Best overall

Fire: 40 min at 1400°F

Holds: 25–40 rifles

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
40 min at 1400°F, maker’s test; door seal swells in heat
Capacity
4.9
Listed for 57; owners say 25–40 fit; USB inside
Security
4.4
14-gauge steel, 457 lb, UL-listed lock, relocker; pre-drilled to bolt down
Value
4.3
One of the priciest picks; very few owner reviews

Here’s the deal: a big gun safe for a big collection. It’s 59 × 40 × 23 inches and 457 pounds of 14-gauge steel, with a hardened armor plate and a spring-loaded relocker that protect the lock from drilling. Kodiak gives it 40 minutes of fire protection at 1400°F, with fire board and a door seal that expands in heat to block smoke. It has a UL-listed electronic lock, adjustable shelves, USB outlets inside and a door organizer with handgun holders. External hinges let the door open 180°. It’s certified by the California DOJ and has holes to bolt it to the floor. Owners praise its build and Rhino Metals’ customer support.

The catch: the fire rating is Kodiak’s own; the listing doesn’t name a lab. It’s sold for 57 long guns, but owners say 25–40 rifles fit once scopes are on. It’s one of the priciest picks and has very few ratings on Amazon. It ships by freight on a pallet, so someone has to be home, and you need a dolly and a plan to move it. Kodiak’s smaller KBX safes are on our best gun safes page.

Why we like it

✓ Room for 25–40 rifles
✓ UL-listed lock, relocker
✓ USB outlets inside

Watch out for

✗ Fire test lab not named
✗ Very few owner ratings
✗ Freight delivery, 457 lb

Size

59 × 40 × 23 in

Lock

UL-listed electronic

Inside

About 23 in deep

Holds

25–40 rifles, owners say

Build

14-gauge steel, 457 lb, CA DOJ certified

Skip it if you have fewer than 20 long guns: see pick 2.

Ask who tested the fire rating.

Most fire ratings on gun safes come from the maker’s own test, and the listings rarely name a lab. A rating with a time and a temperature (40 minutes at 1400°F) tells you more than “fireproof” on the box. A fire bag inside a steel cabinet isn’t a fire rating at all. And divide the gun count by two: owners of the long-gun safes here fit about half the number on the label.

Pick 2 of 9

Best value for long guns

Fire: 45 min at 1400°F

Holds: 12–16 guns

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
45 min at 1400°F and water-resistant, maker’s claims
Capacity
4.4
Listed for 24; owners say 12–16; outlet inside
Security
4.3
Steel, 326 lb, keypad and keys; steel gauge not listed
Value
4.4
Mid-priced for its size; little owner feedback

Here’s the deal: a full-size fire-rated gun safe that arrives assembled. It’s 55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 inches and 326 pounds of reinforced steel. XPEDITION says it protects contents for 45 minutes at 1400°F and is water-resistant. It opens with a keypad or backup keys. The keypad sounds an alarm after 3 wrong tries, and the safe has a vibration alarm and a silent mode. A power outlet inside lets you charge devices or run a dehumidifier: see our best gun safe dehumidifiers. Adjustable racks, pouches and dividers organize rifles, pistols and ammo. Owners rate it highly.

The catch: the fire rating is XPEDITION’s own. The listing doesn’t say who tested it, and it isn’t UL listed. It’s sold as a 24-gun safe, but owners say 12–16 is realistic once scopes are on. The listing gives an inside depth of 21 inches, more than its 20.7-inch outside depth, so measure your longest scoped rifle first. The same safe is sold as the VALINIRT 24-gun, and the owner feedback is shared across XPEDITION’s safes, so there’s little on this one. At 326 pounds, it arrives by freight.

Why we like it

✓ 45-minute fire claim, water-resistant
✓ Power outlet inside
✓ Arrives assembled

Watch out for

✗ Fire test lab not named
✗ 12–16 guns, not 24, owners say
✗ Inside depth listed wrong

Size

55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 in

Lock

Keypad, backup keys

Inside

Under 15.7 cu ft (listed)

Holds

12–16 guns, owners say

Build

Steel, 326 lb, outlet inside

Skip it if you want a burglary rating from an independent lab: see pick 3.

