5 Best “5 Hour” Fireproof Safes: The Most Fire Protection You Can Buy

The short version

01
Best overall: Phoenix 505. 2 hours of fire, a 30-foot drop test and 4.56 cubic feet inside.
4.8/5Check price →
02
Best UL-rated: Master Lock STW205GYC. UL-rated for 2 hours, a day in water, and room for binders.
4.7/5Check price →
03
Best for burglary too: Hollon PM-2819C. A TL-15 burglary safe with 2 hours of fire, at 1,060 pounds.
4.7/5Check price →
04
Best for an office: Hollon HS-750E. 297 pounds, a 30-foot drop rating and a keypad for 4 users.
4.6/5Check price →
05
Best compact: Master Lock STW123DUB. UL-rated for 2 hours in a closet-size safe, at the lowest price here.
4.2/5Check price →
Why do the longest-rated fire safes score low on value?

These safes do one thing better than anything else you can buy: they keep papers below 350°F for 2 hours, twice the usual hour, and that’s the longest fire rating sold. No safe on Amazon is rated for 5 hours. Every pick here weighs 96 to 244 pounds per cubic foot inside, so they’re also very hard to carry off. The price of that protection is money and mass. Each extra hour of fire time means thicker insulation in the walls and door, so the safe costs more to build and ship, and far fewer people buy one, which leaves few owner reviews to go on. So every safe here scores 2.6 to 3.2 out of 5 on value, and the whole market is like this. Don’t need 2 hours, or that much safe? Choose by what you’re protecting:

Longest-rated fire safe (this page)
2-hour fire ✓Heavy steel ✓Low price ✗
The most fire time you can buy, and too heavy to carry off. The priciest fire safes sold, with few owner reviews to go on.
For a home closet: 2-hour home safe
2-hour fire ✓Smaller ✓
Five 2-hour safes from about 1 to 2.4 cubic feet, including a low-profile dial safe. Less room and less steel than the biggest safes here.
For less money: 1-hour fire safe
UL 1 hr ✓Price ✓
A lab-rated hour at 1700°F for a fraction of the price, with more owner feedback. Half the fire time.
For a few papers: fire chest
Carry ✓Price ✓
A UL-rated box for the deed and passports that you grab on the way out. Half an hour of fire, and easy to carry off.

Is there a 5-hour fireproof safe? →

Pick 1 of 5

Best overall

Fire: 2 hr · Class 350

Drop: 30 ft, then reheated

SafesGeek score
4.8/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.7
Class 350 for 2 hr, plus a 30-ft drop and an explosion test; no lab named
Capacity
5.0
4.56 cu ft, 30.7 in tall inside, 2 shelves and a drawer
Security
4.7
445 lb, steel bolt work, bolt-down kit
Value
2.6*
Very pricey; few owner ratings; free replacement after a fire

Here’s the deal: the most fire protection in one box. Phoenix rates it Class 350 for 2 hours, which means the inside stays below 350°F, and it adds two tests most home safes skip: a 30-foot drop onto rubble followed by more fire, which mimics a floor giving way, and an explosion test at 2000°F. Inside there’s 4.56 cubic feet, 30.7 inches tall, with 2 adjustable shelves and a drawer, so binders and file boxes stand up. At 445 pounds, with steel bolt work that keeps the door shut even if the hinges are cut off, and a bolt-down kit in the box, it’s very hard to carry off. If it’s ever in a fire, Phoenix replaces it free.

The catch: the listing names no lab, and it says the fire test ran at 1700°F, the one-hour mark on the standard test curve, while 2-hour ratings usually name 1850°F. CDs and USB drives get only 60 minutes. It’s very pricey, only a handful of owners have rated it, and its water claim is “water resistant” against hoses and sprinklers, with no hours or depth. At 445 pounds, plan the delivery and check your floor.

Why we like it

✓ Class 350 2 hr plus a 30-ft drop test
✓ 4.56 cu ft: binders stand up
✓ 445 lb, bolt-down kit included

Watch out for

✗ No testing lab named
✗ Drives get only 60 minutes
✗ Very pricey, few owner ratings

Outside

37.75 × 25.75 × 22 in

Inside

30.67 × 18.67 × 13.75 in

Weight

445 lb

Lock

Keypad, 4 to 16 digits

Water

Water-resistant; no hours

Skip it if you want a lab named on the fire rating: see pick 2.

