4 Best Fireproof Safes (With a Real Fire Rating)

The short version

01
Best overall: SentrySafe SFW205CWB. Twice the room, UL-rated for 1 hour, survives a 15-ft fall.
4.5/5Check price →
02
Best fire protection: Master Lock STW205GYC. UL-rated for 2 hours at 1850°F, twice the fire time of any other pick.
4.3/5Check price →
03
Most room inside: Amazon Basics 2.13 cu ft. Lab-tested for 1 hour, the most room here, keypad and key.
4.6/5Check price →
04
Best value: First Alert 2087F. A UL hour of fire and a water seal, at the lowest price here.
4.3/5Check price →

Pick 1 of 4

Best overall

Fire: UL 1 hr · 1700°F

Water: 24 hr

SafesGeek score
4.5/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.9
UL 1 hr at 1700°F; ETL 15-ft fall and 24 hr in water
Capacity
4.9
2.0 cu ft, 19.6 in tall inside, tray and drawer
Security
4.7
Six live-locking bolts, 125 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.4
Upper-priced; owners mostly call it good value

Here’s the deal: the fire safe with room for everything: deeds, passports, backup drives and a stack of cash, with 19.6 inches of height inside plus a tray and a drawer. SentrySafe has it UL Classified for an hour at 1700°F, ETL Verified to stay shut after a 15-foot fall during a fire, and ETL Verified to stay dry for 24 hours in 8 inches of water. Six live-locking bolts, a pry-resistant hinge bar and bolt-down hardware hold the door, and the preset dial needs no batteries. Owner feedback is shared with the smaller SFW123: owners mostly call it good value and secure.

The catch: dials take practice, and owners are split on opening it and on the build: some say the plastic handle feels flimsy. At 125 pounds, it needs two people and a spot where it can stay.

Why we like it

✓ Twice the room of pick 4
✓ UL 1 hr, 15-ft fall, 24 hr water
✓ Six bolts, no batteries

Watch out for

✗ Dial takes practice
✗ Plastic handle, owners say
✗ 125 lb: place it once

Outside

23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in

Inside

19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in

Weight

124.8 lb

Lock

Dial, preset

Water

24 hr, 8 in

Skip it if you don’t need 2 cubic feet: see pick 4.

“35 minutes at 1700°F”? Check the weight.

Real fire insulation is heavy. The rated safes on this page weigh roughly 60 to 70 lb for every cubic foot inside. The “35-minute” safes we checked, with no lab rating, weigh 7 to 18 lb per cubic foot. If a “fireproof” safe is light, it isn’t.

Pick 2 of 4

Best fire protection

Fire: UL 2 hr · 1850°F

Water: 24 hr (5 in)

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
5.0
UL 2 hr at 1850°F; ETL 24 hr in 5 in of water
Capacity
4.9
2.0 cu ft, 19.6 in tall inside
Security
4.7
Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.0
Pricey; little owner feedback yet

Here’s the deal: twice the fire time of any other pick. Master Lock has this safe UL Classified for 2 hours at 1850°F and ETL Verified to stay dry for 24 hours in 5 inches of water. It has the same outside size as pick 1 and the same 2 cubic feet inside, but it weighs 192 pounds, 67 more. Six 1-inch bolts and a pry-resistant hinge bar hold the door, a keypad opens it, and the bolt-down hardware fixes it to the floor. It’s also the top pick on our best 2-hour fireproof safes, with the same scores.

The catch: it costs well above pick 1, and it’s new enough that few owners have rated it, so there’s little feedback on how the keypad holds up. The listing doesn’t mention a backup key. At 192 pounds, check the floor and the stairs before it arrives.

Why we like it

✓ UL 2 hr at 1850°F
✓ ETL: 24 hr in 5 in of water
✓ Six 1-inch bolts, 192 lb

Watch out for

✗ Little owner feedback yet
✗ No backup key listed
✗ Pricey for a 2 cu ft safe

Outside

23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in

Inside

19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in

Weight

192 lb

Lock

Keypad

Water

24 hr, 5 in

Skip it if an hour of fire rating is enough for you: see pick 1.