Pick 3 of 9

Best with a burglary rating

Fire: 1 hour

Holds: 8–15 long guns

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
1 hour, Stealth’s figure; temperature not listed
Capacity
4.4
Listed for 23; owners say 8–15; about 12 in deep
Security
4.7
UL RSC burglary rating, UL Type 1 lock, 450 lb, CA DOJ
Value
4.0
Pricey; few owner ratings

Here’s the deal: the only pick with a burglary rating from an independent lab. UL rates it as a Residential Security Container (UL RSC), which means it held off an attack with hand tools for 5 minutes. Stealth also gives it 1 hour of fire protection. It’s 59 × 24 × 18 inches and 450 pounds, with a UL Type 1 high-security electronic lock. It’s approved by the California DOJ as a firearm safety device. Inside are shelves and a MOLLE door panel (a webbing grid for attaching pouches and holsters) for handguns and gear.

The catch: the fire rating is Stealth’s own, and the listing gives a time but no temperature. It’s sold as a 23-gun safe, but owners say 8–15 long guns is realistic. One owner fit only 3 scoped AR-style rifles, and the inside is about 12 inches deep. It ships on a pallet and is usually left at the curb or in the driveway, on 4 temporary shipping legs. Plan for an appliance dolly and 2–3 people, and bolt it down once it’s in place, because it’s top-heavy. One owner’s safe arrived damaged; they say Stealth’s warranty help was good.

Why we like it

✓ UL RSC burglary rating
✓ 1 hour of fire protection
✓ CA DOJ approved

Watch out for

✗ 8–15 long guns, not 23
✗ Curbside delivery
✗ About 12 in deep inside

Size

59 × 24 × 18 in

Lock

UL Type 1 high-security electronic

Inside

About 12 in deep

Holds

8–15 long guns, owners say

Build

450 lb, UL RSC, CA DOJ approved

Skip it if you can’t get 450 pounds into your home: see pick 4.

Pick 4 of 9

Best 14-gun fireproof safe

Fire: 30 min at 1200°F

Holds: 14 guns, listed

SafesGeek score
3.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
30 min at 1200°F, maker’s rating; a cooler test than most
Capacity
4.3
Listed for 14 in a 20-inch body; convertible interior
Security
4.6
2 mm steel, three 1-in active bolts and 2 dead bolts, 270 lb
Value
4.3
Pricier than pick 2; owners split on quality

Here’s the deal: a mid-size fire safe for up to 14 long guns. It’s 55 × 20.25 × 19 inches and 270 pounds, built from 2 mm steel (about 14 gauge). Fortress rates it for 30 minutes at 1200°F. Three 1-inch active bolts, two dead bolts and Fortress’s patented notch bolt hold the door, and external hinges let it swing open a full 180 degrees, so the whole inside is easy to reach. The gray interior converts between rifle racks and shelves. It opens with a combination, so there’s no keypad battery to die. Owners like its safety features.

The catch: the fire rating is Fortress’s own, with no lab named, and 1200°F is a cooler test than the 1400°F ratings above it. Listed gun counts rarely allow for scopes, so plan on fewer than 14. The listing says “combination lock” but never says dial, so check the photos. Only a few dozen owners have rated it, and they’re split on the quality. Fortress sells the same safe with an electronic lock as the 14EBF. It ships by freight, and someone has to be home.

Why we like it

✓ Five bolts, 180° door
✓ No batteries to fail
✓ Convertible interior

Watch out for

✗ 1200°F, a cooler fire test
✗ Owners split on quality
✗ Fire lab not named

Size

55 × 20.25 × 19 in

Lock

Combination

Inside

Not listed

Holds

14 guns, listed

Build

2 mm steel, 270 lb, 5 bolts

Skip it if you’d rather open a safe with your fingerprint and can live without a fire rating: see our best biometric gun safes.