“5 hours” isn’t sold, and “2 hours” needs a lab and the weight.

None of the 148 listings we checked claims more than 2 hours of fire, and only Master Lock’s say “UL Classified”. Three no-name safes claim 2 hours too, two of them “UL”, yet weigh 21 to 37 pounds per cubic foot inside; our picks weigh 96 to 244. Real fire hours are heavy, and a light “2-hour” safe isn’t one.

Pick 2 of 5

Best UL-rated

Fire: UL 2 hr · 1850°F

Water: 24 hr (5 in)

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
5.0
UL 2 hr at 1850°F; ETL 24 hr in 5 in of water
Capacity
4.7
2.0 cu ft, 19.6 in tall inside
Security
4.4
Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
2.9*
Pricey; little owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: the best-documented fire rating here. Master Lock has this safe UL Classified for 2 hours at 1850°F and ETL Verified to stay dry for 24 hours in 5 inches of water, which no Phoenix or Hollon here claims. Inside there’s 2 cubic feet, tall enough for binders standing up. Six 1-inch bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware hold the door, and at 192 pounds it passes our weight test with room to spare. It’s also the top pick on our best 2-hour fireproof safes.

The catch: it has less than half the room of pick 1, and it’s new enough that few owners have rated it, so there’s little feedback on how the keypad holds up. The listing doesn’t mention a backup key. Most of its weight is fire insulation, not armor steel: for a body built against burglars, see pick 3.

Why we like it

✓ UL 2 hr at 1850°F
✓ ETL: 24 hr in 5 in of water
✓ Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb

Watch out for

✗ Little owner feedback yet
✗ No backup key listed
✗ No burglary rating

Outside

23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in

Inside

19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in

Weight

192 lb

Lock

Keypad

Water

24 hr, 5 in

Skip it if you want more room or a drop test: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 5

Best for burglary too

Burglary: TL-15

Fire: 2 hr (Hollon’s rating)

SafesGeek score
4.7/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
2 hr, Hollon’s own rating; no lab or temperature listed
Capacity
4.7
4.35 cu ft listed; inside sizes not given
Security
5.0
TL-15 burglary rating, 1,060 lb steel body
Value
2.6*
Priciest pick; no owner ratings yet

Here’s the deal: a real burglary safe that also carries 2 hours of fire. TL-15 is a UL burglary rating: the door and front held off an expert with hand and power tools for 15 minutes in testing. Hollon adds its own 2-hour fire rating, and at 1,060 pounds, about 244 pounds per cubic foot inside, it’s the heaviest safe here by far. A dial combination lock opens it, so there are no batteries to die, and the listing gives 4.35 cubic feet inside. More safes rated against tools are on our best burglary rated safes.

The catch: the listing is almost bare. It has no bullets, no fire temperature or lab, no inside sizes and no word on anchoring, and no owner has rated it yet, so it may be out of date: check that it’s still sold before you plan around it, and ask the seller for the fire label. It’s the priciest pick by far, and at 1,060 pounds it needs a solid floor and a delivery crew. Its only water claim is “water resistant” in the specs.

Why we like it

✓ TL-15 burglary rating
✓ 1,060 lb: very hard to move
✓ Dial lock: no batteries

Watch out for

✗ No fire lab or temperature listed
✗ Priciest pick
✗ No owner ratings yet

Outside

33.5 × 24 × 22.5 in

Inside

4.35 cu ft; sizes not listed

Weight

1,060 lb

Lock

Dial combination

Water

Water-resistant; no hours

Skip it if fire is your only worry: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 5

Best for an office

Fire: 2 hr (Hollon’s rating)

Users: Up to 4 codes

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.4
2 hr fire and a 30-ft drop, Hollon’s own rating, no lab named
Capacity
4.7
2.43 cu ft, 21.25 in tall inside, shelf and locking drawer
Security
4.7
297 lb, 3-way chrome bolts, internal relocker, anchor bolt
Value
3.2*
Upper-priced; few owner reviews

Here’s the deal: the safe built for an office. Hollon rates it for 2 hours of fire and a 30-foot drop, the test that mimics a safe falling through a burning floor, and its S&G electronic keypad takes up to 4 user codes. At 297 pounds, with 3-way chrome bolts, an internal relocker that jams the bolts if the lock is attacked, a door that locks itself when it shuts, and an anchor bolt for a concrete floor, it’s very hard to pry open or carry off. Inside there’s 2.43 cubic feet, 21.25 inches tall, with an adjustable shelf and a key-locking drawer for petty cash or checks. More safes for a workplace are on our best office safes.