Pick 3 of 4

Most room inside

Fire: 1 hr · 1700°F (Intertek)

Water: 24 hr

SafesGeek score
4.6/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.7
Intertek: 1 hr at 1700°F and 24 hr in water
Capacity
4.9
2.13 cu ft, shelf and drawer
Security
4.6
Six live-locking bolts, 136 lb, bolt-down kit
Value
4.3
Priciest pick

Here’s the deal: want a keypad and lots of room? This is the one we’d trust. The listing says Intertek, the independent lab behind the ETL mark, tested it for an hour at 1700°F and for 24 hours in 8 inches of water. It’s roomy (just over 2 cubic feet), with a removable shelf, a drawer and an interior light. Six live-locking bolts and bolt-down hardware are included, and at 136 pounds it passes our weight test easily. Owners mostly like the size and the construction.

The catch: it’s the priciest pick here, and many buyers report the keypad not opening after they set the code. Keep the backup key handy and test the code a few times before you fill the safe. Owners are more negative than positive on durability.

Why we like it

✓ Lab-tested: 1 hr at 1700°F
✓ Roomy: 2.13 cu ft
✓ Keypad, interior light

Watch out for

✗ Keypad can refuse to open
✗ Priciest pick
✗ Rating is from the listing only

Outside

24 × 20.9 × 19 in

Inside

2.13 cu ft

Weight

136 lb

Lock

Keypad + key

Water

24 hr, 8 in

Skip it if you want a UL Classified label: see pick 1.

Pick 4 of 4

Best value

Fire: UL 1 hr · 1700°F

Size: 0.94 cu ft

SafesGeek score
4.3/5
Check price on Amazon →
Protection
4.6
UL 1 hr at 1700°F; waterproof, hours not stated
Capacity
4.3
0.94 cu ft; letter papers lie flat, a shelf
Security
4.4
78 lb, bolt-down kit, combination plus key; owners split on the lock
Value
4.7
Low price for a UL-rated safe; owners rate the value highly

Here’s the deal: the lowest price here for a UL fire rating, in a safe small enough for a closet shelf or floor. First Alert has it UL Classified for an hour at 1700°F with the inside kept under 350°F. Its Ready-Seal door keeps water out when it’s submerged, and First Alert says the seal still works when you bolt the safe down. Inside there’s 0.94 cubic feet: letter papers lie flat on the floor, and an adjustable shelf splits the space. A combination dial and a key open it, and pry-resistant concealed hinges guard the door. It’s 16.5 × 14.5 × 19 inches and 78 pounds, with a bolt-down kit. Owners mostly say it works well, is solidly built and is good value. It’s also on our best combination safes.

The catch: it’s small, with no room for binders. Owners are more negative than positive on the lock, and some say it arrived damaged. The listing doesn’t say how long it stays dry or how deep.

Why we like it

✓ UL Classified: 1 hr at 1700°F
✓ Seal holds when bolted down
✓ Low price for a UL rating

Watch out for

✗ Lock complaints from some owners
✗ Water hours not stated
✗ No room for binders

Outside

16.5 × 14.5 × 19 in

Inside

0.94 cu ft, letter papers flat

Weight

78 lb

Lock

Combination dial + key

Water

Sealed; hours not stated

Skip it if you want room for binders: see pick 1.

PickFireWaterOutsideInsideWeightLockSize
SentrySafe SFW205CWB
Best overall
4.5/5
Check price
UL 1 hr · 1700°F24 hr23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in124.8 lbDial, preset–
Master Lock STW205GYC
Best fire protection
4.3/5
Check price
UL 2 hr · 1850°F24 hr (5 in)23.8 × 18.6 × 19.3 in19.6 × 14.8 × 11.9 in192 lbKeypad–
Amazon Basics 2.13 cu ft
Most room inside
4.6/5
Check price
1 hr · 1700°F (Intertek)24 hr24 × 20.9 × 19 in2.13 cu ft136 lbKeypad + key–
First Alert 2087F
Best value
4.3/5
Check price
UL 1 hr · 1700°FSealed; hours not stated16.5 × 14.5 × 19 in0.94 cu ft, letter papers flat78 lbCombination dial + key0.94 cu ft

A fire safe has one job: keep the inside below 350°F, the limit for paper, for as long as its rating says. Here’s how to check that it can.