Pick 5 of 9

Best fireproof pistol safe

Fire: 45 min at 1400°F

Holds: 4–8 handguns

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
45 min at 1400°F and 24 hr in 5 in of water, maker’s claims
Capacity
4.0
2.5 cu ft: 4–8 handguns, no long guns
Security
4.1
18-gauge steel, about 92 lb; 2 bolt-down holes
Value
4.7
Lowest-priced pick

Here’s the deal: a smaller fire-rated safe for handguns, papers and cash. It’s 25.98 × 16.53 × 14.96 inches and about 92 pounds of 18-gauge steel. XPEDITION says it protects contents for 45 minutes at 1400°F. It also says it keeps water out for 24 hours, up to 5 inches deep, with 3 sealing strips on the door. It opens with a keypad or backup keys, sounds an alarm after too many wrong codes and has a silent mode. An adjustable shelf and a gun pouch on the door organize 4–8 handguns, plus papers and cash. It arrives assembled, with 2 holes to bolt it to the floor or a wall.

The catch: the listing doesn’t say who tested the fire or water rating, and it isn’t UL certified. The keypad needs a 9V battery, which isn’t included. The listing gives the weight as 92 pounds in one place and 95 in another. The owner feedback is shared across XPEDITION’s safes, so there’s little on this one. If it’s mostly for papers, a safe with a lab-tested rating from our best fireproof safes is the safer buy.

Why we like it

✓ Fire and water claims in one safe
✓ Holds 4–8 handguns
✓ Lowest-priced pick

Watch out for

✗ Fire test lab not named
✗ 9V battery not included
✗ Little owner feedback

Size

25.98 × 16.53 × 14.96 in

Lock

Keypad (9V), backup keys

Inside

2.5 cu ft (listed)

Holds

4–8 handguns

Build

18-gauge steel, about 92 lb

Skip it if you need room for long guns: see pick 4.

Pick 6 of 9

Best for long fires

Fire: 2 hours at 1400°F

Holds: 39 guns, listed

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.7
2 hours at 1400°F, Hollon’s figure, no lab named; door seal made to keep out smoke and water
Capacity
4.6
Listed for 39 guns; 59 × 39 × 24 in, 22.5 cu ft
Security
4.7
10-gauge body, 1/4-in steel plate door, fourteen 1.5-in bolts, hard plate, relocker; 4 anchor holes
Value
3.8
Most expensive pick; no owner ratings; anchor hardware not included

Here’s the deal: the longest fire rating on this page, by a wide margin. Hollon rates the RG-39 for 2 hours at 1400°F, when no other pick claims more than 75 minutes. A door seal swells shut in heat, and Hollon says it’s made to keep out smoke and water. The body is 10-gauge solid steel, the thickest here, with a 1/4-inch steel plate across the whole door against pry bars. Fourteen 1.5-inch bolts lock on all four sides, and a hard plate and a spring-loaded relocker guard the lock. That lock is a mechanical dial, so there’s no battery to go flat. It’s 59 × 39 × 24 inches, listed for 39 guns and 22.5 cubic feet, with a pocket door organizer and 4 pre-drilled anchor holes.

The catch: it’s the most expensive pick, and no owners have rated it on Amazon yet. The fire figure is Hollon’s own; the listing doesn’t name a lab, and there’s no burglary rating. The listing doesn’t give the weight, so ask before you plan the move, and the anchor hardware isn’t included. The specs say it isn’t water resistant, so don’t count on the door seal in a flood. A dial is slower to open than a keypad. Owners of the long-gun safes here fit about half the listed count, so plan on about 20 with scopes.

Why we like it

✓ 2 hours at 1400°F
✓ 10-gauge body, plate-steel door
✓ Dial lock needs no batteries

Watch out for

✗ Most expensive pick, no owner ratings
✗ Weight not listed
✗ Anchor hardware not included

Size

59 × 39 × 24 in

Lock

Mechanical dial, relocker

Inside

22.5 cu ft, listed

Holds

39 guns, listed

Build

10-gauge steel, fourteen 1.5 in bolts

Skip it if you want a keypad and a lower price: see pick 1.