The catch: the fire rating is Hollon’s own; the listing names no lab and no temperature. It costs about twice pick 2, few owners have rated it, and its only water claim is “water resistant”, with no hours or depth. The listing disagrees with itself on the inside width (15.3 inches in the details, 21 in the specs). At 297 pounds, plan the delivery and check that your floor can take it.

Why we like it

✓ 2 hr fire plus a 30-ft drop
✓ 297 lb, relocker, anchor bolt
✓ Keypad for up to 4 users

Watch out for

✗ No testing lab named
✗ Upper-priced
✗ Few owner reviews so far

Outside

27 × 21 × 20.1 in

Inside

21.25 × 15.3 × 13 in

Weight

297 lb

Lock

S&G keypad

Water

Water-resistant; no hours

Skip it if you want a named lab on the fire rating: see pick 2.

Pick 5 of 5

Best compact

Fire: UL 2 hr · 1850°F

Water: 24 hr (5 in)

SafesGeek score
4.2/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
5.0
UL 2 hr at 1850°F; ETL 24 hr in 5 in of water
Capacity
3.5
1.23 cu ft by its inside size; the capacity line says 0.82
Security
4.1
Three 1-inch bolts, 128 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
3.2*
Pricey for its size; little owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: pick 2’s ratings in a safe that fits a closet floor, at the lowest price here. Master Lock has it UL Classified for 2 hours at 1850°F and ETL Verified for 24 hours in 5 inches of water. Three 1-inch bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware hold the door, and at 128 pounds, about 104 pounds per cubic foot inside, it passes our weight test.

The catch: the listing contradicts itself on room. The title says 1.23 cubic feet and the inside sizes (13.9 × 12.8 × 11.9 in) agree, but the capacity line says 0.82. The title calls the lock a combination dial while the specs say electronic. Master Lock sells a keypad version too (STW123GTCML), but its owners mostly say it won’t open, so we left it out. Prefer a dial? More dial safes are on our best combination safes.

Why we like it

✓ UL 2 hr at 1850°F
✓ ETL: 24 hr in 5 in of water
✓ Lowest-priced pick

Watch out for

✗ Listing disagrees on capacity
✗ Binders won’t stand up
✗ Little owner feedback yet

Outside

17.8 × 16.3 × 19.3 in

Inside

13.9 × 12.8 × 11.9 in

Weight

128 lb

Lock

Dial combination

Water

24 hr, 5 in

Skip it if you need room for binders standing up: see pick 2.

PickScoreProtectionCapacitySecurityValueBuy
Phoenix 505
Best overall
4.84.75.04.72.6*Check price
Master Lock STW205GYC
Best UL-rated
4.75.04.74.42.9*Check price
Hollon PM-2819C
Best for burglary too
4.74.44.75.02.6*Check price
Hollon HS-750E
Best for an office
4.64.44.74.73.2*Check price
Master Lock STW123DUB
Best compact
4.25.03.54.13.2*Check price

Not one you can buy for a home or office. We checked 148 listings, and the longest fire rating any of them claims is 2 hours. Here’s why, and what to look for instead.

Fire labs heat the safe in a furnace that follows a standard curve: about 1700°F after one hour and 1850°F after two. A safe for papers passes if the inside stays below 350°F, the point where paper chars, the whole time. That’s why 1-hour ratings say 1700°F and 2-hour ratings say 1850°F: it’s the same test, run longer.

Every extra hour needs more insulation in the walls and door, so the safe gets heavier, bigger and pricier with each one. Our 2-hour picks already weigh 96 to 244 pounds per cubic foot inside, against roughly 60 to 70 for the 1-hour safes we rate. Protection longer than that comes from fire-rated record rooms and vaults built into a building, not from a safe you order online. If a listing says 5 hours, ask which lab tested it.

Once a safe has 2 hours, look for four more things. A named lab (UL or Intertek ETL) with a time and a temperature. A drop test, where the hot safe falls 30 feet and is heated again, as if the floor gave way (picks 1 and 4). A water rating if hoses or a flood worry you (picks 2 and 5). And a burglary rating if theft worries you as much as fire (pick 3).