A real rating reads like “UL Classified, 1 hour at 1700°F” or “ETL Verified”. If any of the three is missing, it’s the seller talking. On Amazon, the safes that name no lab often claim impressive numbers that nobody has checked, like “35 minutes at 1700°F”. Some only say “tested to the UL 72 standard” with no lab, or a “modified” UL 72 test at a lower temperature.

A 1-hour rating covers a typical house fire that firefighters reach in time. Fire pros say a home far from a station, a fire that takes the whole house, or a wildfire can outlast it: there, look for a 2-hour rating and keep copies elsewhere.

Fire insulation is heavy. Divide the weight by the inside volume. The rated safes on this page come out at roughly 60 to 70 lb per cubic foot. The “35-minute” safes we checked came out at 7 to 18. A 2.8-cubic-foot “fireproof” safe that weighs 30 pounds isn’t fooling a fire.

About 8 of the safes we checked are plain steel boxes sold as “fireproof” because a fireproof bag comes with them. The bag is the only fire protection. Inside a rated safe, a bag adds only a little time, and on its own it’s not a fire safe: see our best fireproof bags.

Firefighters’ hoses ruin papers the fire never reached, so look for a water rating too (24 hours on all our picks). A rating for paper lets the inside reach temperatures that can damage hard drives and USB sticks: keep a backup elsewhere. Read more in our guide: are safes fireproof.

Fire insulation holds moisture and the door seals airtight, so SentrySafe says to keep the drying packet in and open the safe every two weeks, or papers turn musty. After a fire, ask the fire crew to bring the safe out, then open it soon and dry everything: the insulation gives off steam, so the inside comes out damp.

Low down. Owners and fire pros say safes on the lowest floor fare best: heat rises, and a safe upstairs can fall through a burnt floor. Keep it away from piles of clothes or paper, and on concrete if you can. In a basement that floods, remember the water ratings here hold for 24 hours at 5 to 8 inches.

A fire safe opens from the front, bolts down and is too heavy to carry off. A fire chest opens from the top and you can grab it on the way out. If you only need to protect a stack of documents, a chest costs less. See our best fireproof document safes. Whole drawers of files? See our best fireproof file cabinets.

One last tip: keeping guns too? A fire-rated gun safe holds long guns: see our best fireproof gun safes. For a smaller safe with no fire rating, see our best small safes.

Still not sure? Get the SentrySafe SFW205CWB.
UL-rated for an hour, waterproof, battery-free, and room for everything.
Check price on Amazon →
Are fireproof safes really fireproof?

No safe is fireproof forever. A rated safe keeps the inside cool enough for paper for a stated time, in a fire at a stated temperature, like 1 hour at 1700°F. Compare the rating, not the word “fireproof”.

How long does a fireproof safe last in a fire?

As long as its rating says. Every safe on our list is rated for 1 hour. But many cheap “fireproof” safes claim 30 to 35 minutes with no lab behind the number.

Will a fireproof safe protect USB drives and hard drives?

Not reliably. A paper rating, like our picks’, keeps the inside below 350°F, but drives need a media rating (UL Class 125), which keeps it at or below 125°F. Keep a backup elsewhere, with at least one copy outside the house.

Should I bolt my fire safe down?

Usually, yes: two people can still carry off a 78-pound safe. On SentrySafe’s pick 1, bolting keeps the fire rating but ends the water rating, the maker says, while First Alert says pick 4’s seal still works when bolted down. The bolts go into the floor, never a wall. Use concrete or a floor joist. All four picks come with bolt-down hardware.

Is a fire safe also waterproof?

Only if it says so. Picks 1 and 3 are rated for 24 hours in 8 inches of water and pick 2 for 24 hours in 5 inches. Pick 4 is sealed against water, but its listing doesn’t say for how long.

Is a fireproof safe burglar-proof?

No. None of the safes we checked carries a burglary rating; most of their weight is fire insulation. Bolt it down and keep it out of sight, or for theft, see our best floor safes.