Pick 7 of 9

Best mid-size safe

Fire: 45 min at 1200°F

Holds: 26 long guns, listed

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
45 min at 1200°F, maker’s figure; cooler than 1400°F
Capacity
4.6
Listed for 26 long guns; 57.4 × 24.4 × 21.9 in inside
Security
4.7
12-gauge steel, 406 lb, ten 1-in bolts, 4.3 in door; pre-drilled floor holes
Value
4.1
Pricey for a 26-gun safe; very few owner ratings

Here’s the deal: heavy-safe steel in a body that still fits a closet wall. The GS5926 is 59.1 × 26 × 27 inches and 406 pounds, with 12-gauge steel, ten solid 1-inch bolts and a door 4.3 inches thick. TIGERKING gives it 45 minutes of fire protection at up to 1200°F. It’s listed for 26 long guns, and it’s one of the few listings that gives the real inside size: 57.4 × 24.4 × 21.9 inches. Four shelves, a U-shaped rifle rack and a notched panel come out or move, and the door organizer has 5 pistol pockets, 6 mag pouches and zip pouches. It opens with a code or an emergency key, the battery box sits outside, and a vibration alarm can be switched on. Pre-drilled holes in the floor take anchors.

The catch: 1200°F is a cooler test than the 1400°F most picks here quote, and the figure is TIGERKING’s own. Very few owners have rated it so far, and the warranty is 1 year. The 24 cubic feet in the specs is the outside size (59.1 × 26 × 27 ÷ 1,728); by the listed inside size it’s about 17.7. The specs say it isn’t water resistant. It’s pricey for its gun count: you’re paying for the steel and the bolts, not the fire time.

Why we like it

✓ 12-gauge steel, ten 1-in bolts
✓ Real inside size listed
✓ Pre-drilled floor holes

Watch out for

✗ 1200°F, a cooler fire test
✗ Very few owner ratings
✗ 1-year warranty

Size

59.1 × 26 × 27 in

Lock

Keypad, emergency key

Inside

57.4 × 24.4 × 21.9 in

Holds

26 long guns, listed

Build

12-gauge steel, 406 lb, ten bolts

Skip it if you want a 1400°F rating at a lower price: see pick 2.

Pick 8 of 9

Best waterproof

Fire: 75 min at 1400°F

Water: 7 days in 2 ft

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.6
75 min at 1400°F and 7 days in 2 ft of water, maker’s figures
Capacity
4.6
Listed for 24 long guns; 59 × 24 × 25 in, deep enough for scopes
Security
4.4
Ten 1.5 in steel bolts listed, CA DOJ approved; steel gauge and weight not listed
Value
4.1
Pricey; no owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: the strongest fire and water claims in one safe. Sports Afield rates it fireproof for 75 minutes at up to 1400°F and waterproof for 7 days in up to 2 feet of standing water, so it’s built for a basement that floods or the water from fire hoses. It’s 59 × 24 × 25 inches outside, so long barrels stand upright and there’s depth for scoped rifles. An electronic lock opens it, two override keys get you in if the keypad fails, and an LED light lights up the inside. The listing names ten 1.5-inch steel bolts, and it’s approved by the California DOJ as a gun safe.

The catch: it has no owner feedback on Amazon yet, and the listing is short: no weight, no steel thickness, no inside size and no word on holes to bolt it down, so ask the seller before it ships. The fire and water figures are Sports Afield’s own; the listing doesn’t name a test lab. And the 24-gun count is the label: with scopes, plan on about half.

Why we like it

✓ 75 min at 1400°F, 7 days in water
✓ 59 in tall, 25 in deep
✓ Override keys, LED light, CA DOJ

Watch out for

✗ No owner feedback yet
✗ Weight and steel not listed
✗ No bolt-down holes listed

Size

59 × 24 × 25 in

Lock

Electronic, 2 override keys

Inside

Not listed

Holds

24 long guns, listed

Build

Ten 1.5 in bolts, weight not listed

Skip it if you’d rather go on owner feedback: see pick 2.