A real rating names a time, a temperature and a lab: “UL Classified, 2 hours at 1850°F”. Only the Master Locks (picks 2 and 5) say that. Phoenix gives the class and the hours (Class 350, 2 hours) but no lab, and Hollon gives its own 2-hour rating. That’s why pick 1 scores 4.7 on protection and the Hollons 4.4, not 5.

Divide the weight by the inside volume. Our picks come out at 96 to 244 lb per cubic foot. The “2-hour” safes we left out came out at 21 to 42, including two that say “UL”. A 2-hour safe two people can carry up the stairs isn’t fooling a fire. Weight has a cost too: check that your floor and stairs can take a 128 to 1,060 pound safe before you order.

A paper rating lets the inside reach temperatures that can ruin drives. Pick 1 is rated for 60 minutes for CDs, USB drives and memory sticks; the other picks give no media rating. Keep a backup somewhere else too. Read more in our guide: are safes fireproof.

A 1-hour rating covers a typical house fire with firefighters on the way. The second hour matters if you live far from a fire station, if the house could burn a long time before anyone puts it out, or if what’s inside can’t be replaced. Fine with an hour? Our best fireproof safes are UL-rated for 1 hour at a fraction of the cost, and our best large fireproof safes offer big 1-hour safes with more owner feedback.

Long guns need a gun safe, and most fire-rated gun safes list 30 minutes to an hour: see our best fireproof gun safes. Whole drawers of hanging files? See our best fireproof file cabinets.

One last tip: bolt it down. Picks 1, 2 and 5 come with a bolt-down kit and pick 4 with an anchor bolt; pick 3’s listing doesn’t say, though at 1,060 pounds it isn’t going anywhere fast. For a safe set into the floor itself, see our best floor safes.

Still not sure? Get the Phoenix 505.
2 hours of fire, a 30-foot drop test and room for binders standing up.
Check price on Amazon →
Is there a 5 hour fireproof safe?

Not on Amazon. We checked 148 listings, and the longest rating any of them claims is 2 hours. The 5 safes above are the most fire protection you can buy. If a listing claims more, ask which lab tested it.

What is the longest fire rating on a home safe?

Two hours. Master Lock’s 2-hour safes (picks 2 and 5) are UL Classified for 2 hours at 1850°F; Phoenix and Hollon give 2-hour ratings without naming a lab. For more home-size choices, see our best 2-hour fireproof safes.

Is a 2-hour safe worth it over a 1-hour safe?

If you live far from a fire station or keep papers you can’t replace, yes: it doubles the time the inside stays below 350°F. For most homes, a UL 1-hour safe is enough and costs far less.

Will these safes keep water out?

Picks 2 and 5 are ETL Verified for 24 hours in 5 inches of water. The Phoenix and the Hollons say “water resistant” at most, with no hours or depth. Need both? See our best fireproof waterproof safes.

Is a 2-hour fire safe burglar-proof?

Most aren’t: their weight is mostly fire insulation. Pick 3 is the exception, with a TL-15 burglary rating, and the other picks bolt down. For more safes rated against tools, see our best burglary rated safes.

What’s the cheapest safe with the longest rating?

Of our picks, pick 5, the Master Lock STW123DUB, and it’s UL Classified for 2 hours. The cheaper “2-hour” safes we checked failed our weight test.

We looked at 109 products that show up in 11 Amazon searches for a 5 hour fireproof safe, then added every safe from our other fireproof safe research that claims 90 minutes of fire or more: 148 listings in all. None claims more than 2 hours. We set aside gun safes and file cabinets (they have their own guides), a media safe built for backup tapes, and other sizes and locks of the same safe: Phoenix and Hollon make most of their designs in several sizes. Then we checked every fire claim: which lab, what time, what temperature, whether a drop test is listed, and whether the weight backs it up.

Every pick claims 2 hours of fire and passes our weight test. We left out “2-hour” safes that fail the weight test, including two that say “UL” and one that says “test approved” with no lab; a fire cabinet whose listed weight is far too low for its rating; and a keypad safe that owners mostly say won’t open.

How we score: each pick gets four scores out of 5, on the things buyers of this product care about most, and the overall score is the average of the four. A 5 is the best we’ve seen on that point in anything we review; a 2 means the pick does nothing for it. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 148 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points. One exception: when every pick is weak on the same stat, we still show that score, marked with *, but leave it out of the overall, because it can’t tell the picks apart.

We didn’t burn these safes ourselves. Where a lab is named, the lab did.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.