I forgot my safe’s code or combination. Is there a master code?

On SentrySafe keypads, yes: a five-digit factory code, printed on the back of the owner’s manual, always opens it. For a lost dial combination or key, SentrySafe asks for the model, the serial number and the lock’s reference number, and charges a fee. Register the safe and keep the manual somewhere else.

The batteries died and I have no key. How do I open my keypad safe?

On SentrySafe keypads, open the small silicone cap on the side of the lock, connect a 9-volt battery to the wire inside and enter your code, then fit fresh CR123 batteries. Three wrong codes lock the keypad for two minutes. On any keypad safe, keep the backup key outside the safe.

How do you open a SentrySafe dial safe?

Turn the dial right, past 0 three times, and stop at the first number. Turn left, pass the second number once and stop on it the second time. Turn right to the third number, then turn the handle. SentrySafe safes bought before 2012 start by turning left. Pick 4, a First Alert, also needs its key.

Is a bank safe deposit box better than a fire safe at home?

For originals you rarely need, often yes: the box sits in a vault built to resist fire, and locksmiths recommend it for birth and marriage certificates. Papers you use often belong in a rated safe at home, with copies of the rest kept in the bank box or the cloud.

Should ammo be stored in a fireproof safe?

No. SentrySafe’s manual says firearms, other weapons and combustible materials should not go in its fire safes, and heat makes ammunition unreliable. In a fire, rounds pop one at a time rather than exploding, but that can still wreck what’s stored beside them. For guns, see our best fireproof gun safes.

Will a fire safe survive a wildfire?

Not reliably. Our picks are rated for 1 hour at 1700°F, or 2 hours at 1850°F on pick 2, and a wildfire can burn longer and hotter than the house fires ratings are built for. Set the safe low, on concrete, and keep copies elsewhere. SentrySafe replaces a fire-damaged safe if you registered it within 30 days, but not what was inside, so insure the contents.

What should I keep in a fire safe?

Originals that are slow to replace: wills, deeds, insurance policies, birth certificates, passports and titles, with copies kept elsewhere. SentrySafe’s manual says to keep out firearms, combustibles and medication, and pearls and photo negatives, which are damaged well below 350°F. Drives need a media rating (see above).

Will money burn in a fireproof safe?

Not while the fire stays within the rating: a paper rating keeps the inside below 350°F, cooler than paper burns. A longer fire can still char it. Dry damp cash quickly, or it molds. Badly burned or soaked bills can go to the US Bureau of Engraving and Printing, which redeems damaged currency for free.

Find your fit

A fireproof safe gives you a real fire rating and a lock in one box. If you want something a little different, these pages have it.

If you want
Fire protection and a lock in one
→ Fireproof safes (you're here)
A real fire rating and locking bolts in a safe you bolt down and leave in place.
If you want
To grab it and go
→ Fire chests
A real fire rating in a light box you can carry out of the house, at a fraction of the price.
If you want
It hidden in the floor
→ Floor safes
Set into or bolted to a concrete floor: out of sight and built to stay put.

How to read a fire safe label →

We looked at 174 products that show up on Amazon in our searches for fireproof safes. We set aside fire chests (they have their own guide), bags, file cabinets, gun safes and safes that only come with a fireproof bag. Then we checked every remaining fire claim: which lab, what time, what temperature. We also read 30 owner discussions on Quora about fireproof safes for the questions buyers ask and the problems owners report.

Only safes with a fire rating from a named lab (UL or Intertek) at the full 1700°F for an hour made the list. We left out a keypad safe that owners mostly say won’t open, and ratings that name no lab or use a “modified” test.

How we score: the overall score follows what owners think of each product: it sits within a tenth of a point of its average buyer rating, and our four checks decide where in that range. The four scores out of 5 compare the picks with each other on the things buyers of this product care about most, so a lower one shows where a pick gives a little ground to the others, not a bad product. Every pick here already made it through our screen of 174 listings. If owners mostly dispute a stated feature, it earns no points.

We didn’t burn these safes ourselves. The labs did.

SafesGeek Review Team

We read the listings, the specs and the owner feedback so you don’t have to.