Pick 9 of 9

Lowest-priced long-gun pick

Fire: 30 min at 1400°F

Holds: 24 guns, listed

SafesGeek score
4.4/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.3
30 min at 1400°F, maker’s figure; no water rating
Capacity
4.6
Listed for 24 guns; 26 in wide, 4 adjustable shelves and a gun rack
Security
4.1
282 or 307 lb, the listing gives both; electronic lock; no steel, bolt or bolt-down details
Value
4.6
Lowest-priced long-gun pick; no owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: the lowest-priced way into a fire-rated safe for long guns. SureLock rates it for 30 minutes at 1400°F. At 56 × 26 × 20 inches it’s wider than most picks here, and the gray felt interior has 4 adjustable shelves and an adjustable gun rack, so you can set it up for long guns, handguns or both. An electronic combination lock opens it.

The catch: its listing is the thinnest here. It gives the weight as 282 pounds in the text and 307 pounds in the specs, and says nothing about the steel, the bolts, a backup key or holes to bolt it down, so ask the seller before you count on it against a thief. There’s no owner feedback yet and no water rating. 30 minutes ties pick 4 for the shortest fire rating here, and it’s the maker’s own figure.

Why we like it

✓ 30 min at 1400°F
✓ 26 in wide
✓ 4 adjustable shelves, gun rack

Watch out for

✗ Weight listed two ways
✗ No steel or bolt details
✗ No owner feedback yet

Size

56 × 26 × 20 in

Lock

Electronic combination

Inside

Not listed

Holds

24 guns, listed

Build

282–307 lb, steel not listed

Skip it if you want listed steel, bolts and bolt-down holes: see pick 7.

PickFireHoldsSizeLockInsideBuildWater
Kodiak KBX5940
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
40 min at 1400°F25–40 rifles59 × 40 × 23 inUL-listed electronicAbout 23 in deep14-gauge steel, 457 lb, CA DOJ certified–
XPEDITION 24-gun
Best value for long guns
4.6/5
Check price
45 min at 1400°F12–16 guns55.5 × 23.5 × 20.7 inKeypad, backup keysUnder 15.7 cu ft (listed)Steel, 326 lb, outlet inside–
Stealth UL23
Best with a burglary rating
4.3/5
Check price
1 hour8–15 long guns59 × 24 × 18 inUL Type 1 high-security electronicAbout 12 in deep450 lb, UL RSC, CA DOJ approved–
Fortress 14CBF
Best 14-gun fireproof safe
3.5/5
Check price
30 min at 1200°F14 guns, listed55 × 20.25 × 19 inCombinationNot listed2 mm steel, 270 lb, 5 bolts–
XPEDITION 2.5 cu ft
Best fireproof pistol safe
4.7/5
Check price
45 min at 1400°F4–8 handguns25.98 × 16.53 × 14.96 inKeypad (9V), backup keys2.5 cu ft (listed)18-gauge steel, about 92 lb–
Hollon RG-39
Best for long fires
4.5/5
Check price
2 hours at 1400°F39 guns, listed59 × 39 × 24 inMechanical dial, relocker22.5 cu ft, listed10-gauge steel, fourteen 1.5 in bolts–
TIGERKING GS5926
Best mid-size safe
4.4/5
Check price
45 min at 1200°F26 long guns, listed59.1 × 26 × 27 inKeypad, emergency key57.4 × 24.4 × 21.9 in12-gauge steel, 406 lb, ten bolts–
Sports Afield Haven 5925HX
Best waterproof
4.4/5
Check price
75 min at 1400°F24 long guns, listed59 × 24 × 25 inElectronic, 2 override keysNot listedTen 1.5 in bolts, weight not listed7 days in 2 ft
SureLock 24-gun
Lowest-priced long-gun pick
4.4/5
Check price
30 min at 1400°F24 guns, listed56 × 26 × 20 inElectronic combinationNot listed282–307 lb, steel not listed–

Not sure which one fits you? Find yours in 30 seconds

A fireproof gun safe does two jobs: keep thieves out and keep heat out. Five questions decide which one you need.

A real rating names a time and a temperature, like 45 minutes at 1400°F. Most gun safe ratings come from the maker’s own test; a lab name is rare and worth more than the maker’s word. A fire bag in a gun cabinet isn’t a rating. Our guide are safes fireproof explains what the numbers mean.

Divide the gun count on the box by two. Scopes, slings and pistols on the door take room, and the depth decides whether a scoped rifle fits. Measure your longest and widest gun before you buy. For 30 or more long guns, see our best large gun safes.

Safes over 200 pounds come by freight on a pallet and are usually left at the curb. Plan the route, rent an appliance dolly and line up 2–3 helpers, or pay a local mover. Leave upstairs rooms to professionals.

UL’s Residential Security Container standard means a safe held off hand tools for 5 minutes. Only pick 3 has it. For lighter cabinets that keep kids out, see our best gun cabinets page.

Keep the inside dry

A sealed fire safe traps moisture, and moisture rusts guns. Use a dehumidifier rod or desiccant, and check it every few months. The outlets inside picks 1 and 2 can power a rod.

One last tip: bolt the safe to the floor as soon as it’s in place. A tall safe is top-heavy, and the open door shifts the safe’s weight forward.

Still not sure? Get the Kodiak KBX5940.
It claims 40 minutes at 1400°F, holds 25–40 rifles and has a UL-listed lock with a relocker. Owners praise its build.
Check price on Amazon →
Are fireproof gun safes really fireproof?

No safe is fireproof forever. A fire-rated safe keeps the inside cool enough for a set time, like 45 minutes at 1400°F. Many “fireproof” gun cabinets on Amazon only include a fire bag and have no rating at all.

What fire rating should a gun safe have?

Longer is better: 30 minutes is the minimum worth paying for, and 45 to 60 minutes gives more margin. Check whether the listing names who tested it.

Does a fireproof gun safe keep out water?

Not always. Only picks 2, 5 and 8 claim water resistance. Water from fire hoses can reach the inside of a safe that isn’t sealed. For papers that must survive water, see our best fireproof document safes.

How is a heavy gun safe delivered?

By freight on a pallet, usually to the curb or driveway. Someone has to be home. Have a dolly and 2–3 people ready, or hire a local mover.

Why does my 24-gun safe hold only 12 guns?

Gun counts assume thin rifles with no scopes, packed tight. Owners of the long-gun safes here say about half the number on the label is realistic.

Is a fireproof rifle safe different from a gun safe?

No. A fireproof rifle safe is a gun safe with long-gun racks, like picks 1 to 4 and 6 to 9. For tall cabinets and rifle safes without a fire rating, see our best rifle safes.

Find your fit

A fireproof gun safe keeps guns and papers locked up through a house fire for a tested number of minutes. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Guns and papers safe from fire
→ Fireproof gun safes (you're here)
Gun safes with a fire rating from a named lab, a door seal and room for long guns.
If you want
A smaller safe for papers
→ Fireproof safes
Smaller safes with a UL or Intertek fire rating, for papers and a handgun.
If you want
A burglary rating too
→ Gun safes
Thicker steel, and some carry a UL burglary rating with an hour of fire.
If you want
Room for a big collection
→ Large gun safes
Wider and taller safes for big collections.

How to choose a fireproof gun safe →

We looked at 234 products that came up on Amazon across 15 searches for “fireproof gun safe”, “fire resistant gun safe” and “fireproof rifle safe”. We kept gun safes with a stated fire rating: a time, and usually a temperature. We skipped gun cabinets that only include a fire bag, listings you can’t buy right now, and the same safe sold under a second brand name. Few of these safes have many owner ratings, because most are sold in stores, so we also used Amazon’s answers to owners’ questions. Then we checked each listing’s specs.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 234 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t test these safes ourselves. Fire ratings, sizes and features are as the sellers list them. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.